FIGHT CLUB Director David Fincher Slates JOKER As "A Betrayal Of The Mentally Ill"

FIGHT CLUB Director David Fincher Slates JOKER As "A Betrayal Of The Mentally Ill"

Fight Club and Mank director David Fincher has shared his thoughts on 2019's Joker, and his take on the $1 billion grossing DC Comics adaptation has generated a lot of controversy online. Check it out...

Filmmaker David Fincher is outspoken at the best of times, and as he looks to make the move to Netflix (starting with the upcoming Mank), the director has opened up about the struggles of making movies in the current Hollywood landscape. Predictably, comic book adaptations came up, including last year's R-Rated box office hit, Joker.

"Nobody would have thought they had a shot at a giant hit with Joker had The Dark Knight not been as massive as it was," Fincher recently told The Telegraph (via EW). "I don’t think anyone would have looked at that material and thought, 'Yeah, let’s take Travis Bickle and Rupert Pupkin and conflate them, then trap him in a betrayal of the mentally ill."

Some have defended Fincher online, arguing that the "betrayal" he mentions is a reference to Joker's plot. However, the prevailing opinion is that he views the movie itself in that light. 

Whatever the case may be, the filmmaker has come under fire since this interview was released, and later compared Joker's reception to 1999's Fight Club. "The general view afterward among the studio types was, 'Our careers are over.' The fact we got that film made in 1999 is still, to my mind, a miracle," Fincher noted.

Joker received mostly positive reviews and was a major hit, grossing over $1 billion despite its R-Rating. There's a chance a sequel could happen, but Warner Bros. has yet to confirm those rumours. 

What's your take on Fincher's comments here?


Click on the "Next" button below to take a look
at some awesome Easter Eggs from Joker!

Zorro The Gay Blade

Zorro

One of the most direct references to the comic books in Joker comes when we see Thomas and Martha Wayne leading Bruce out of a movie theater where they've been watching Zorro the Gay Blade.

That was obviously the movie the Waynes watched in the comics before they were gunned down, but rather than Bruce dragging them out because he's scared, it seems they're just trying to escape the unrest on the streets of Gotham. It's worth noting that this movie was released in 1981, which confirms that Joker is also set during that year. 
 

"Super Rats"

Ratcatcher

Early on in the movie, we see a news report mentioning that Gotham City has been invaded by "super rats." Batman has never faced a gigantic rat in the comics, but there is a villain called Ratcatcher.

His real name is Otis Flannegan and he uses his a preternatural ability to train rodents to commit crimes. There's nothing to indicate that's what's happening here, of course, but it's possible it's a nod to the villain! 
 

Justin Theroux's Unexpected Cameos

Justin

Justin Theroux has seemingly become the master of noteworthy cameos in big franchises, because after his brief appearance in Star Wars: The Last Jedi, he shows up in Joker as well. 

We see him when Arthur is playing that tape of Murray Franklin welcoming a guest named Ethan Chase on the show to promote something called American Playboy. It's hard to tell, but that is indeed Theroux who makes this small, but still really fun little cameo in the DC Comics movie.

The Franklin Murray Show

Joker23

As has already been noted online, the font used for "Live With Murray Franklin" is the same we saw in the Batman: The Animated Series titles. It's not the only nod on this show, though. 

Arthur's dressing room is #404. That was the first chapter in Frank Miller and David Mazzucchelli's iconic Batman: Year One, a story that doesn't necessarily inspire what we see in Joker, but definitely has the same tone. The 1980s setting is also the same and this could be where Todd Phillips looked for inspiration for his take on Gotham City. 
 

A Obscure DC Comics Villain

Arthur-Penny

Look closely and you'll notice that Dr. Benjamin Stoner is responsible for Penny Fleck's diagnosis. Well, in the comics, a Dr. Stone was also part of Arkham Asylum during the 1980s and he later went on to become a rather obscure Doctor Fate villain! 

There's another possible Easter Egg with Detective Burke, one of the cops pursuing Arthur. We don't learn his first name, but there was a Tommy Burke who was a detective in the pages of Detective Comics and Gotham Central. However, he doesn't seem to have much in common with this version.

Bryan Callen's Cameo

Callen

If you've got sharp ears, you might notice that one of Arthur's co-workers is played by Bryan Callen, the comedian and actor who played Eddie in Todd Phillips' Hangover movies. 

He said on a podcast a while back that he had been cast as an ageing stripper in Joker, so chances are he was meant to have a larger part which got cut down either for timing issues, or because he revealed more than Warner Bros. wanted him to! With any luck, he'll make it into the deleted scenes.

Pogo's Comedy Club

Arthur

Arthur performs his admittedly terrible stand up set in Pogo's Comedy Club, and there's probably a good reason it's named that. It's not because it's based on an iconic location, however; instead, Pogo the Clown was actually serial killer John Wayne Gacy's "respectable" alias.

This is a dark hint at what's to come for Arthur later in the movie and a very clever little touch. 

Charlie Chaplin's Modern Times

Chaplin

When Arthur manages to track down his "father" Thomas Wayne in that theater, the film playing is 1936 comedy Modern Times starring Charlie Chaplin. 

This film was actually added to the Library of Congress in the US National Film Registry in 1989 as it was deemed "culturally significant." The movie is a commentary on poor working conditions in the industrial age and there are themes in there which are definitely relevant to Joker and our world.
 

The Dark Knight Returns

Joker-Talk-Show

Joker's appearance on Franklin Murray's talk show is very similar to The Dark Knight Returns, as he commits a similarly violent act in that story. 

However, another nod comes when Joker plants a kiss on a fellow guest. Dr. Sally has to be a nod to Dr. Ruth Weisenheimer from Frank Miller's seminal tale, so Todd Phillips clearly paid some attention to the source material when crafting this particular scene in the DC Comics adaptation. 

"TW"

Fleck12

This is easily missed on a first viewing, but when Arthur is putting on his makeup, he picks up a photo of his mother as a young woman with a message on the back reading, "Love your smile, TW."

He quickly crumples that up and dismisses it, but this could very well be confirmation that Thomas Wayne is Arthur's father. Alternatively, Penny might have written it on there herself! 

Wayne Manor

Alfred

Arthur pays a very tense visit to Wayne Manor where he comes across his "brother" Bruce Wayne. In one of Joker's weirdest nods, the young Bruce slides down a pole in his playground in what feels like a very direct reference to the Bat-Pole which became a staple of the 1960s classic TV series. 

Oh, and the Englishman who gets roughed up by Arthur is exactly who you think he is. Actor Douglas Hodge is credited as Alfred Pennyworth at the end of the film despite never being named in it.
 

A Nod To Batman's Co-Creator

Bruce

Early on in the movie, Arthur meets with his social worker, Debra Kane. She was actually a character in the Batman novel The Ultimate Evil, but common sense says this is a nod to Batman co-creator Bob Kane. 
 
There's also a possible reference to Bill Finger, as Sophie Dumont works in Gotham Savings Bank on 20 William Street. That might be something of a stretch, though, especially as Finger is so often overlooked in movies.
 
DISCLAIMER: Comic Book Movie is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and... [MORE]
Related Headlines
JOKER Was The Best-Selling Home Entertainment Title In The UK Last Year

JOKER Was The Best-Selling Home Entertainment Title In The UK Last Year

Somewhat surprisingly, Todd Philips' Joker has managed to top the likes of Frozen 2 & Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker to become the best selling home entertainment release in the United Kingdom last year.
JOKER: Warner Bros. Boss Toby Emmerich Went To Great Lengths To Stop The Film From Being Made

JOKER: Warner Bros. Boss Toby Emmerich Went To Great Lengths To Stop The Film From Being Made

Joker was a $1 billion hit for WB, but Toby Emmerich went to great lengths to stop the DC Comics adaptation from being made, going so far as to drop the budget in an effort to deter Todd Phillips!
FIGHT CLUB Director David Fincher Slates JOKER As A Betrayal Of The Mentally Ill

FIGHT CLUB Director David Fincher Slates JOKER As "A Betrayal Of The Mentally Ill"

Fight Club and Mank director David Fincher has shared his thoughts on 2019's Joker, and his take on the $1 billion grossing DC Comics adaptation has generated a lot of controversy online. Check it out...
Latest Headlines
HAVEN'S END Star Catherine Taber Chats Exclusively About Her Love For Voicing Penelo In FINAL FANTASY XII

HAVEN'S END Star Catherine Taber Chats Exclusively About Her Love For Voicing Penelo In FINAL FANTASY XII

Catherine Taber recently spoke exclusively with us about her new sci-fi film Haven's End and when talk turned to her portrayal of Penelo in Final Fantasy she told us she named her dog after the character!
SPIDER-MAN 3: New I Believe Mysterio Poster From The Threequel's Set Features Jake Gyllenhaal

SPIDER-MAN 3: New "I Believe" Mysterio Poster From The Threequel's Set Features Jake Gyllenhaal

Yesterday, we shared photos from the set of Spider-Man 3 revealing that the public have conflicting opinions about Peter Parker and Mysterio, but this one makes it clear Quentin Beck has his supporters...
WANDAVISION Pays Homage To A Bygone Era With '50s TV Advert-Inspired Promo Posters

WANDAVISION Pays Homage To A Bygone Era With '50s TV Advert-Inspired Promo Posters

The first two episodes of Marvel's WandaVision took place in a classic sitcom-like reality, and these new promotional posters pay homage to the cheesy TV adverts of the '50s and '60s. Take a look...
WANDAVISION: Evan Peters Seemingly Confirmed For Disney+ Series By His Spanish Voice Dub Actor

WANDAVISION: Evan Peters Seemingly Confirmed For Disney+ Series By His Spanish Voice Dub Actor

It's been rumored for some time now that WandaVision will feature Dark Phoenix star Evan Peters, and the actor's involvement in the series has seemingly been confirmed by a Spanish voiceover actor!
STAR WARS Exclusive: Catherine Taber On THE CLONE WARS & FORCES OF DESTINY Pre & Post Disney

STAR WARS Exclusive: Catherine Taber On THE CLONE WARS & FORCES OF DESTINY Pre & Post Disney

Catherine Taber voices many Star Wars characters, and she recently talked to us about how Disney's acquisition of the franchise impacted things such as Clone Wars and Forces of Destiny. Check it out below!
WANDAVISION Star Elizabeth Olsen Says The Show Gets More Cynical As It Approaches Modern Sitcom Era

WANDAVISION Star Elizabeth Olsen Says The Show Gets More "Cynical" As It Approaches Modern Sitcom Era

The first few episodes of Marvel's WandaVision were similar in tone to classic sitcoms such as I Love Lucy and Bewitched, but star Elizabeth Olsen says things will soon take a more cynical turn...