COMICS: Gail Simone Seemingly Forced Off BATGIRL

COMICS: Gail Simone Seemingly Forced Off BATGIRL

It seem those rumors of Simone leaving the title - unbeknownst to the writer herself at the time - turned out to be true. Simone has sent out a couple of Tweets that are sure to leave her legions of fans very disappointed. Read on for the details..

When rumors surfaced that Gail Simone might be calling it quits on DC's New 52 Batgirl title, the writer was quick to debunk them herself. But now it seems that Simone will be leaving the comic - but not willingly..


This refers to an incident in Green Lantern #54 in which Kyle Rayner returns home to find that his girlfriend, Alex DeWitt, had been killed by the villain Major Force and stuffed in a refrigerator. Read into the response what you will! Whether this is following on from those initial rumors or just an unfortunate coincidence is unknown, but one thing is for certain, Batgirl - and indeed comic fans in general - will not be pleased. DC's New 52 relaunch had its share of duds no doubt, but Simone's work on Batgirl was a real highlight, and sold pretty well too, so this is quite perplexing. Simone will most likely make issue #16 her last as the 'Death Of The Family' arc reaches its conclusion. No word yet on who DC have chosen to replace her.

Posted By:
Mark Cassidy
Member Since 11/9/2008
Filed Under "DC Comics" 12/9/2012 Source: Via
DISCLAIMER: is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and... [MORE]
1 2
DioFoRio - 12/9/2012, 1:22 PM
wow tactless.
DioFoRio - 12/9/2012, 1:23 PM
via email? Anyone reading the book think it's justified?
Jollem - 12/9/2012, 1:26 PM
that's like being dumped through text
Hellsing - 12/9/2012, 1:33 PM
Proof that DC is run by a bunch of [frick]ing idiots ( so is marvel to a certain extent). Some one please slap the editior and Dan Dido
Invictor - 12/9/2012, 1:41 PM
I've been reading Batgirl, it's a VERY great series
Invictor - 12/9/2012, 1:43 PM
I feel very sorry for her, she is a very talented writer
Invictor - 12/9/2012, 1:45 PM
This can't be happening!

@RorMachine, please tell me this is an alternate reality in which i'm having a nightmare, please tell me
hush - 12/9/2012, 1:50 PM
That's very disappointing to hear, Batgirl has been a highlight of the new 52 if you ask me. I was initially concerned due to Barbara being rebooted back into Batgirl, but the job was done brilliantly. This is a real shame.
MJPETTY7 - 12/9/2012, 1:54 PM
That sucks!!! The book was great!!!
Invictor - 12/9/2012, 1:54 PM
She actually has a past of good word such as writing Superman, Secret Six, and Birds of Prey.

DC Comics, what have you been smoking?
You obviously wanna smoke away all of your comic book sales if you're kicking a major part of the Bat Family Writer.
Snyder must defend her!
SwingsetKnight - 12/9/2012, 1:55 PM
What?! But...but that makes no...

Ann Nocenti, DC! ANN NOCENTI! That's who you were supposed to sack! Dammit, read my e-mails more carefully...
Invictor - 12/9/2012, 1:56 PM
and she also wrote Wonder Woman and Deadpool!
BubblesShedAndBreakfast - 12/9/2012, 1:57 PM
So is DC gonna start to stand for Douchy C*nts? Very unprofessional to drop a talented writer for no reason. If they did that to move her to a more high profile comic then I understand but to just email her and say you're off a book with no explanation is so immature and tasteless.
Invictor - 12/9/2012, 1:57 PM
@SwingsetKnight Gail Simone is "Ann-Nocent"

........ You saw what I did there?
DioFoRio - 12/9/2012, 2:00 PM
hopefully she takes this as a blessing and does some independent stuff.
Invictor - 12/9/2012, 2:01 PM

They had some good artwork back then, it's better than most of the artwork today, perhaps.
2gold - 12/9/2012, 2:03 PM
Gutless. That is straight up gutless. Didn't have the balls to bring her in and fire her in person. Didn't even have the guts to call her on the phone.
jimpinto24 - 12/9/2012, 2:04 PM
Gail Simone did a good job writing the Batgirl comics. It's to bad she is being forced out! :(
RorMachine - 12/9/2012, 2:16 PM
lmao Tea
Invictor - 12/9/2012, 2:17 PM
DC Comics.....Come closer please.....

You're gonna get an ass-whoopin!
Invictor - 12/9/2012, 2:27 PM
Just wait until next Comic-Con, Cunningham is gonna get it
paptschik - 12/9/2012, 2:29 PM
Well...maybe Batgirl will be decent now.
I like Simone, love her team books, but this is one of the comics by her that I absolutely hated (the other being her Wonder Woman which is weird given how good her work on the Wonder Woman movie was).
While DC is making plenty of, this barely can rank among them.
I mean, Simone's "LEGIONS OF FANS" tend to just barely keep her books above the point of cancellation and that's it. Sure, that doesn't speak for quality (especially given that Batgirl is probably her beststelling work, but at the same time far FAR from her best), but I'm just pointing out, that the level of fan love she gets is not nearly as large as the internet makes it out to be. It's just that some people online are rather vocal in how much they like her work. But the people that support her online because they like her or because she is a woman but don't buy her book...they don't mean much in the grand scheme of things. They don't help anyone. Sales matter. It's a sad fact, it's why Snyder is dominating DC these days (and he is one writer I'm not exactly a big fan of...then again, Marvel snatched most of the writers i's tough days to be a DC fan)
SCURVYDOG619 - 12/9/2012, 2:30 PM
So Starlin's going to write Batgirl...You know,because the timing of both Simone getting fired and Starlin 'taking over a title' seem related.....

If you believe in conspiracy theories,of course....
rbfn04 - 12/9/2012, 2:37 PM
Eventho I think it is a wrong idea to take Babs out of the wheelchair, Batgirl was one of the few really good reads of the New52.

Unfortunetly, a gutless move by DC by just emailing her. Grow some backbone and have a meeting. Or, at least, call.
CaptainAmerica1945 - 12/9/2012, 2:45 PM
Ahh the "New 52" way to drop good writers! Glad I am not reading any of DC's books, they don't deserve my money!

That being said, I may have to pick up Batgirl on Amazon.
paptschik - 12/9/2012, 2:48 PM
Honestly, do people think Batgirl can get any more offensive in terms of writing Babs? Simone's current version of Babs is weak, incapable, acts like a child and where Oracle fought the Joker, new Babs starts crying because she sees one of his goons. That's not exactly empowering. (and I still can't comprehend that the fantastic classic BOP Babs and this wreck are written by the same person!)
Battabing - 12/9/2012, 2:49 PM
I don't see a problem with firing by email. It's not like she and the editor live up the street from each other. Often times they're on opposite sides of the country.
A phone call would have been better, though.
If you can't reach her by phone then, yes, email.
It's still better than texting.
rbfn04 - 12/9/2012, 2:54 PM
paptschik well, this version of Babs is not over getting shot and beeing in a wheelchair. so, no, PTSD is not offensive.

@Battabing phone call. Common cortesy.
paptschik - 12/9/2012, 2:57 PM
There is PTSD and not getting over a storyline. And it's not just the Joker thing (even though the book barely seemed to feature anything else in it). Babs, as a whole, seemed so much more imature, which especially shows when she is next to Black Canary. Where it seemed like they were friends, equals, it now seems like...the obviously less mature little sister of Black Canary.
To me it just feels like a fantastic and strong character was changed into a weak character for a rather boring and pointless story.
ArtisticErotic - 12/9/2012, 2:58 PM
I wasn't reading Batgirl but seems like they lost another good writer, that's what? Like 7 now? I wonder how many people will be left when this is all said and done?

DC is slowly dying one writer and artist at a time. No one is going to want to work with them considering this track record, unless the big heads running the company are fired or something.

I don't mind updating costumes and a few other changes but the new 52 has done more bad than good. The older fans are pissed and don't even read from them anymore, the newer fans they've gained were mad because of the continued change of creative teams like every [frick]ing week.

Gail if I were you I'd go and create my own stuff at Vertigo or just leave DC altogether and go over to Image or something and just make your own original characters. follow in the footsteps of Robert Kirkman [frick] the BIG TWO they're not worth it these days.

BatSlam - 12/9/2012, 3:02 PM
maybe its batgirl that is going to die. her response to the question about not stuffing enough girls in refrigerators kind of points to it to if you look at it in the right light. Possible dc didn't tell all the writers who the death was going to be, or lied to them about who it was to make sure a leak didn't get out, and now babs is going to be killed, maybe this time with a monkey wrench instead of a crow bar ala jason todd.
rbfn04 - 12/9/2012, 3:02 PM
paptschik from what i could gather it was the first time she confronted the Joker after the shot. She seems to have been deaged. So, it makes sense she's not over it (beeing the first time she confronted the Joker) and not beeing equal to BC.

Now, her being younger, Canary not being younger. Is one of the many mistakes of this New 52 (still think she was a better character as oracle...)
rbfn04 - 12/9/2012, 3:03 PM
@TheNerdicon nah, I hate most of the stories being told.
asdalhjljh - 12/9/2012, 3:12 PM
I think this calls for a lawsuit.
FlashhGordon27 - 12/9/2012, 3:14 PM
I really enjoyed what she'd done with Batgirl, and couldn't wait to see her James Gordon Jr arc, maybe that's why she replied with "I don't know..." When I tweeted her asking how many issues the arc would be roughly? Maybe she saw this coming. Stupid movie by DC though, Batgirl was a fun read.
rbfn04 - 12/9/2012, 3:21 PM
Most? Other than Batman and GL I don't see how that can be possible
toco89 - 12/9/2012, 3:27 PM

On what basis?

There's no law as to what means to use in notifying a separation that I'm aware of. Unless there is some clause on a contract she might have signed or something.

FlixMentallo21 - 12/9/2012, 3:31 PM
DC's current management--made up of wimps and pansies since 2007
ScottScottScott - 12/9/2012, 3:57 PM
I am devastated by this news Gail Simone is by far my absolute fav writer. I hope Brian Cunningham ends up with permanent Erectile Dysfunction for this! By E-mail? What a Coward!!!
soaponapope - 12/9/2012, 4:16 PM
I like Gail Simone but she needs to get off of the refrigerator and female characters in comics thing. It may have been true a few decades ago, it's really kind of outlived its usefulness and is bordering on obnoxious.
1 2

Please log in to post comments.

Don't have an account?
Please Register.