Poll Question: ROGUE vs SUPERGIRL


View Results

Please log in to vote.

Don't have an account?
Please Register.

30 Comments
Rustyham - 2/29/2012, 12:43 PM
Kill rogue with eye lasers, done.
Ichaos - 5/23/2012, 12:45 AM
Or keep her at a distance with super breath. BUT the circumstances does say they are given prep time. Meaning she might absorb a power or two say like the Hulk and wolverine just a bit?
tylerox9 - 5/23/2012, 1:09 AM
Rouge already posses the powers of Ms. Marvel, meaning she can keep up toe to toe from the get go. And thens he can take Super Girls powers. Rogue easily.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4OU-6G-oIdQ

here is a similar situation that should show Rogues worthiness in this fight.
AmahlFarouk - 5/23/2012, 3:16 AM
First meeting, Rogue would win, but Supergirl takes it because she knows better than to touch skin-to-skin.

@Rustyham, you seriously think Supergirl would be so quick kill a fellow superhero?
uvsk420 - 5/23/2012, 4:46 AM
@tylerox9 these arent the comic versions they're the t.v or movie versions and rogue doesn't have the any of ms marvel's powers
BigCrupZilla - 5/23/2012, 5:40 AM
uh, I always thought they were the comic versions!

@amahl is right especially since this is a re-match
hehemata - 5/23/2012, 8:54 AM
rogue has ms marvel to begin with

she is pretty damn close to supergirl in power levels

then rogue can assimilate her powers too

rogue can outlast her purely because she's a leech

rogue takes this
weaponX2 - 5/23/2012, 9:34 AM
first of all, people need to read the rules for these matchups..the rules say you can use any version of the character and I would choose the comic version, which has the powers of Ms. Marvel. this version of Rogue is very evenly matched with Supergirl and should be able to get close enough to take Supergirl's powers and use them against her...Rogue wins
andyrey2380 - 5/23/2012, 11:41 AM
Weaponx2- agree with ur first point but i say supergirl can take this
Magnus66 - 5/23/2012, 1:38 PM
Interesting. Can Rogue's mutant powers work on a Kryptonian? They are not human after all.

If so, Rogue edges this one out IF she can make and maintain contact long enough.

If not, then even with the pre-absorbed powers of Ms Marvel, this would be one hell of a fight... but I would give it to Supergirl for the win.
AnungUnRama - 5/24/2012, 3:42 PM
First encounter: Supergirl would hit Rogue in with an incredible speed right in her face. IF Rogue would keep consciousness then Supergirl would recognize that Rogue absorbed a part of her powers when she touched her for some nano seconds. So she would make sure not to touch her again: Supergirl takes out Rogue with her heat vision across a great distance (or maybe with her cold breath). Fight over.
AnungUnRama - 5/24/2012, 3:52 PM
Well sorry I just recognized that this is a rematch so the fighters know each other. This makes the fight even shorter. Supergirl would never ever let Rogue get even close to her - which is not quite difficult since Supergirl is much faster. So Supergirl would take out Rogue with her heat vision in the nano second she recognizes her -> Fight over - no contest.
billnye69 - 9/3/2012, 5:45 AM
Anyone who thinks Ms Marvel is as strong as any of the Kryptonians under a yellow sun is crazy and shouldn't vote due to mental instability.
Godzillafart - 9/3/2012, 5:46 AM
Kryptonians are notorious wussies.
AlSimmons - 9/3/2012, 6:10 AM
Whatever happens we dudes win. *wink wink*
SpideyQuad - 9/3/2012, 7:06 AM
Ms. marvels original strength levels (when Rogue absorbed her powers) were not a fraction of a super girls. Anyone who thinks she can go toe to toe with her doesn't understand either character.

Binary's powers levels might be a different matter, but that's not rogues power set.
inky - 9/3/2012, 7:09 AM
depends on if rogue still has full abilities od ms marvel if so super girl is toast sad to say it but if rogue just a blank template then super girl wins hands down, so i tend towards ms marvel powers :)
upside - 9/3/2012, 7:24 AM
@ jwsmith85

the rules state voting is based on "the most iconic version" of each character. So rogue has her powers. But still out matched. Only chance is to touch supergirl and knock her out.
andyrey2380 - 9/3/2012, 8:28 AM
@jwsmith, what upside said. And my vote goes to supergirl.
Clundgren - 9/3/2012, 8:37 AM
This fight comes down to Rogue trying desperately to touch Supergirl's skin. I think we can all agree that this is a battle we'd like to see.
SwingsetKnight - 9/3/2012, 8:55 AM
The powers Rogue absorbed from Ms. Marvel make her very strong and fast, granted. Doesn't mean shit, as she's nowhere near strong and fast enough to deal with a Kryptonian. Rogue has 50 tons and can break the speed of sound in flight. Whoop-dee-[frick]ing-doo. Supergirl can fly at light speed and fight at Mach 10 (i.e. faster than Rogue's human brain has even a chance of processing, allowing her to pound every clothed inch of her into a bloody pulp without fear of a power drain). She's strong enough, acc. to Supes, to crack the planet in two, so in fact there'd be every possibility that the fight would take just one punch.
hehemata - 9/3/2012, 9:24 AM
the fight comes down to rogue stripping down to her birthday suit


every hit supergirl makes will strengthen rogue, and she wouldn't even realise until rogue eventually catches up with her recovery of ms marvel and supergirl combined, whilst supergirl has lost that much
Ship - 9/3/2012, 10:37 AM
One word, Parasite, if superman can beat parasite, which basically have the same Rogues Powers, so I think Supergirl can take Rogue.
SkaarJones - 9/3/2012, 11:35 AM
Parasite is more powerful than Rogue. Rogue had trouble absorbing Ares. Supergirl would be too much for her.
SkaarJones - 9/3/2012, 11:36 AM
Rogue doesn't have Ms. Marvel absorbed in her anymore either.
Magnus66 - 9/3/2012, 12:56 PM
Still Supergirl.
SwingsetKnight - 9/3/2012, 2:21 PM
@ hehemata: LOL. By the same token (prep time), though, Kara can just put on a pair of gloves and a balaclava, and Rogue's still doomed.
relentless1 - 7/28/2013, 2:40 AM
rogue wins due to her absorption powers

Please log in to post comments.

Don't have an account?
Please Register.