The importance of the CW's "Arrow"

Why the CW's take on the Emerald Archer must succeed...

Here’s an interesting question: if the WB’s Smallville had not been based on an established superhero character like Clark Kent/Superman, would anyone have watched it? Would it have ever made it to ten seasons on the air? Imagine Tom Welling not playing a young Clark Kent but instead some original teenage character from space with superpowers. Does anyone honestly think it would have been anywhere near as successful?

Despite the fact that Smallville had a small yet loyal following and a large and sometimes loud group of haters, it did do one thing that cannot be denied: it continuously kept the DC Comics character of Superman in the collective consciousness of the public. Due to Smallville’s very “CW-ish” style of teen drama storytelling, the Superman mythos (however much adapted or diluted) were introduced to people who would never normally have any interest in comic book super heroics. Fans (usually female) of shows like FOX’s The O.C., the CW’s One Tree Hill, and the WB’s Dawson’s Creek were unusually drawn to a show about Superman, and the token singular action scene in every episode of Smallville helped to rope males and comic book fans in as well.

Now, the CW has introduced a similar concept in the form of their primetime action/drama Arrow, which has aired the first half of its first season to a generally positive critical response and favorable ratings. Like with Smallville, the CW has injected a fair level of “teen drama” into the Emerald Archer’s new adventures, but it has also learned from past mistakes and has maintained a generally high level of action and crime drama. I consider myself to be a fan of Arrow, but I’ve come across a fairly large amount of people who dislike the show for one reason or another, or have decided not to even give it a chance in fear that it’s just a Smallville clone. Thus, here is my message to any comic book fan: GIVE ARROW A CHANCE!

I will be the first to admit, it’s not the best show on television (AMC’s The Walking Dead takes that prize as far as I’m concerned), but it does have some cool entertainment to offer; even if sometimes it does feel a little like a Batman Begins rip-off. What’s great about Arrow is that, even though the showrunners have decided to include some typical teen drama tropes (love triangle between protagonist, his ex-flame, and his best friend), it has become clear throughout the first half of this season that arrow-shooting and crime fighting are the real stars of the show. What I find most interesting about Arrow is that it seems to be doing for the Green Arrow what Marvel’s Iron Man did for good old Shellhead (on an admittedly smaller scale). Many people (including myself) knew close to nothing about the character of the Green Arrow, but are starting to gain more interest in learning more due to the entertainment value of the show. Before Arrow debuted, I really felt like the Green Arrow did not need to be included in the Justice League film due to hit theaters in 2015, but now I’m thinking that he’s a necessity.

“Green Arrow is too similar to The Avengers’ Hawkeye.” “Mainstream moviegoers will see Green Arrow and immediately think of the Justice League film as an Avengers rip-off. “ I’ve heard the many reasons why so many people think Green Arrow should not be included in the cinematic Justice League roster, but I think I can easily see it being a hugely successful choice. First of all, I would make sure that there is absolutely no marketing displaying that the character appears in the film until after it has already premiered (this would keep the mainstream audience from drawing blind comparisons). Secondly, I would try to find some way of explaining his deserted island origin, as this is the most major of differences between Green Arrow and Hawkeye. Third, I would make sure to show that Green Arrow is not somewhat of an agent/assassin for hire (like Hawkeye’s relationship with Shield) but as a vigilante crime fighter who can do things on his own. After all, both characters have extensive histories in their respective source materials and are therefore vastly different characters. So why can’t general audiences discern one badass archer from another?

So, here is not only the biggest difference between Smallville and Arrow, but the biggest reason for Arrow’s importance: it’s giving some spotlight to a comic book character by actually presenting him in a context that is at once appealing to mainstream audiences, AND is faithful enough to its source material to please comic book fans. Arrow’s Oliver Queen doesn’t spend most of every episode pining for Laurel Lance like Clark Kent did with Lana Lang; he spends much more time not only beating up criminals, but ACTUALLY WEARING A COSTUME! Arrow is not the story of how Oliver Queen becomes the Green Arrow; it IS the story of the Green Arrow. So, what I urge to any potential viewer who is on the fence about Arrow is this: keep in mind that if the CW’s Arrow becomes even more of a hit, it will prompt the decision makers to possibly give another comic book character a chance on the small screen. Despite Arrow actually being a good show, watching it may provide a chance for a different live action superhero to make it to the small screen. If a show about the Green Arrow can achieve relatively high ratings (for the CW), imagine how much money a Batman show could reel in.

Which comic book character(s) would you like to see on the small screen? With the high price of good special effects, which characters would even be economically viable for a network to produce? Give your ideas in the comments section below!
Posted By:
Member Since 7/27/2012
Filed Under "Fan Fic" 12/29/2012
DISCLAIMER: This article was submitted by a volunteer contributor who has agreed to our code of conduct. is protected from liability under the Digital Millenium Copyright Act (DMCA) and "safe harbor" provisions. CBM will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please contact us for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. You may also learn more about our copyright and trademark policies HERE.
LEEE777 - 12/29/2012, 9:55 AM
Difference is tho, ARROW is a fantastic gritty show, not like that pile of SMALLVILLE crap (Seasons 8, 9 and 10)

Yeah, hope ARROW stays on the air a long time, it deserves it.

Only stupid ppl with think JUSTICE LEAGUE and characters are an AVENGERS rip off. I think most know DC comic characters (Batman/Superman/WW/etc) been around a lot longer for decades!

Yeah a BATMAN series would be awesome on the small screen, doubt WB let that happen, even though they should. After all if their gonna reboot, may as well leave it off the big screen a good 5 or 6 years at the very least... plus we got BATS in JLA!

Good read
LEEE777 - 12/29/2012, 9:56 AM
Man i miss the EDIT button lol


Oh yeah thumbs up!
shahrazstate - 12/29/2012, 10:22 AM
I have seen a few episodes and its a good show.
ManofSteel23 - 12/29/2012, 10:53 AM
I liked smallville,apart from season 8 and basicly the middle of season 10's filler episodes,but like zack synder said his kids watched it and it has been there so we AT LEAST have superman one way or the other on our screens,I think it did a good job in keeping it in everyones minds until man of steel comes out,and Arrow is a good show,but they have obviously taken ideas from the dark knight films,such as choosing not to have ANY super powers in the series and shit like that,but Ill keeping watching it,yet I dont see how green arrow can get around by just jumping on buildings and shit without some sort of transport like batman lol
Jlocklin - 12/29/2012, 10:55 AM
Arrow is growing on me. But the CW is really the wrong kind of network for this kind of show. I want to see a serious attempt at a superhero series from AMC, HBO or Showtime. Less pretty teen drama and more compelling takes on the best of the source material. Enhance overall quality by putting more money into less episodes. AMC made a zombie comic the best drama on TV and HBO has done a brilliant job adapting the epic Song of Ice and Fire. I think they should give the superhero genre a chance.
jazzman - 12/29/2012, 11:02 AM
i do have a major problem with Arrow tv series. is that he just killing too many people sometimes he aint any better than the criminals.
DrDoom - 12/29/2012, 11:25 AM
Green Arrow sucks.

Parker2017 - 12/29/2012, 12:46 PM
Arrow is pretty cool but for a tv show, I can see moonknight going the nolan/Arrow route. I'd LOVE to see a show on Daredevil.
aresww3 - 12/29/2012, 12:55 PM
The problem with Arrow is it is a Batman Begins clone, and your point that they will possibly introduce another show if its successful probably Wonder Woman but without powers has already put me off watching it. I did watch the first couple episode and to be honest found the acting so attroscious it was almost unwatchable.
marvel72 - 12/29/2012, 1:25 PM
lost interest in arrow after episode 5,its only just a little bit better than smallville.
jaysin420 - 12/29/2012, 4:25 PM
It's hysterical to me how people stick up for this terrible show and even compare it to Smallville, which lasted a freaking decade.

People forget that Smallville season one was fantastic and the next few were pretty strong too. It wasn't til around S4 when it started to go downhill, but that was 4 years in and Arrow hasn't gotten through one season yet!

I hate the no superpowers thing but I could get over that if the stories or the acting was great but it's not even close.

The acting is awful, say what you want about Welling but Smallville had Rosenbaum and Glover who were fantastic, among others.

I do agree with you about giving shows like these a chance cause it's like all we got, but I tried and I really really really hate it.
gmoney0505 - 12/29/2012, 9:21 PM
Arrow is a great show. People are just trying to hate it cause the show is not doing what they want to do and instead is doing what is expected to happen if a man is an actual vigilante that came back from being stranded on an island for years.

The show borrow some things from batman movie, but that is like 1% form the entire first half of the season. There are too many differences from this show than that movie to be a clone.

Arrow is a good show and I wish people would stop spreading false things about the show just because they want other people to hate it just like they do.
marvel72 - 12/30/2012, 6:11 AM
the walking dead is the only good tv show based on a comic book,its superior to arrow in every way.

darkjoker1 - 12/31/2012, 7:46 AM
i love Arrow this green arrow is better then that crappy version in Smallville -_- and it has a great story and great charaters in it and deathstroke and deadshot is AWESOME :D
dezdigi - 1/1/2013, 11:14 AM
I'm enjoying the show. Let's see how it evolves. Hopefully, the CW will let it be more of a superhero/vigilante show rather than their usual formula.
ndcruz46 - 1/2/2013, 10:37 AM
I really don't consider Arrow a teen drama. Both my sister and I enjoy it and we are both over 50! I did
watch Smallville from beginning to end and I thought it was well developed. Arrow begins its' story with adults
taking center stage, not teenagers as in Smallville. Oliver Queen is not from a distant planet but a human adult with all the brooding that comes with a secret life. For my sister to even watch this is a miracle, she
thought I was a little nuts for being hooked on Smallville. Oliver Queens' story not just centers around his life, but that of those around him and their secrets. I hope Arrow has a long and happy life! It certainly has peaked my interest.

Please log in to post comments.

Don't have an account?
Please Register.