ComicBookMovie.com Start A Fansite!
You are not currently logged in. Login

I think Captain America should be...

Just read the article!!!
Okay sports fans, I've thought about this a lot over the past few years, as have a lot of you. It's hard to pick somebody who fits the bill. While you don't want someone who is a pretty boy, you don't want someone who looks like he just killed a grizzly bear with his own hands. While you don't want a complete unknown necessarily, you don't want someone whose Hollywood persona is going to clot the character they're portraying. Whenver I see something with this actor, I always find myself wondering "Why hasn't this guy become an A-Lister yet?"

See, I'm not going to come right out and say his name, or plaster his face all over this article, because then people see who he is and make a snap judgement, and I would have to reason them BACK to an open mind, but if you read what I have to say first, perhaps you'll be in a better place to accept him. So let's go:

For starters, this actor is only 31, which is ideal as Cap will most likely be featured in 3-4 movies and that will be over an 8 year span or so. The younger the better, but still you don't want someone too young. You want someone that looks like they might be a soldier. THIS actor has actually PLAYED a soldier...TWICE!! One of those films featured him as a WWII vet!

Next there's the issue of screen presence. What made me really take notice of this actor was his subtlety. Typically he plays more reserved characters on screen, as opposed to hyper-kenetic freaks. In the second movie in which he played a soldier he was a great leader. He was all about his troops, but he was no puss either.

Next there is the physical appearance. He's not blonde hair and blue eyes, but if you're THAT narrow minded you wont be made happy anyway. However he is in good shape, a bit slim but I'm sure a trainer could fix that, and he's 6'2".

So as far as presentation, how would Cap be? Okay this is how I like to look at it. I'm a practicing Catholic, and proud of it. I don't push it on people, but if the opportunity is there to show my pride, I take it. I would have Cap act the same way, and show anger at any disrespect shown to the States. This part will be harder to nail, as it seemed like until Obama was made president, there was VERY LITTLE pride in America. Then there was this flashing moment where people were proud, but when they saw Obama didn't have the Midas Touch, it began to fade again. My biggest concern is that they try to water down the patriotism in some way. That would be unforgivable.

Finally, the last thing that made me think this candidate would be outstanding was his performance in a 2007 action/horror CBM about a rural policeman facing an impossible enemy. While never becoming a ruthless killing machine (a la Rambo) he quietly lead his charge to safety, defeating the enemy and ultimately giving his life for his friends.

Still haven't figured it out? Then go on this link, hopefully after everything I said you'll appreciate the idea has much as me:

http://stores.usedbooksandothers.com/catalog/Black%20Hawk%20Down.jpg
1 Yes
1 No
TheDurkinKnight
11/20/2009

DISCLAIMER: This posting was submitted by a user of the site not from Comic Book Movie editorial staff. All users have acknowledged and agreed that the submission of their content is in compliance with our Terms of Use. For removal of copyrighted material, please contact us HERE.

42 Comments

Comicbookmovie...why did you put this in fan fic? It's casting...editorial!!
TheDurkinKnight - 11/20/2009, 5:19 PM
Josh harnet!!! right?
himynameiszach - 11/20/2009, 5:33 PM
Josh harnet!!! right?
himynameiszach - 11/20/2009, 5:34 PM
Yep...whaddya think? I dunno why they put this in fan fic!!
TheDurkinKnight - 11/20/2009, 5:37 PM
TOM BRADY FOR CAP!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Ozymandias - 11/20/2009, 5:39 PM
I like Hartnett, have for a while. I think he's a great actor. He wouldn't be my first choice, but I think if he were to bulk up a bit, he could probably pull it off.
ecksmanfan - 11/20/2009, 5:47 PM
See that's what I'm saying ecks...I think he's got that quiet charisma and strong presence that Cap would have. He looks like a decent guy, I could easily see him as a patriot.
TheDurkinKnight - 11/20/2009, 5:50 PM
dude i was totaly thinking of him as cap earlier!! you like [frick]in read my mind!!!! he would be a really great choice! but why did you say he has blond hair? its black actualy. but who cares really. he could also just dye it or what ever. but this choice is down with me. now there are stil other people to play him. but harnet is good for me!

himynameiszach - 11/20/2009, 6:03 PM
nevermind i read your article wrong! hah
himynameiszach - 11/20/2009, 6:03 PM
DURKIN @ Ive just put a picture up of JOSH HARNET for CAP lol!

: D



Lmao man!!!

He ain't a bad pick man! I'd rather him than a certain other person lol! ; )

ACKLES for HAWKEYE!!!


LEEE777 - 11/20/2009, 7:13 PM
He's not the worst choice Iv heard..I mean, im not a afn, but he did impress in 30 Days Of night and I guess he looks the part..although he has no eyes. I hate that piss hole in the snow look. [frick] it, better than Ackles, Worthington, feckin Jason lewis anyway:)
RorMachine - 11/20/2009, 8:11 PM
He's amazing in Black Hawk Down and Sin City and he could pull it off great but he just doesn't quite look like him.
ClintEastwood - 11/20/2009, 11:01 PM
Josh Hartnet is the worst pick for Cap America
I've ever seen! He looks absolutely nothing like
Steve Rogers! Absolutely NOTHING! He's a worse
choice than Sam Worthington! Have you ever seen
a picture of Steve Rogers? I mean WTF! His facial
features look nothing like Steve Roger's! He has
squinty beady bad-guy eyes!

Man, I'm really starting to get a permanent headache
from all these lousy choices for Cap! Has anybody
seen a picture of Steve Rogers! ANYBODY! Crap!!!
DDD - 11/21/2009, 4:54 AM
Here are pics of Steve Rogers to refresh everybody's
minds! Look at these, this is the features of Steve Rogers
from the comics since the 40's! Josh Hartnet
and Sam Worthington look nothing like this! ABSOLUTELY
NOTHING! There's even a poster in there, some fan made,
who has someone real who looks like Steve Rogers!


















DDD - 11/21/2009, 5:27 AM
All these actors look like Steve Rogers!
There's NO EXCUSE for using an actor who
don't look exactly right, like the Steve
Rogers of the comic books that ALWAYS
shows him the same! Heck even Tom Welling
and Brandon Routh would look like Steve
Rogers if they died their hair blond!

JUSTIN HARTLEY, 6'3"






RYAN McPARTLIN, 6'3"


TEDDY SEARS, 6'3"






JENSEN ACKLES, 6'1"






ALAN RITCHSON, 6'2"

DDD - 11/21/2009, 5:57 AM
Sam the man Worthington. noone else.
1chris2 - 11/21/2009, 7:04 AM
Sam Worthington, weak jaw line, weak body frame, 5'10",
terrifying Auzzie accent for every character he plays!
Weak whispery mush mouth voice, did I mention 5'10!
5'10" IS VERY SHORT BY THE WAY! VERY SHORT! WTF IS WITH YOU GUYS WHO WANT SAM WORTHINGTON! HOW DARE
YOU SAY A FOREIGNER FOR CAPTAIN AMERICA?! I'M AN AMERICAN! DON'T SCREW WITH MY CAPTAIN AMERICA, PLEASE!
DDD - 11/21/2009, 7:18 AM
DDD @ Take the naked T-ackle picks down, ppl will talk lol!!! ; D

An P.S. OZZY or not he's a BILLION times better than ACKLES, WORTHINGTON is!!!!


I'd even take WILL SMITH over tackles!!! : D


HAWKEYE ONLY!!! End of!!

Image and video hosting by TinyPic
LEEE777 - 11/21/2009, 9:11 AM
Image and video hosting by TinyPic
LEEE777 - 11/21/2009, 9:14 AM
Image and video hosting by TinyPic
LEEE777 - 11/21/2009, 9:15 AM
Image and video hosting by TinyPic
LEEE777 - 11/21/2009, 9:15 AM
leo decaprio, matt damon or gabriel macht...plus all these guys have wicked acting chops
Anil Rickly - 11/21/2009, 9:43 AM
Teddy Sears is spot on, but Hartnett wouldn't be all that bad.
lyky90 - 11/21/2009, 10:01 AM
@DDD I appreciate your passiona and I'm an American too, but I would MUCH RATHER have someone who would do a great job but doesn't look much like Rogers without the mask, then some pretty boy who has no acting ability. I don't wanna see some dude dye their hair anyway. Hartnett is where it's at, he has already played soldiers and did a great job.

@Anil...I dunno about Gabriel Macht, but the other two are bed-wetting liberals man! I couldn't block their trash-talking, cry-babying out of my mind while watching a Cap movie. Sides, Damon is too old. Even if he WAS the right age he's a puss. I don't care about Bourne, the guy was complaining about James Bond, saying he was a msygonist! WTF?! It's a movie! He's a pretentious little biotch. I really, REALLY can't stand him. I'm ashamed that he's an Irishman!! As for DiCaprio, he LOOKS like a pussy and a half, and he spouts his liberal cry baby crap all the time too...at least he's a stellar actor, far better than Damon. Keep in mind, these criticisms are not directed at you, I just can't stand liberal whiney bitches like those two (Or George Clooney, or Sean Penn). Actors should act and not spout their politics. Knibb High Football rules!!
TheDurkinKnight - 11/21/2009, 10:59 AM
Oh no, I don't really like Hartnett for anything especially for Cap. Can I ask why there was a picture of what I believe to be Ronald Reagan on the thumbnail? It's just I thought he was kind of a cr@ppy president, like an earlier version of George Bush.
Ryden - 11/21/2009, 11:01 AM
Sam Worthington for Captain America!!!!!!!!!!!
TheCritic17 - 11/21/2009, 1:01 PM
@durkin....i get ya...sol goode...i undrstand that sumtimes they run their mouths...and damon may be slighly old...but leo is still the best i think...like i said i rather have a guy who can act the hell outta the cap and shield...despite what he does and say in his free time...once you gimme a gr8 performance on screen u can go save how many faukkin trees u want :)


worthington's right for a good few roles...but not cap!!!
Anil Rickly - 11/21/2009, 2:08 PM
Leee..man, if you had of posted just one more pic of Jensen as Hawkeye I would have been convinced...

Himzy, your a friendly chap ain't cha?
RorMachine - 11/21/2009, 2:51 PM
@himynameiszach- And you're going....going....GONE...seriously I give you one week before you're banned for being an asshole who has no clue how to argue. You called DDD immature? He gave some casting you don't like and you unleashed a fury of spelling errors and bad insults, go get a life dude.
Ryden - 11/21/2009, 4:05 PM
ive waited a while to see this character's performance on tv...zachary knighton of flashforward...he has the face, needs a little muscular gym work...but his acting in the series is that of a lost soul and he really can be an underdog candidate for cap...not a major contender but i think he;s better than a lot of names thrown around..
also michael weston for the atom ray palmer!!!
just fyi :)
Anil Rickly - 11/21/2009, 4:34 PM
HIMYNAMEEISZACH@ if you're not comfortable with your
heterosexuality like I am then I guess you are offended
by pics of men with their shirts off! I would say you
must be a closet fag!

Their are plenty of CBM rolls that have been filled with
literal unknowns! I'd rather have a young and up-and-
coming actor who has acting chops than old has-beens
like Matt Damon! I wasn't trying to sell Ackles as Cap
just trying to point out there are actors out there who
resemble Cap from the comics so there is no need to use
an actor who doesn't look like Steve Rogers!

If ya noticed I put Jensen Ackles almost last! I'm not
one of the Ackles and no one else people. Teddy Sears
is an excellent actor, just go watch him on "RAISING THE
BAR" on TNT on TV! By the way, Dustin Hoffman
started in TV commercials and soap operas before he
became the academy award winning actor he is today, as
did many of the big names in Hollywood today!

Ackles has an extremely high "Q" rating!
I know you don't know what that means but in
the acting business it means an actor's viewer's
popularity rating...which is the rating they use when
casting a TV show or movie so that the actor will be
an attraction on TV or the Box Office! That's real
movie-making, choosing actors who will put the
movie-goers in the seats and make the movie companies
tons of money!

Using big name actors to play CBM characters is not
always the way to go! A big name actor overshadows the
character sometimes because all you can think about
is it's him on the screen instead of the character!
Just look at who Branagh chose to play Thor! He is a
relative unknown! Branagh knows what he's doing in
casting a movie, you surely don't HIMYNAMEISZACH@



DDD - 11/21/2009, 4:36 PM
@Thedurkinknight, I understand where you're coming
from, I would actually rather have an actor play Cap
who didn't totally resemble him but is an accomplished
actor who could play the essence of Steve Rogers than
a crap actor who looks exactly like him! But there are
tons of very good actors who look like Steve Rogers from
the comic books since the 40's till now. There is
no need to cast an actor who doesn't look like Steve
Rogers.

I meant no extreme offense to the Worthington lovers,
he just doesn't resemble Steve Rogers in any criteria,
looks, personality, voice, or height! I have proven
my case with the absolute facts of Sam Worthington.

@Anyl Rickly you understand what I'm talking about!
I never thought about Zachary Knighton but yes he does
resemble Steve Rogers, fer sure, and he is an excellent
actor! He could first play the weak Steve Rogers the way
he is right now, then they could beef him up with
an horrendous workout like they gave Gerard Butler for
The 300, then he could play the super-soldier Cap!
Good idea!

@Leee I see where you're coming from too and I respect
your choice of Worthington for Cap but Sam just doesn't
fit the scientific facts! I thought of Ackles for
Hawkeye myself before all this Ackles/Cap uproar!
DDD - 11/21/2009, 5:02 PM
@Ryden...I picked him cause he was the GREATEST PRESIDENT OF MODERN HISTORY!! My goodness, you really are my polar opposite...but still a great sparing partner! And DDD you're falling into that category too!

@Anyl...saving trees, that's funny!

@HIMYNAMEEISZACH, sorry dude, but there's no way I'm gonna have that kinda trash talking on one of my articles, so I had to 86 your comments. Don't misconduct yourself on here.
TheDurkinKnight - 11/21/2009, 5:50 PM
@TheDurkinKnight- Likewise my friend :D But I can't beileve you think that he was the bes-.................sigh..........I'll control myself ;)That himynameiszach is a douchebag LOL
Ryden - 11/21/2009, 6:06 PM
@TheDurkinKnight, I'm not really trying to be a
sparring partner with you! I guess I'm not as
adverse to Hartnet playing Cap as I am
Unworthington! If they cast Josh as Cap I would
surely watch the movie! Hartnet is a fantastic
actor! And he's American too! I just want someone
who resembles Stever Rogers to play Cap! I just
want Captain America done right! He's kinda
sacred to me!
DDD - 11/21/2009, 6:21 PM
@DDD...you spoke to JMS in person? damn u r lucky cuz he is a god!!! his thor run and batman brave and the bold is utter heaven..

BUT IM GONNA HAVE TO KICK UR ASS A BIT...cuz matt damon is a hasbeen?..dude forget the capn america bit...he has shown his versatility in roles from good will hunting to dogma to bourne trilogy to departed to good shepard etc...besides him makin luv to affleck the guy kas rocked almost any role that's come his way so i take strong offense when u refer to one of hollywood;s best actors as a hasbeen..that aint called 4...if u dont think he's cap, sol godde but u trashin him based on bias for a character aint nice man...his pedigree and record is very amazing...heck the guy sumtimes is considered oscar worthy,,,he hasnt been in much lately but u cant call him a has been my friend...i think u showed no respect to damon for no reason buddy :(
ur my fren still but i find it unwarranted that u bashed matt damon like that..the guy is a damn good actor..as seen in team america:P...but it's all one love
Anil Rickly - 11/21/2009, 6:49 PM
@DDD, oh, well that's cool. I love when people have differing opinions tho, as long as they're not douchey about it like the one dude who was a dick to you.

@Ryden...yeah I know, I'm a conservative all the way, tho I do like Bill Clinton a lot tho, I would have voted for him over Obama and would even consider voting for him over Mayor Rudy.

TheDurkinKnight - 11/21/2009, 7:09 PM
I spoke out of turn about Damon, @Anil Rickly!
He is an excellent actor and very Oscar worthy! I was
just a bit hot under the collar and spoke out of turn. I
meant he is too old to play Captain America at the
beginning! I apologize for any offense I caused!
Everybody's got a right to their opinion and I love
the opposing discussions on here about CBM"S and comics.
Variety and difference is what makes the world
interesting! But that @HYMYNAMEISZACH dude is really
rude!

Yes, I spoke to J. Michael personally but there were
a bunch of us at that Seminar so I only had a chance
to speak with him briefly. But it was cool as hell
to actually shake hands with one of my heroes in writing!
He is a very personable man and very helpful
and nurturing towards other writers.
He's written several books on scriptwriting which I
use as my scriptwriting bibles! You can't go wrong
listening to that talented and creative guy! He knows
a great deal about the business of writing
screenplays for TV comic books and movies!
DDD - 11/21/2009, 8:40 PM
@DDD...dude u r so lucky pal...JMS is a frickin god to me...he really inspires me when i do my stories also...i use him as a muse when i do my fan fics onsite also...lucky ducky bastard man!!!
i know that guy pissed u off...but dont worry man...leo is gonna get the shield then u come visit us in the caribbean...drinks on me :)
Anil Rickly - 11/22/2009, 2:48 PM
Boat drinks for everybody, @Anil Rickly!
I'll be down there right after I see the
Cap movie! :D

Leonardo would be good as Cap and I have
confidence they will pick an excellent
actor to play Cap America! Marvel's
been doin' all the right things with their
properties lately!
DDD - 11/22/2009, 5:55 PM
Josh Hartnett is a great actor but I have to agree with DDD, he looks nothing like Steve Rogers and I really can't see him as Cap despite him being good at soldier roles. My vote is No.
Also...I notice how all of a sudden people aren't bashing Hartnett and calling him a bad actor and all that b.s. [*COUGH*...LEEE...*COUGH*].

P.S.- Sam Worthington is a HORRIBLE choice for Captain America!!

TonyDark - 11/27/2009, 1:01 AM
he could surprise everybody, just saw black dahlia and thought of him as cap too ... but i doubt he'll get the part
HUMANIMAL - 1/6/2010, 6:43 PM

Please log in to post comments.

Don't have an account?
Please Register.