Why The World Needs Tom Welling To Be Superman

It's not enough to be good, the next Superman needs to be Great!


I’ll start with the look. Tom Welling has the best look to play Superman, I mean just look at the guy. 6’4 about 2, 225lbs (LOL). His face looks perfectly spot-on. Some will say he looks too young. That’s because they only know him from Smallville, but he is 31 (32 in April) and remember, on Smallville he is playing a young Clark Kent. The intent of the show is to make him look younger. In a movie he would obviously be made to look his age. Also in the current season of Smallville he is being made to look older as he develops the secret identity of Superman. Now back to the look. Blue eyes, right build although I would imagine that he would get a bit more cut for a movie appearance. The look is SOO important, I can’t stress that enough. Every aspect of the look, to include eye color (not brown), is important. If you want to be Superman you have to have the ENTIRE look (crack at BR). Second, let’s look at the relationship he already has with the character and the Superman audience.



I remember the first time I saw him before “Smallville” came out. It was in an article in Wizard magazine. There was a story about the show and a picture of this guy. I thought, “Wow this guy looks perfect! But, can he act?” I got my answer, and it was hell yeah! As Smallville has grown, so has Tom in his acting ability, and in the character. As a sample of his acting ability, take a look at this clip on YouTube. www.youtube.com/watch?v=P5xQa2T-CwE. Not many actors can shed a tear on command, but Tom does it here, and the scene is one of many amazing scenes from Smallville. Here are a couple more clips to checkout if you like. Just go to my YouTube channel at (http://www.youtube.com/user/tenaciousbt1) and I will have them there. Just look for Superman Reborn, and Tom Welling for Superman.


Now I know what some of you are going to say. But, the writing on Smallville is crap. And there have defiantly been some crappy writing on the show, but there has also been some really terrific writing. So don’t judge whether Tom is right for the role solely based on your Smallville experience, especially if you have only seen a handful of episodes here and there. I have seen them all; in fact, I have seen every single episode. That’s a lot of TV. Now it doesn’t happen every week but there have been some moments on the show where Tom Welling comes off as ten times the Superman as anyone else (minus Reeve).
Speaking of Christopher Reeve, he was on Smallville a couple of times before he passed away (RIP), and it has been reported that he would have liked to see Welling as Superman. That may not mean anything to some, but I think you have to give some respect to the fact that he handed the baton off to Tom Welling. Here’s some proof, I pulled this is a line from http://www.chrisreevehomepage.com/biography.html
“In February 2003 he handed the Superman torch over to Tom Welling on the popular science fiction drama Smallville playing Dr. Virgil Swann, a character created just for him.”


There is no question that Tom Welling is the man for the job. Will he accept, is the real question?
I hope he accepts. I know if he does everyone will see how right he is for the role, if they don’t already see it. I have been reading superman comics my entire life. I have seen every superman movie multiple times. I have watched every episode of Lois & Clark, Smallville, Superman the cartoon series, Justice League unlimited...basically everything about Superman, and I couldn't find a better Superman than Tom Welling if I tried. He is exactly what you imagine when you think of what superman would look like if he were flesh and blood. Tom Welling was born to play Superman, and the fact that this guy found his way into acting and then into Smallville is, well I'll just say it, its destiny. Tom Welling was destined to play Superman! It would be a true tragedy of the art of film making especially in this era of super-hero filmmaking if Tom Welling doesn't play the role he was born to play...SUPERMAN!
62 Yes
3 No
tenaciousbt
1/2/2009
tenaciousbt1

29 Comments

Yeah, Tom Welling is a pretty good Superman. I wouldn't be opposed to the idea. Plus, he's more ripped than Brandon Routh.
Joker1Zero - 1/2/2009, 3:36 PM
I am so tired of the Christopher Reeve passed the torch to Tom Welling nonsense.

Check this out from 2003...

http://www.chrisreevehomepage.com/n-2003.html

Quote:
January 17, 2003: At a New York press conference in Greenpoint, Brooklyn, Christopher Reeve and Tom Welling talked to reporters to publicize the episode Rosetta before its filming. Heidi MacDonald attended the press conference for Mile High Comics presents... Asked about the upcoming Superman movie, Reeve said that producer Jon Peters had called him up a few months before. "He told me that his original idea was to do a film of Superman Vs Batman, to be directed by Wolfgang Petersen. They were pretty far into it, and then Jon saw the documentary that my son made about me and how five years after the injury I started to move." Peters was so moved that he began to rethink the idea. "Why should [they] have two superheroes fighting? The movie that Warner Brothers is making now will be a much more uplifting and spiritual story. " He declined to name anyone he thought would be suitable for the title role, but added "The character is more important than the actor who plays him because of the mythology. I'm sure that they'll take their time and find the right man. But it should be an unknown." He then looked at Welling and said "Tom, you're probably not an unknown any more."
doubledown44 - 1/2/2009, 3:51 PM
OK. That picture of Welling on the cover of time...Is spot on Superman. Reminds me a little too much of Dan Cain...Which was an awesome show BTW.

I don't really give a damn who plays Superman, whether it's Welling or Routh or freakin' Abe Vigoda...Just make it a good movie for cryin' out loud...Keep Supes away from the baby because that's just a total load of bullshit if you ask me...Make him a badass boyscout who has an honor code and keeps to it. But make him kick some ass. I don't want to see him throw a freakin' kryptonite mountain into space because that's just lame.

Bring on some SUPER villains and KILL LEX LUTHOR! Or make him President and get him out of the freakin' way. The next time I see a Superman movie it BETTER involve a real adversary...Namely Brainiac, or it will be #7 in the suckfest that has been Superman movies...
IonParallax - 1/2/2009, 5:10 PM
I agree with Welling, because as a one time actor, to truly understand a character, you need to know where they come from. I know that Smallville doesn't follow all the rules, but its still Clark Kent and Superman and he would get it better than anyone else, because he's been Superman for years.

Watching the Superman movies, I don't think that they will work in a modern era. If DC isn't going to integrate their movies like Marvel is doing, why not set it in the 30's or 40's? Clark Kent/Superman can be a big boy scout and it would work! He could say swell and golly and it would fit!

BuckyB7588 - 1/2/2009, 6:55 PM
Bucky,

Of course I think you are right about Tom, I have to say I don't like the idea about a Superman Movie set in the 30' or 40's. I would like to go the opposite direction and modernize him. I want to go off world and expand his universe. Maybe to Apokolips with Darkseid. Now that would be interesting, and he could still be in incoruptable boyscout too, going up against the totally evil Darkseid, in a very dark place.
tenaciousbt - 1/2/2009, 7:25 PM
That's a good idea too, which I didn't even think of. Nice call!
BuckyB7588 - 1/2/2009, 7:27 PM
No to Welling. Yay Brandon! Brandon is not fit because his eyes aren't truly blue? If you guys excepted Tobey Mcguire as Peter Parker, (and he's so damned little it's hard to take him serious as a hero, which is why they always tear his mask off), Brandon deserves the chance to do right by The Man of Steel. Welling is the T.V. MOS, and that's it. Give Brandon a meaty story, a strong director-hell, even Brandon stated he wanted to "punch something/someone" next time around, and move the franchise into the new millenium( correct spelling?) with a new villian, Brainiac, whom all of us want to see. Ed Burns, mentioned in another post, would make a dynamite Brainiac! and they can move the Lois/Clark relationship in a new direction. Lastly, have the villian kill Superbastard, and increase Superman's intensity for revenge, and nearly kill the villain.
SupermanReturns2 - 1/2/2009, 8:57 PM
Oh God here we go again. NO TO BRANDON ROUTH. He had his shot. You assume he is going to magically be better with a better script and director. More likely he will take a great script and a great movie and make it just good. The story you mention sounds good, and if it were made it would be one of those movies that is just missing something. That something would be the wrong actor in the starring role. Just punching something won't make him better. He doesn't have the acting ability to do the job right. You don't even know what product you would be getting. I mean he had Brian Singer carefully directing him to be a Chris Reeve clone (which he failed at) and without that he will have to portray Superman in an entirely new way. Probably even worse. You know what all of this is moot anyway, considering that no new director is going to come in and keep the actor a previous director picked, unless the Studio made him, and they won't do that. If they were going to do that, why even hire the guy? If you know anything about Hollywood or how movies are made than you know that there is about a .001% chance of the new director keeping BR. Just look at the director before him. Tim Burton I believe. He hired Nicholas Cage. Signed him to a contract and everything, but when Singer came in, Cage was out. Even though the studio still had to pay him his signing bonus, which was millions of dollars. So Warner Brothers was willing to flush millions down the toilet because Singer didn’t want Cage, and you think they are going to force the next guy to keep BR, when I guarantee you he isn’t signed on for the same money Nicolas Cage was. They are going to respect the wishes of the new undoubtedly big name director and take whoever he wants. And he is going to want his own guy for HIS movie. So I am not really sweating the whole BR thing. So you all keep dreaming. He is out. Hopefully Tom Welling is in, but if not I know BR is out.
tenaciousbt - 1/2/2009, 9:27 PM
Goodness, could you see Nic Cage as Superman. Talk about an Eipc FAIL of masterful proportions.
IonParallax - 1/3/2009, 10:44 AM
yes welling is a dab hand at carrying a movie..just look at his performance in the fog...oh hang on...:)

he does look pretty good as supes in that pic though
RorMachine - 1/3/2009, 11:56 AM
rorschach01,

Well, now this is perfect. You are comparing Tom Wellings past performance in a totally unrelated movie that had nothing to do with Superman, and using that as some sort of evidence that he either won't be, or might not be good in a new Superman movie. But, what I hear from people like yourself, over and over again is that, if you give BR a better director and a better script than he could do well as Superman. Well I just don't understand why everyone thinks that BR deserves a second chance with a better script and director, but Tom Welling doesn't even deserve a crack at it. Why can't anyone see that if you give Tom Welling the great script and great director, than the movie will ROCK. You know the whole reason I put the pictures up is because myself and others believe that the reason there is some opposition to Tom Welling being Superman is because people lack imagination. They couldn't see Tom Welling as Superman so myself and others have made manips to give people just a glympse as to what a Tom Welling Superman would look like, and get the Smallville image out of their mind. Either Tom Welling will get his chance or someone else will, but like I said before, everyone needs to wake up to the fact that BR is out.
tenaciousbt - 1/3/2009, 3:04 PM
If BR is out, why was he there with Bale at some function not so long ago with WB and DC bigwigs, don't count him out yet, he's still in their stable or else you wouldn't be so worried about him.
CatGrant - 1/3/2009, 3:43 PM
so what if the fog has nothing to do with superman? hes still shit in it! hes still unconvincing in a leading role, he still chokes under the pressure of carrying a movie. granted im sure he would be better as superman... but i just dont think he would do a better job than routh.

and i never said i wanted a better director or better script for routh..i liked supes returns as it was ! i would like to see the sequel amp up the action and give the man something to punch but i still think singer would do a good job

and wishfull thinking will get you nowere dude! br is far from out
RorMachine - 1/3/2009, 4:38 PM
Dude, watch this

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0NIFvrV4VP4
TheSoulEater - 1/3/2009, 9:53 PM
CatGrant,
First of all, you are right I WAS (past tense) worried about BR, but I had a good right to be. I didn't want him to F'up another opportunity to make a great Superman movie. But once I thought it through and figured out what I said above about the whole director switch and cast switch thing, I lost all worry.

Secondly, I don't know where your getting you information, so I can't confirm whether or not BR and CB were anywhere together, but it doesn't matter if they were or not. Right now the studio hasn't signed another director. At least not that anyone knows of yet. It would be bad business to fire BR before they have to, so I understand why there is some doubt about whether or not he will be in the next movie. But, when the next director is hired and he decides to get rid of BR, then he will be fired and not before.

rorschach01,

Dude, the wishful thinking is all you now. BR is out, out, out. This is just one of those things where you will have to wait to see that "I'm right" LOL. Oh, and you will see. And, on that day I will be here and I will shout it from the roof tops. Hallelujah, free at last, free at last, thank
tenaciousbt - 1/3/2009, 11:25 PM
Excellent article.
I agree wholeheartedly
ReikoLJ - 1/4/2009, 11:57 AM
Check out the Tom Welling vs Brandon Routh poll on the new message board. Tom Welling is winning 2 to 1! He has won in every poll I have seen.
tenaciousbt - 1/4/2009, 3:52 PM
tenaciousbt1 "He has won in every poll I have seen"

[Lex] Are you sure.........[Lex]
CatGrant - 1/4/2009, 7:25 PM
IonParallax: "Goodness, could you see Nic Cage as Superman. Talk about an Eipc FAIL of masterful proportions."

Yeah... I said give BR a new director "if" you are changing directors. The disappointment wasn't in him, it was the story. Tenaciousbt1, you said my idea was missing something, I wasn't claiming to rewrite the story, only stating if another story comes through give fans the opportunity to see Superman be "super". No "baby mama drama". A fresh villian with a new challenge. Routh didn't stink it up as supes, and as for your comments on Cage, that was 10 yrs ago! Cage and everyone attached to that proposed project had moved on. Singer had stated he had ideas to amp up the action in a sequel, which he did very well with X2, I for one, say "well, you'd damned better get down to it!"
Lastly, F@#* the polls! They didn't factor before, and it ain't gonna matter now. The company will do as they please... The next time they listen to you will be the first.

... and as for your personally autographed Time cover,:
"...Tell Welling Dean Cain called, he wants his Lois and Clark Superman costume back."

SupermanReturns2 - 1/4/2009, 8:09 PM
Yeah...BRANDON ROUTH IS OUT. ALL OF YOU WELLING BASHERS CAN GO TO HELL !!!
RPintorO - 1/5/2009, 5:00 AM
RPintorO,
Sweet avitar, Where did you get that one? I haven't seen that one yet.
tenaciousbt - 1/5/2009, 10:38 AM
Hey Tenacious, have you seen the new promo picture for Smallville? http://www.supermanhomepage.com/images/smallville8/s8-tom-welling.jpg. TW was born to be Superman. He's perfect for the role.

SR sucked. Wrong story, wrong director, wrong everything. Lois Lane played by an such a skinny chick? COME ON. And don't get me started on BR. He was tried so hard to be a Reeves clone and FAILED so hard.
LucyK - 1/15/2009, 7:01 PM
"People have longed for gods and messiahs to swoop down from the skies and save us from our troubles. But in the end, those saviors leave, and we are faced with the same troubles as before." - Lois Lane, "Why the World Doesn't Need Superman" (from SR)

Is Warner Brothers willing to risk the future of this franchise by casting another established actor in the leading role? Do they think that casting this guy will draw more fans in? Admit it, folks: he's typecast as a young Clark Kent.

The world doesn't need Tom Welling for a Superman movie - and neither do I. He can stay in Smallville.
Lana2009 - 1/16/2009, 3:29 AM
LucyK,
I saw that pic. It's sweet. Lana2009 should take a look and see if that is a young Clark Kent.


Lana2009,

Seriously Lana, I understand that he played a young Clark Kent and all but have you seen the show lately? He looks every bit a fully adult version of Clark Kent as BR did. Infact Tom Welling is older than BR. He looks older too. You may not thing so if you only look at old photos of Tom Welling, but check him out these days. He is 31 and looks more manly than BR ever will.
tenaciousbt - 1/16/2009, 5:06 AM
"Lana2009,

Seriously Lana, I understand that he played a young Clark Kent and all but have you seen the show lately? He looks every bit a fully adult version of Clark Kent as BR did. Infact Tom Welling is older than BR. He looks older too. You may not thing so if you only look at old photos of Tom Welling, but check him out these days. He is 31 and looks more manly than BR ever will."

Then I suggest you look at some recent event photos featuring the two actors. I think you'll see why I disagree with your view that Tom looks more mature than Brandon.

Here is the most recent public appearance for Tom - the Costume Gala at the Met, May 2008 (copy and paste link, courtesy of Cami at DTS forums):

http://img201.imagevenue.com/img.php?image=24201_Tom_Welling_exits_the_Metropo414_122_363lo.jpg

And here's Brandon at an awards after-party in October 2008:

http://www.wireimage.com/SearchResults.aspx?igi=340269&s=Brandon%20Routh&sfld=C&vwmd=e

Frankly, Brandon looks more his age (29) than Tom does.




Lana2009 - 1/16/2009, 11:41 PM
Lana2009,

I understand that you think BR looks more his age and that Tom Welling looks young, but you were not really fair with the pictures you choose. Even though they are both recent, Tom Welling is clean shaven and BR has a five o’clock shadow that makes him look older. Plus, just look at the picture of BR that you sent. Honestly, does that look like Superman? I don’t think so. I mean that is the guy from the movie and all, but if you had never seen him before in your life would you really say, “Now that guy looks like Superman?” I wouldn’t. But Tom Welling looks like Superman 24/7. He doesn’t need the help of the entire cinematography department to make him look like Superman. Two can play this game. Check these out.

This one of BR is a year old and I know I can find ones where he looks older, but I was trying to prove a point; that he can look very young in pictures.
http://www.imdb.com/media/rm1160417536/nm0746125

Obviously here, I am trying to show Tom looking older.
http://www.tomwelling.us/wallpaper/tom_welling_wallpaper_01.jpg

tenaciousbt - 1/19/2009, 10:44 AM

I found these too. Tom Welling looks older in these as well.


http://www.tvboyfriends.com/wp-content/uploads/2007/05/WindowsLiveWriter/TomWelling_10302/tom%20welling%201%5B1%5D.jpg

http://www.tvboyfriends.com/wp-content/uploads/2007/05/WindowsLiveWriter/TomWelling_10302/tom%20wellng%202%5B1%5D.jpg

tenaciousbt - 1/19/2009, 10:50 AM
tenaciousbt, I couldn't agree more with you on this one.
Tom Welling fits better with the Superman role better than Routh.
It took me a while to realize it but it finally came to me. it makes sense with him. He's got those soul-piercing eyes, he's got the look for the part, he been familiar with the character for many years in Smallville and he's a wonderful actor. I mean Routh did....ok. But I do believe that Tom Welling could do it much better and maybe possibly take the character to the next level, kinda like how they did in the dark knight film. Honestly, I can't think of anyone eles than Tom Welling for the part. Personally, I like the guy and I do look up to him and as a true fan, I would support him with all my being. It is the most quality and logical thing to do. And if the writers and directirs would be blind if they don't realize it. I strongly believe that Tom Welling has the most potential to become the best Superman since Christopher Reeve. It is obvious that soooooooo many fans want Welling to get the part, too. I do, too. And I hope in the next movie, they had better keep true to the fact that in the comic book, that when he flies closer towards the sun, he would gain enormous amount of power and speed(faster than light). And according to the info I gathered, I heard DC and the writers of "Smallville" are reverting Superman's powers back to pre-crisis levels, which I think is kinda cool:)
Anthonypilone01 - 10/7/2009, 12:49 AM
Well, this appears to be an old argument, but I'm going to chime in anyway! I'm 47 yrs old & went to see the Chris Reeve movies when they 1st came out. I also watched the original black & white show in re-runs during the 60's growing up & I also watched Brandon Routh. I now happen to be a current fan of Smallville.
While I 'liked' Chris Reeve & thought he was good, I never felt that he had the right 'sense of realism'. (And before someone screams sacriledge, just think how hard it is to look "real" in a pair of tights!) When Chris 1st got the part he had to BULK up because he was so scrawny! And his smile was always just a little off. It almost felt like he couldn't take the role seriously. Like it was tongue in cheek for him.
Brandon Routh was adequate enough and was even handsome, however once again not quite the ticket.
If Tom Welling were to fly up next to me in a pair of tights tomorrow, however I could totally "ponder" the reality of a Krypton. His is the most believable! Even when he was getting a feel for the part in the beginning, you could see something there. (BTW I take my movie watching seriously & make a decent critic. I've been going to the movies for almost 40 years & watch at least 200 a year between the big screen & DVD's).
I sincerely hope he gets the part although new director's tend to want an unknown. Unfortunately, the economy doesn't help either. More studios are cutting lead actors in order to keep salaries down. Big names mean big bucks & less profit for the studios bottom line!
In this case I think they would be cutting their nose off to spite their face.
Too many Smallville fans are invested in Welling's characterization of the 'Man of Steel'. They will not be as likely to follow the transition to the big screen without him.
And at the same time, a new comer could be hit or miss ie... Routh. Why take a chance on an unknown when you already have the best MAN for the Steel?
pkanext - 11/25/2009, 5:22 AM

Please log in to post comments.

Don't have an account?
Please Register.

Horror SciFi SciFi Video Game Movies Animated Features Anime & Manga
Earths Mightiest Fansites
Earths Mightiest Fansites


Join our Forum
Join the discussion in our Community Forum!

www.MightyHotties.com

CBM Calendar
2010
  • Apr. 9th - The Losers
  • Apr. 16th - Kick Ass
  • May 7th - Iron Man 2
  • May 18th - Jonah Hex
  • Jun.25th - The Green Hornet
  • Aug.20th - Priest
2011
  • May 6 - Spider-Man 4
  • June 17 - Thor
  • July 22 - The First Avenger: Captain America
2012
  • May 4 - The Avengers