William Shatner said what about Star Wars?

The age old geek debate continues! Star Trek or Star Wars which is the winner?

Follow Spock:
By Spock - 9/21/2011
William Shatner (Capt. Kirk) is well known to be a ladies man and the flagship actor for Star Trek. On a recent video interview Shatner was quoted: "Star Trek dealt with human relationships, Star Wars was special effects....was at its best." In effect admitting Star Trek is BETTER than Star Wars!

While I agree with somewhat he says in this interview not everything, I will have to point out that Star Trek came on the air in 1966. During the U.S.'s Civil Rights & Vietnam War era. Thou it was first doesn't mean it's the best!

Gene Roddenberry creator of Star Trek was way ahead of his time being a VISIONARY of what "WE" could be. Star Trek dealt with real issues of the times, amongest other social issues & continues to do so.

Note to Lucas what the Hell are you waiting on. Gives us a Star Wars TV Series already, the technology is here now!






One of my favorite episodes-- The Measure of a Man

Which centers on the android crewmember Data. This one calls into question the very nature of Data’s being, as well as his right to choose. Is he a man, or is he a machine? About human rights and “disposable people.”


P.S. Iam a fan of both but I would pick Star Trek over Star Wars anyday! Let your voice be heard in the usually place!
LIVE LONG & PROSPER!
DISCLAIMER: This article was submitted by a volunteer contributor who has agreed to our code of conduct. ComicBookMovie.com is protected from liability under the Digital Millenium Copyright Act (DMCA) and "safe harbor" provisions. CBM will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please contact us for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. You may also learn more about our copyright and trademark policies HERE.
1
LIKE!
18 Comments
m1312020 - 9/21/2011, 12:57 AM
I pick Highlander for my cult show normal people laugh at me for enjoying.
Valar1 - 9/21/2011, 1:07 AM
star wars is pablum
m1312020 - 9/21/2011, 1:18 AM
@demonhunter15 Agree.The director's cut of the 2nd one
helps a little,but not by much.The rest not worth mentioning.
m1312020 - 9/21/2011, 1:39 AM
@demonhunter15 Sadly it was canceled last year.I was
looking forward to it also.
Boekelaar - 9/21/2011, 2:16 AM
Star Wars all the way, I love Abrams Trek however. But I don't hate Star Trek or anything, I think it's harder to compare with one mostly being television and the other being pretty much solely movies. But the SW movies are better than the ST movies but the ST shows are probably better than most SW shows. But yeah I've always felt it's an unfair comparison, can't they both just be considered awesome? :)
Dmon - 9/21/2011, 2:49 AM
Star Trek all the way.
Coloso - 9/21/2011, 4:08 AM
Star Trek, live long and prosper!

10. Darth Vader has only one sphere, the Death Star. The Borg have thousands upon thousands of spheres AND cubes. (Geometric shapes seem to be a favorite among villans...)
9. Those light sabers are kinda primative compared to phasers. Why have a sword when you can have a gun?
8. Star Trek has four series (soon to be five) and a lot more movies.
7. The Federation vs. The Force. Skywalker wouldn't have a chance!
6. Star Trek's technology is much more advanced. What's so bad about transporters saving you life, anyway?
5. The graphics in Voyager alone are just as good as those in the re-made version of Star Wars.
4. Chakotay doesn't fall in love with Janeway and find out she's his sister.
3. People on Star Wars are mostly planet-ridden. Doesn't seem like there have been any ships lost for seven years to make it back home against all odds, no space stations that survive through constant battles, or anything else like that.
2. There is more than one way to get around...from star ships to shuttles to transporters...from warp to transwarp to slip stream...

And the Number One Reason Why Star Trek is Better Than Star Wars:

The Borg Queen isn't Kathryn Janeway's mother.
Coloso - 9/21/2011, 4:14 AM
1.. Just how many Star Trek films have been made?
2.. None of Star Trek's leading characters have an interminable breathing
obstruction
3.. Star Trek doesn't have to resort to using petty telekinetic forces to
make some action
4.. Star Wars creators obviously can't count as they made 4, 5, and 6
first!?
5.. Strangely enough, all the leading ships in Star Wars are totally
invincible to enemy fire
6.. Star Wars storyline is either so difficult to understand, or so badly
written, that they need to tell us it by scrolling it on the screen before
the film starts
7.. Isn't there some slight similarity between the 'photon' and 'proton'
torpedoes?
8.. And which was created first?
9.. Which sound better: a 'hyperdrive motivator' or a 'warp core'?
Exactly.
10.. Star Trek doesn't have some stupid hairy monster out of Bigfoot and
the Hendersons
11.. One word: Q.
12.. DS9's Dabo girls vs. no women at Tatooine's spaceport bar.
13.. Data would kick C3P0's metal ass.
14.. The new special effects on the trilogy don't even come close to the
effects on the DS9 episode, Sacrifise of Angels

;P
Coloso - 9/21/2011, 4:16 AM

RunDTC - 9/21/2011, 6:18 AM
Star Wars, forever and always. I was raised on Star Wars and it helped shape me as a person. but I do love the new Star Trek film, the one with Chris Pine and Zachary Quinto, and consider it quite supperior to all the SW prequels and Return of the Jedi.
ManofSteel23 - 9/21/2011, 6:20 AM
They should make a star wars tv series that bridges the gap between 3 and 4,maybe the force unleashed tv series? since the guy who did star killer is davis from smallville
lalosuper3001 - 9/21/2011, 7:36 AM
Yeeeaaaah! DOCTOR WHO WINS!!!!
Star Trek a close second, followed by Star Wars and Scientology...
Chewtoy - 9/21/2011, 9:11 AM
They're such apples and oranges that I'd have a hard time saying which was better. For pure entertainment nothing Star Trek did can touch the original Star Wars trilogy... but for actual, meaty stories then the best episodes of the various Treks have a lot more going for them. Of course, you have to look past all of the bad episodes...

Gerrit - 9/21/2011, 1:01 PM
I hate when people talk about Star Trek vs Star Wars as if it was a debate about a "real" between them, comparing technology and all that stuff. It's just a matter of opinion, people.
Gerrit - 9/21/2011, 1:02 PM
Damn, "real" fight
Bodwulf - 9/22/2011, 10:59 PM
Princess Leia,Captain James T. Kirk
KNIGHT3000 - 9/23/2011, 7:47 AM
No disrespect to TREK fans, but, when I was growing up watching STAR TREK was like watching 2 kids play BATTLE SHIP. Not so much fun. What really drew me in to STAR WARS was the use of LightSabers, and the many Sword fights as the saga progressed. My least favorite is Episode 4 because it had the least amount of Swordplay.
magaunac - 9/26/2011, 9:51 AM
Personally, I've always been a fan of Star Trek. I also loved the original trilogy of Star Wars. The thing that seperates them most to me now though are their creators. Right up to the end, Roddenberry wanted to show some of the best of what humanity could become and be capable of. Lucas has progressed from, in the beginning, wanting to tell an epic story, to now just wanting more money. He isn't going to quit until he's ran his creation into the ground. Star Wars went from the great sci-fi story to being hocked as various cartoons for little kids. Star Trek went from a single tv series to 5 tv series and 11 movies. There have been great parts as well as bitter disappointments, but it still thrives. In the end, my opinion is that Trek will outlast wars because it's being passed on to new people, changes are being made...sometimes for the better, sometimes for the worse. Star Wars is being greedily held on to by the same person that created it, and is trying to squeeze every last penny he can out of it. I mean no disrespect to anyone by this comment, but to me, those die hard lucas fans are almost the same as being in an abusive relationship. They take a slap in the face like Jar Jar Binks, but it's ok because Lucas didn't mean it.

Please log in to post comments.

Don't have an account?
Please Register.