Second Wave Of TDKR Reviews Hit; Are They Still Positive?

Second Wave Of TDKR Reviews Hit; Are They Still Positive?

So far Christopher Nolan's final Bat-flick has received unanimous praise, but now the next wave of reviews - including a couple of high ranking Brit mags - have hit. Is the Nolan love-fest still in full swing?

Follow Mark "RorMachine":
By Mark "RorMachine" Cassidy - 7/16/2012
Well, yes actually! Although one reviewer does seem to have a few problems with the pacing, and points out a other issues too. But the general consensus so far seems to be that The Dark Knight Rises is a resounding success, and a worthy conclusion to a great trilogy. Anyway, read on for yourselves, there are no real SPOILERS to speak of, but as usual if you want to know as little as possible about the movie before seeing it, I'd skip this.
Here are snippets from the next wave of reviews.

We'll start with Empire, who give the movie 5 stars..

"..He raised the bar so high, no-one could be expected to clear it. Still, whether you believe this betters Begins or eclipses Knight, it is certainly a satisfying conclusion to what is now — we’re calling it — the best superhero series of all time.

As ever, Nolan’s Batman is at its best in the more intimate moments — whether it’s a man finally realising a hero’s identity, or the scene- (and jewellery-) stealing introduction of a new character. As slinky burglar Selina Kyle, Anne Hathaway is superb: physically dangerous, emotionally intriguing and sexy without milking it. (It’s a very different take from the Catwoman portrayed by Michelle Pfeiffer, but no less enjoyable.) As ambiguous as Kyle is, her journey shares with Wayne’s a sense of struggling for a fresh start, for a clean slate, ultimately for redemption.

With spectacle in abundance and sexiness in (supporting) parts, this is superhero filmmaking on an unprecedented scale. Rises may lack the surprise of Begins or the anarchy of Knight, but it makes up for that in pure emotion. A fitting epitaph for the hero Gotham deserves.




Total Film also award 5 stars, but actually manage a to sneak in a comparison between TDKR and Batman And Robin..

"Luckily for everyone, there aren't many points of comparison between The Dark Knight Rises and Batman & Robin. But Christopher Nolan's epic and Joel Schumacher's epic fail do share something: scenes where you truly feel the love between Bruce Wayne and his ever-faithful butler Alfred.

And yet, gruff, gritty and gothic though it is, TDKR may bring a lump to your throat that isn't popcorn-related. Its chief summer challenger Avengers Assemble may have bigger zingers, but this has one thing Whedon missed: emotional engagement; a genuine sense of jeopardy; deepening human drama. (OK, three things.)

Spider-Man 3, X-Men: The Last Stand, Blade: Trinity… third time's often the harm for superhero movies. Not on Nolan's watch. A smart, stirring spectacle that faces down impossible expectations to pull off a hugely satisfying end to business. Boy, you’re in for a show tonight…"


Hitfix say they expect a divided reaction once all of the reviews are out there, but also give a glowing review..

"We may never see superhero films quite like these again, and that's fine. Nolan had something special to say with his time in the trenches, and he's ended on his own terms. I suspect that the reaction to the film will be hotly divided, but I'm firmly on the side that this is a triumph, a victory for all involved, and one of the year's most impressive efforts so far in any genre, on any subject. "The Dark Knight Rises" confirms that these films have always had an endgame in mind, and it has been a remarkable ride, one I would not want to follow. Whoever Warner Bros hires to reboot the "Batman" films a few years from now, I wish you luck. The bar is as high as it could possibly be."


And finally Coming Soon , who have a few problems with the movie but ultimately give it an 8 out of 10..

"Trying to pile so many ideas into the first hour leads to an incredibly convoluted plot set-up that's all over the place as it introduces new characters like Joseph Gordon-Levitt's police officer, whose first meeting with Wayne seems as forced as his later romance with Marion Cotillard's Miranda Tate, something that comes from out of left field and may not have been necessary. It takes a long time for the existence and purposes of these characters to become clear, making the first half of the movie that much more frustrating.

The story isn't quite as solid as "The Dark Knight" and the main villains aren't quite as memorable, but having a director with such a strong vision and conviction to fulfill it makes Nolan's Batman finale pay off at least as a bookend to "Batman Begins" even if it may require quite a bit more patience than both previous films."


I'll be seeing the movie on Wednesday morning, so we'll have a review up later that day (hopefully). But for now, Bat-fans must be very happy with the reception. Do any of you guys who caught early screenings have anything to add?









Source: Various
DISCLAIMER: This article was submitted by a volunteer contributor who has agreed to our code of conduct. ComicBookMovie.com is protected from liability under "safe harbor" provisions and will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. For expeditious removal, contact us HERE.
9
LIKE!
424 Comments
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
jimmymcnulty - 7/16/2012, 4:31 AM
You know this is going to be the best trilogy ever right? Along with lotr. And this will be the best superhero film trilogy for a very long time. Maybe forever. How awesome is Nolan and Co. come on haters! Show some love!
Quasimodo - 7/16/2012, 4:53 AM
So it seems that it's better than begins but not as good as tdk
marcuskiner - 7/16/2012, 4:53 AM
"I don't talk fast, you just listen slow."

- A wise man

I think that sums up that persons complaints. Sure, we all have opinions, but maybe they'd understand if we slowed the movie down. This is Batman, not X-men or Fast Five.
GingerBird - 7/16/2012, 4:53 AM
I'm expecting the inevitable "backlash" if the reviews stay THIS positive.

But it'll still get TONS of Oscar noms.

:)
teabag - 7/16/2012, 4:55 AM
"Joel Schumacher's epic fail do share something: scenes where you truly feel the love between Bruce Wayne and his ever-faithful butler Alfre"

forgifs.com

lol id hardly say George Clooney smirking over Alfreds death bed made you feel the love :)
FireKnightRises - 7/16/2012, 4:58 AM
NOLAN IS THE MAN

IN NOLAN WE TRUST

and [frick] you girf
spiralblitze - 7/16/2012, 4:59 AM
i bet it ends with batman revealing his identity!!
inky - 7/16/2012, 5:00 AM
feed the ego drive lol its not that its a bad movie etc its the over the top hype with it its as if Dc and Warner have no faith in there product so are ramming it up every ones nose so they can gain support as for oscars if any they will be studio bought.
the more they hype it the less i feel it will be worth going to see, and in reality these movies of nolans are far removed from the comic book as to be no longer comic book just the names remain and that for batman is wrong as batman started the comic book movie thing way back with adam west and the greatest batman movie of all time rubber shark and funny bomb scene for the win.
teabag - 7/16/2012, 5:01 AM
I think alot of the rumours got it right with the ending....The division between Batman and Bruce's fate :)
FireKnightRises - 7/16/2012, 5:01 AM
are that means alfred will die? NOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!
CrimsonReign - 7/16/2012, 5:02 AM
@Quasimodo...however, there are lots of traditional comic fans who thought Begins was better than TDK. Therefore, I find it possible that about half of the opinions will think just the reverse: better than TDK but still not as good as the original (Begins). I tend not to judge a trilogy that way though. I will look at the works as a whole (although with LOTR, I like Return of the King and Fellowship more than I do Two Towers but it is really just splitting hairs in some sense).

CANNOT WAIT TO SEE BATS!
zware - 7/16/2012, 5:02 AM
Wait so the lowest review so far is 8/10. Hahaha... Where the haters at now??? I thought this movie was going to suck?
inky - 7/16/2012, 5:03 AM
OMG it ends with batman revealing his identity holly cow thats such a Marvel rip off and people think nolan is good please it looks like the guys a copy artist with delusions of greatness well he works for Dc Warner enough said lol
BlackFlash - 7/16/2012, 5:04 AM
"Rises may lack the surprise of Begins or the anarchy of Knight", things like this are not helping me at all with this film, I want more Begins and less Knight.

"I suspect that the reaction to the film will be hotly divided". Why?
Nubase - 7/16/2012, 5:04 AM
.He raised the bar so high, no-one could be expected to clear it. Still, whether you believe this betters Begins or eclipses Knight, it is certainly a satisfying conclusion to what is now — we’re calling it — the best superhero series of all time.

So there!
emilyella - 7/16/2012, 5:05 AM
Urgh so predictable
teabag - 7/16/2012, 5:05 AM
xNightwingx - 7/16/2012, 5:07 AM
Sorry @inky but you are WRONG
Beatnation - 7/16/2012, 5:07 AM
The Dark Knight Rises Rotten Tomatoes 100%:

http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/the_dark_knight_rises/
spiderpanda2012 - 7/16/2012, 5:08 AM
let's get on with this movie because when the Bat ends, the Spider rises hehehe...
teabag - 7/16/2012, 5:09 AM
Grif@ lol :P
R888 - 7/16/2012, 5:09 AM
With all these great reviews, the fights must have been improved, that makes me very happy.

antonio - 7/16/2012, 5:10 AM
Good stuff.
R888 - 7/16/2012, 5:10 AM
NeoBaggins - 7/16/2012, 5:11 AM

"we’re calling it — the best superhero series of all time."



antonio - 7/16/2012, 5:14 AM
Another review. This time from Press Telegram. 4/4
http://www.presstelegram.com/ci_21072970/nolans-dark-knight-rises-spectacular-filmmaking
Nubase - 7/16/2012, 5:14 AM
@R888

The fights have been improved, nolan hired a top martial artist for the scenes to make real and hardcore as possible, one reviewer said some of the fights between bane and batman was like watching a UFC fight and that one scene has no background music, just them sluggin it out for 20 mins.
inky - 7/16/2012, 5:14 AM
@xNightwingx im wrong just becouse i dont follow the brainless batman kiss ass mob who think nolan is great.
come on a comic book movie is that give me adamwests batman over all this special affects drug induced drivvel, comic book movie as in relation to the printed works so nolan has used the names wow he must be great shame his employers forgot to tell him its a comic book.
so im wrong to think howard the duck was a better movie than any crap pumped out by Dc Warner in recent years, no i tend to think about what the work is meant to be not what massive budgets and mad special affects give you.
Nubase - 7/16/2012, 5:15 AM
@patrickbateman47

really..and the movie is not even out yet, you sad little puppy, go back and watch your avengers then for the god know how many times.
teabag - 7/16/2012, 5:17 AM
The best Superhero series of all time im sure

but is this movie the best superhero movie of all time :)
Nubase - 7/16/2012, 5:17 AM
@patrickbateman47

your are right, in a few weeks we will see real critics reaction, l will come back to on that one and l won't be alone be assured on that
spiderpanda2012 - 7/16/2012, 5:18 AM
really why does he wear his Batman costume? it doesn't give that symbol of hope like Superman's costume brings...his costume reflects loneliness and despair...and he is wondering why Gotham is such a shitty place to be in hehehe...

He should have shown up using Adam west's costume to give Gotham the hero it needed hehehe...
antonio - 7/16/2012, 5:19 AM
Robbie Collin's full review will be published soon.
"Just out of The Dark Knight Rises. Can't quite believe Nolan's audacity. It's astounding - outstanding even - and as cold as polished steel.

The plot has a novelistic scope and it's every bit as much of an ensemble movie as Inception. Here Batman is a symbol more than a character.

Themes and imagery from BB and TDK are woven throughout, but Nolan's influences are bigger: Dickens, Eisenstein, Lang are all in there."
https://twitter.com/robbiereviews
zware - 7/16/2012, 5:20 AM
@patrickbatemen47

Your right... Empire, Variety, the Hollywood reporter, the Toronto sun.... Those aren't "real" critics.... Lmao
TheOneSuperMan - 7/16/2012, 5:20 AM
@ Tea I have visited this site for yrs and recently joined. I have to tell you that you are hilarious ! Thanks for all the laughs, and an ever bigger thanks for the beautiful women you've posted !!
teabag - 7/16/2012, 5:22 AM
Antonio@ " as cold as polished steel"

Damn so far thats the only thing thats been said that pissis me off :(
antonio - 7/16/2012, 5:22 AM
7/16 (Monday)
The Batmobile Documentary (CW)
Christian Bale (Today Show)
Morgan Freeman (The View)
Joseph Gordon-Levitt (Late Night With Jimmy Fallon)
Michael Caine (Late Show with David Letterman)
TDKR US PREMIERE - 6PM EST
spiderpanda2012 - 7/16/2012, 5:22 AM
Just1Superguy: Nah...Superman peaked with Christopher Reeves...the only way you can change that is to remove Christopher reeve's image in everyone's mind...Its the year of the Spider my friend...and be more afraid if you go piss Spider-man and make him join the freakin Avengers...KAboom...
Berger45 - 7/16/2012, 5:23 AM
Not many days left! Looking forward to this epicness of epicness! Also looking forward as hell to watching Man of Steel teaser trailer before my mind gets blown!

antonio - 7/16/2012, 5:24 AM
@Teabag
Here's one that is more powerful. From one of the two Indiewire reviews.

"If, as Badass Digest argues, “The Avengers” “defeated irony and cynicism,” then “The Dark Knight Rises” feels like the rock-bottom, lowest-point examination of ourselves which provides the substance to make Joss Whedon’s optimistic vision endure. Because Nolan’s film is a reminder that superheroes aren’t merely a frivolous distraction, or even a wish-fulfillment fantasy, but an embodiment of our best selves – or at least what we want our best selves to be. A cinematic, cultural and personal triumph, “The Dark Knight Rises” is emotionally inspiring, aesthetically significant and critically important for America itself – as a mirror of both sober reflection and resilient hope."
R888 - 7/16/2012, 5:24 AM
Man Im going to love that underground fight scene, no music just them beating the shit out each other, so much win.
R888 - 7/16/2012, 5:24 AM
@Berger45

Yes so true
teabag - 7/16/2012, 5:25 AM
TheOneSuperman@ daaaaaaw cheers bud..and welcome to CBM


Boobs 4 You..





:P
antonio - 7/16/2012, 5:26 AM
@Strange I'm not seeing him anywhere scheduled. He will be at the NYC world premiere tonight, though.
antonio - 7/16/2012, 5:27 AM
Rene Rodriguez gives it a very positive review.
http://www.bradenton.com/2012/07/16/4115659/the-dark-knight-rises-brings-batman.html
NeoBaggins - 7/16/2012, 5:28 AM
I'm pretty juiced for that Man of Steel trailer. I'm going to be at the theater so [frick]ing early.
teabag - 7/16/2012, 5:28 AM
Antonio@ On paper that sounds amazing..but it also sounds as if the movie's themes are calculated and empty to me...same with that cold comment...idk..im very happy with the comparison to BB being more of a focus then TDK in the reviews but as i have said before...i look for a lil heart ans soul in movies

still hoping this has that ...sounds like it will..but those two you just posted make me unsure :)
teabag - 7/16/2012, 5:29 AM
There's a starbucks coffee in that pic?? ;P
antonio - 7/16/2012, 5:31 AM
@Teabag all about context. :)
RorMachine - 7/16/2012, 5:34 AM
I just hope they screen the MOS trailer with the showing I see..Irish cinemas are notoriously miserable about things like that. We'll prob get Spider-Man and [frick]ing Ice Age 4 or something.

As for the reviews, I'm most happy to hear that Catwoman is successful..I wasn't really worried about Hathaway's performance, just how they interpreted the character. All sounds good so far..whip or not!
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

Please log in to post comments.

Don't have an account?
Please Register.

.