Poll Question: SUPERMAN vs THOR


View Results

Please log in to vote.

Don't have an account?
Please Register.

134 Comments
1 2 3
scmittydude - 2/1/2012, 12:26 AM
hahaha that picture just looks like "and conan gave ME that voice?"
acidbath - 2/1/2012, 2:30 AM
Yeh superman is week to magic mjolnr would bust him up
Cheeze187 - 2/1/2012, 3:01 AM
The only reason I think Thor would win is because of the first encounter aspect. Superman is smart but he also is a boyscout, he tends to sandbag at first. His sandbagging vs a God wielding Mojo would probably take him quick.
MrE - 2/1/2012, 3:07 AM
I agree with you, Cheeze. Reason I picked Thor is the battle instinct. Supes is going to pull his punches until he knows he needs to let it fly. By that time, Thor has already smoked him. I don't think Thor could kill Superman, but definitely gives him something to think about for a few weeks.
Ginrocks - 2/1/2012, 3:16 AM
Sorry Supes, Thor is a God and your just an Alien.
MrCharles - 2/1/2012, 4:56 AM
Sup's weakness to magic doesn't mean that he doesn't have power anymore .... He's an alien but he has powers of a God too..
ClarkFarley2012 - 2/1/2012, 5:53 AM
Damn a tough one here. Both are my favorite characters. I think Thor wins because his power has more range than Supes. Thor's God Madness would do the trick.
SpideyQuad - 2/1/2012, 6:51 AM
Incredibly tough match to call. I reluctantly picked Superman, but I really love both characters. NDC really tends to amp up their characters powers. Marble Marvel on the other hand seems to set their characters with more modest restrictions. On one hand the dimensional powers of Thor's hammer could just whisk Superman away.
hehemata - 2/1/2012, 6:59 AM
picked superman cuz he has super speed

he'd be able to dodge thor's hits easily
esvelazquez73 - 2/1/2012, 7:01 AM
They've met before in crossovers... superman wins. Although it was a close one for me, I have to give it to Superman.
captainrogers - 2/1/2012, 7:10 AM
This is a tough one. They both have abilities that the other one does not have. They are comparable in strength. Superman being prone to Magic is what kinda swings this to Thor's favor for me.
But I truly believe you can just flip a coin to decide who wins this one.
hehemata - 2/1/2012, 7:14 AM
naw superman can dodge lightning

also there's no evidence as yet that thor's lightning is magical in nature. it's summoned by magic, but that does not make the lightning itself magical. superman can take normal lightning


superman's too imba. dc enjoys squeezing too many powers into single entities (martian manhunter, superman, wonder woman).

i maintain sueprman's ability to move at the speed of light and react respectively so takes the cake. he'd be just a blur around thor. they might be close in physical str/stamina , but supes would literally go in circles around thor

this is why i prefer marvel over dc. dc soups up its main heroes too badly and tries compensating by giving them ridiculous weaknesses.

comics? thor over supes anyday.

precisely because supes owns thor too easily.
LoudLon - 2/1/2012, 8:08 AM
It'd be a great fight that would likely result in breaking the planet in half, but I think Thor would ultimately win this -- and I think the deciding factor would be because Supes has been shown to tire once he's used up enough of the yellow sunlight his cells absorb, whereas Thor's endurance is pretty much limitless, not to mention that his abilities increase tenfold when he goes into his "warrior's rage" deal.

It'd be a great fight but sorry, Supes.
lukasbolander - 2/1/2012, 8:10 AM
Thor can teleport Superman to a dimension far away from our Yellow sun. Thor wins
MartianSupermanhunter22 - 2/1/2012, 9:58 AM
Lawl at the dumbshit god comments.......Darkseid is also a god in which Supes has defeated many times. Wasn't easy but he still did it which shows amazing determination and stamina. Also the magic comments Supes (not easily) can deafeat Captain Marvel, when his powers are strictly based on magic. And most other galaxies have yellow suns, so teleporting him wouldn't do shit really.

I love both characters dearly. Buuuuuut i go Superman all the way.
MartianSupermanhunter22 - 2/1/2012, 10:00 AM
And a pissed off Superman is one of the most feared things in the DCU. So saying a pissed Thor would defeat him easily is stupid.
deanwilkins - 2/1/2012, 11:09 AM
Thor would win this one. Asgardian magic anyone?
wavehunter - 2/1/2012, 1:45 PM
Have to give the slightest edge to Thor because of mjoln.
TheJoker52 - 2/1/2012, 2:31 PM
Thor wins he is a god Superman is just a alien . Thor would crush him then go off and have a drink . Thor wins stronger , magic , and the point if anything why dont he just take superman somewhere there isnt a yellow sun .
Corpse - 2/2/2012, 5:08 AM
Superman wins. I love Thor, and Thor is mighty but Superman is mightier.
thunderforce - 2/2/2012, 8:58 AM
Thor ftw .
gravedigger9906 - 2/2/2012, 4:22 PM
Superman because of the speed. Its the only thing that gives a definate edge. Strength, lightning, heat vision, wind all cancel each other out.
TheWitness - 2/8/2012, 6:50 PM
(1st Match)
SUPERMAN
216 Votes (48.21%)
THOR
232 Votes (51.79%)
Corpse - 2/14/2012, 1:35 AM
Superman takes this. He is faster and stronger. Magic can hurt him but if he is really angry, not even kryptonite or anything can keep him down. Sorry goldilocks!
SuperSomething616 - 2/14/2012, 2:47 AM
After Thor's power boost (yes I know he no longer has the odinforce but doesnt seem his powers have wavered because of this) and having Mjolnir...Thor would win with a big bolt of heavenly lightning!!!

He would do this while listening AC/DC Thunderstruck!!!
RGINLA - 2/14/2012, 7:34 AM
I love this debate even more than Superman vs. Hulk!!! Wizard first did this like 15 years ago and said that this battle would need to be held in it's own galaxy because neither men would give up. IMHO, Superman and Thor could fight to a virtual stand still. Even with Superman's greater ability, Thor's god based magic & Mjolnir would basically turn this into a super version of Mad Magazine's 'Spy Vs. Spy'!

Here is the KEY to the battle... Superman HAS fought 'gods' or those with godlike or god-based powers before, (Asmodel, Darkseid, Captain Marvel)... Thor has NEVER faced anyone on Superman's level, OH WAIT, yes he has. Thor has fought and lost to Gladiator, and I think we can all agree that Gladiator is a lessor version of Superman.

Next KEY... Mjolnir. Besides a Power Ring from Oa, Mjolnir may be the most powerful weapon in all of comics. With a swing of Mjolnir, Thor has leveled mountains, armies, and the Hulk. HOWEVER, with Thor's god level arrogance, he was battered by the Green Goliath when the oaf convinced Thor to fight him WITHOUT the use of Mjolnir. Hell, the Hulk has even beaten Thor with Mjolnir, and he isn't even worthy enough to weld it!

Last KEY... Superman's speed is unmatched by the Thunder God. Superman can turn Thor into the lightning strikes that Thor calls down much like he did against Captain Marvel. Superman has picked up and carried Mjolnir before, and could do so again. Superman doesn't even have to use Mjolnir against Thor, all he has to do is separate him from it. When this happens, and it would happen... Superman defeats Thor.
ACira - 2/14/2012, 9:55 AM
Superman's my favourite comic character, but I think Thor would just beat him. Especially if he's in control of the Odinforce. Without it, I think they're very evenly matched (As Thor said himself, the science of Asgard is the magic of Earth, more or less, and one of Superman's weaknesses is magic)

Although its also worth noting that Superman is probably just as worth of Mjolnir, if not moreso, so that gives him a huge boost power wise, as he could take the hammer from Thor and use it against him.

Even match, it all comes down to who gets lucky.
SkaarJones - 2/14/2012, 3:15 PM
Superman takes it every time. He KO'ed Thor and caught his hammer blow 1 handed in the crossover, and he continues to grow stronger everyday under a yellow sun. Mjolnir can hurt Superman, but Superman heals quick if he can even be made to bleed. He's faster, stronger, better reactions and senses, can freeze Thor, learns and calculates instantly and Thor was afraid of being hit by regular Hyperion's eyebeams. Superman usually dials them down to not kill, but he destroyed an army of Doomsday clones. Superman is not to be f***ked with.
upside - 2/19/2012, 2:35 PM
583 votes!? looks like the hackers are back. supes is a wuss. his powers would drain so fast from the fight. and i dont think thor is going to let him go fly by the sun every 20 minutes to regenerate.
RGINLA - 2/20/2012, 5:20 PM
@Upside... When have you even seen Superman's powers 'drain'??? Please educate me...
HulkbusterNYC - 3/2/2012, 12:06 AM
THOR!
thunderforce - 3/2/2012, 4:51 AM
I didn't see that before but it is with prep time and each knows the others strengths and weaknesses . Thor would win easily he can transmute matter and make cryptonite and teleport them away from a yellow sun and supes is toast .
upside - 3/2/2012, 8:28 AM
@rginla. Ok bad choice of words. Maybe not "drain" but weaken.

"Superman abilities will eventually weaken without replenishing his energy reserves with normal (yellow) sun radiation."

Thors magic and far superior fighting skills will wear Supes down.
whoboy62 - 3/2/2012, 9:33 AM
I want to give props for everyone being so reasonable in the rationales. I come to CBM less than I used to, because I am tired of the hate often dished out from one to another, usuall based on the preference of DC or Marvel.

I do want to disagree with hehemata about power levels. Marvel has it's share of ridiculous wielders of power.

You have the Silver Surfer who wields the power cosmic, the Hulk who supposedly has no limit to his strength depending on his anger and Wolverine who can be completely and utterly destroyed, but cannot die because of his healing factor. That is not the healing factor that I used to read in the classic Claremeont X-men Days.

DC has its share as well, just saying.
johnmarston - 3/2/2012, 10:26 AM
Didnt this fight happen not too long ago? and didnt thor win?
huh.....
thunderforce - 3/2/2012, 11:36 AM
This fight happened more than once and yes Thor won . Something seems fishy here .
thunderforce - 3/2/2012, 11:39 AM
I think someone gave Supes about a 300 vote lead right off the hop .
SUPERSHADOWBAT - 3/2/2012, 12:29 PM
Superman for the win. Please stop using this "he's. A God" thing, because in this context it means nothing. Primitive humans called those beings who had other worldly powers gods and worshipped them because they didn't understand that they were from another dimension or who knows even aliens! Superman has more weapons and if you think he hasn't learned fighting skills from Batman, Karate kid, Mongul, etc.. It eould be a long drawn out fight, but Supes with his speed and strength would win.
upside - 3/3/2012, 9:17 PM
Superman can lift entire mountains........ But Thor can lift the planet those mountains are on.
relentless1 - 5/31/2012, 12:16 AM
superman is in a class above thor as far as powers go, he alot stronger, faster and has freeze breath hurricane breath heat vision to counter any lightning or such things that thor might trow at him, face it marvelites, ur boy is out gunned here
Angelus - 5/31/2012, 2:33 AM
Superman has beat Thor before and will again. I like Thor but Superman is Superman. Magic is a weakness like kryptonite but he will surpass it. I even find it ridicoulus that Thor won over Shazam in the comic but done is done so I accept it.

And in what Marvel universe would Odin allow Thor to strike at Superman with mjølnir? If honor and valor is so important to the asgardians, I would not be suprised if Superman got to fight Thor without the hammer, which would turn out even worse for him.

@Upside - Superman raises that with blackholes and suns. And hitting through spacetime fabric. Blackholes have the masses of several suns all together so, yeah.
blahblahboy - 5/31/2012, 6:47 AM
Superman is one of those characters that when his competitor is offered prep time superman can be easily defeated, Thor would be know to get superman away from the sun, and for all we know Odin could have some kyponite lying around the weapons vault, or he could easily "summon up" some. And on the Flip side thor has no real weakness that Superman can act on other then his love for humans, but superman isn't the type to take hostages and such.
Thor takes this one but only because of the prep, without prep it would be close but supes would smack thor around in the end like the Superman vs Hulk fight.
deanwilkins - 5/31/2012, 7:25 AM
Of course Superman is winning. This is a popularity contest after all. Let's ignore the prep time in which Thor would get ample amounts of kryptonite. Let's forget that Thor has Asgardian magic powering him.
MartianSupermanhunter22 - 5/31/2012, 12:17 PM
deanwilkins- you are a dipshit if you think this is a popularity contest. How about you look at Supes win record then look at Thors. Supes is winning because he is superior to Thor. Just leave kryptonite out of it. You can hardly find it anymore in the DC universe. As far as the magic, being a rematch Supes will stay clear of his hammer. Easy win for the worlds greatest Superhero.
Gerrit - 5/31/2012, 1:28 PM
They are given prep time and while Thor has no weaknesses Supes has. Thor wins.
Magnus66 - 5/31/2012, 1:37 PM
Thor's battle experience and incredible array of powers both physical and magical would give him the edge to defeat Superman... although both combatants would suffer severe and substantial injury from this fight, and the damage to the surrounding area would cause earth shattering destruction.

In the end... Thor. Just barely, but still Thor.
MartianSupermanhunter22 - 5/31/2012, 3:48 PM
What the heck happened to Thor's numbers!!?? I suppose it takes a few hours for the votes to kick in?
andyrey2380 - 5/31/2012, 8:50 PM
Thor has far too many capabilities over Superman. I think Thor could win against Supes anytime but especially with prep. These two going at it would be epic but I give it to Thor 7 out of 10 times.
relentless1 - 5/31/2012, 11:09 PM
ugghhh...the marvelites have finally chimed in, why not use your brains instead of making this a popularity contest?? superman out =matches thor in every way possible, hell they have even matched up in the comincs and SUMPERMAN BEATS THOR, when even the writers come together from rival companies and they unanimously agree to give the nod to superman you all should respect that shit, lol even the cocks who you marvelites have your lips wrapped around give the nod to superman
oreilly - 6/1/2012, 7:21 PM
This poll has been HACKED!
1 2 3

Please log in to post comments.

Don't have an account?
Please Register.

.