The Problem with the last movie to me was the script, they had good actors, but the script made it cheesy.
If I had to cast a Director it would be Christopher Nolan to be honest with you. Most of you will probably have a problem with that, but if you look at the movies that Nolan has made, all of them have been good.
Daredevil is a dark character, he is not like Spider-Man,Captain America or any other hero that is meant attract a younger generation.
If Daredevil is to succeed, I think it needs Christopher Nolan or somebody with a similar directing style.
Now here is my cast.
Leonardo Dicaprio as Matt Murdock
Adrianne Palicki as Elektra
Laurence Fishburne as Wilson Fisk
Jason Statham as Bullseye
Arnold Vosloo as Zoltan Drago