Moviegoers rate Fantastic Four Worst Comic Book Movie of All Time

Moviegoers rate Fantastic Four Worst Comic Book Movie of All Time

Fantastic Four has had a tortured 3 year journey to the big screen, with many fans clamoring for the rights to the property to revert back to Marvel Studios. Plagued by bad press, horrific reviews, and devastating box office receipts, the audience has now dealt the film a killing blow. Read on for details.

You've read article after article on this site written by better people than me about this film, so I'll skip the hyperbole and just get right to the facts. 

Cinemascore is a market research firm that has been surveying moviegoers for their first reactions to films for over 35 years. Audience members have been historically generous to movies, as the exit polling occurs on the first Friday of release and captures those people who were most enthusiastic to see the movie. This has led to scores that aren't always an accurate representation of the film's quality. While a handful of films have been given an F over the years, most films generally fall in a range of A to B-. A movie generating a "C" Cinemascore is generally regarded as a failure. 

Movies that get very good or very poor reviews sometimes see Cinemascores that are opposite of their reviews, as the audiences grade the film on a further curve. A movie that is poorly reviewed might see their Cinemascore come in higher, a reflection of audiences saying "It wasn't THAT Bad." A recent example of this is Entourage, which got an A- Cinemascore despite poor reviews.

Likewise, critically acclaimed movies sometimes get lower scores as the glowing reviews bring in audiences that might not have normally seen the movie. A recent example of this is Mad Max Fury Road, which got a lower than expected B+ in spite of universally positive critics reviews. 

So now that you know how to read the Cinemascores, here is a list of the lowest graded Comic Book movies that I could find on Cinemascore. I could find only one other Comic Book film, The Spirit - that was graded as low as the Fantastic Four. 

Only movies that were graded B- or below are listed. Because I know some will ask, Catwoman, Elektra, Green Lantern, Judge Dredd (1995) and Steel all received a "B". This backs up what I was saying about audiences responding as much to critics as the movie. I couldn't find a score for Supergirl. 

Hellboy: B-
The Hulk: B-
League of Extraordinary Gentlemen: B-
Punisher: War Zone: B-
Son of the Mask: B-
Batman and Robin: C+
Ghost Rider Spirt of Vengeance: C+
Jonah Hex: C+
RIPD: C+
Superman IV: The Quest for Peace: C
Fantastic Four (2015) C-
The Spirit: C-

DISCLAIMER: Comic Book Movie is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and... [MORE]
Related Headlines
FANTASTIC FOUR: Marvel Rumored To Be Seeking Diverse Actors For Most, If Not All Team Members

FANTASTIC FOUR: Marvel Rumored To Be Seeking Diverse Actors For "Most, If Not All" Team Members

Best to take this one with a pinch of salt given the source, but a new rumor is claiming that Marvel Studios is looking for diverse actors to play Sue, Johnny, Ben and Reed in The Fantastic Four reboot.
FANTASTIC FOUR: Kevin Feige Shares His Thoughts On When We Could Get Casting News For Marvel's First Family

FANTASTIC FOUR: Kevin Feige Shares His Thoughts On When We Could Get Casting News For Marvel's First Family

We're all anxious to learn who will play Reed, Sue, Ben, and Johnny in Fantastic Four, and Marvel Studios President Kevin Feige has now shared his thoughts on when we might finally hear some casting news.
A QUIET PLACE PART 2 Star John Krasinski Says Hell Yeah To Playing Reed Richards In FANTASTIC FOUR

A QUIET PLACE PART 2 Star John Krasinski Says "Hell Yeah" To Playing Reed Richards In FANTASTIC FOUR

Emily Blunt may not be overly keen on taking on the role of Sue Storm in Fantastic Four, but her husband John Krasinski is clearly on board with the prospect of playing Reed Richards/Mister Fantastic...
FANTASTIC FOUR: Full Emily Blunt Interview Tells A Very Different Story To Viral 4-Second Clip

FANTASTIC FOUR: Full Emily Blunt Interview Tells A Very Different Story To Viral 4-Second Clip

Yesterday, a clip from an interview with Emily Blunt went viral after the actress expressed frustration with being asked about Fantastic Four (again). However, the full thing tells a very different story.
A QUIET PLACE PART II Star Emily Blunt Is Getting A Bit Sick Of The FANTASTIC FOUR Questions

A QUIET PLACE PART II Star Emily Blunt Is Getting A Bit Sick Of The FANTASTIC FOUR Questions

Emily Blunt is currently doing the interview circuit to promote the release of A Quiet Place Part II, and the actress is clearly getting just a tad fed up with the constant Fantastic Four questions...
Latest Headlines
WHAT IF...? - First Clip From The Series Introduces Captain Carter And Bucky To The HYDRA Stomper

WHAT IF...? - First Clip From The Series Introduces Captain Carter And Bucky To The HYDRA Stomper

Marvel Studios has shared the first clip from What If...? ahead of its premiere next Wednesday on Disney+, and it sees Captain Carter and Bucky Barnes meet the HYDRA Stomper (piloted by Steve Rogers).
BLACK PANTHER: WAKANDA FOREVER Rumored To Introduce Ironheart; WEREWOLF BY NIGHT Coming To Disney+?

BLACK PANTHER: WAKANDA FOREVER Rumored To Introduce Ironheart; WEREWOLF BY NIGHT Coming To Disney+?

We have two big rumours to share with you today as it's claimed Riri Williams will make her MCU debut in Black Panther: Wakanda Forever, while a Werewolf by Night series could be heading to Disney+...
THOR: LOVE AND THUNDER Set Photos Reveal A First Look At Christian Bale As Gorr The God Butcher!

THOR: LOVE AND THUNDER Set Photos Reveal A First Look At Christian Bale As Gorr The God Butcher!

Photos from the Malibu set of Thor: Love and Thunder have revealed our first look at Christian Bale as Gorr the God Butcher, and to say The Dark Knight star is unrecognisable would be an understatement...
THE SUICIDE SQUAD Director James Gunn Isn't Too Worried About Some Snyder Cut Fans Review Bombing His Movie

THE SUICIDE SQUAD Director James Gunn Isn't Too Worried About Some Snyder Cut Fans Review Bombing His Movie

Warner Bros. appears to have zero plans to #ReleaseTheAyerCut, and that's upset a lot of SnyderVerse fans. However, The Suicide Squad director James Gunn isn't sweating them review bombing his new movie.
SHANG-CHI AND THE LEGEND OF THE TEN RINGS WriterExplains Why Wenwu Isn't The Mandarin You're Expecting

SHANG-CHI AND THE LEGEND OF THE TEN RINGS WriterExplains Why Wenwu Isn't "The Mandarin" You're Expecting

Shang-Chi and the Legend of the Ten Rings will finally introduce us to The Mandarin, but one of the movie's writers has explained why that title doesn't necessarily fit Tony Leung’s Wenwu in the movie.
AQUAMAN AND THE LOST KINGDOM Star Yahya Abdul-Mateen II Is Ripped As He Preps For Black Manta Return

AQUAMAN AND THE LOST KINGDOM Star Yahya Abdul-Mateen II Is Ripped As He Preps For Black Manta Return

Aquaman and the Lost Kingdom star Yahya Abdul-Mateen II is looking seriously ripped as he heads to the gym to prepare for his return as Black Manta, while Jason Momoa speaks out to defend superhero movies.
THE SUICIDE SQUAD Star Margot Robbie Is Done Taking A Break Playing Harley Quinn; Hopes For BATGIRL Team-Up

THE SUICIDE SQUAD Star Margot Robbie Is Done Taking A Break Playing Harley Quinn; Hopes For BATGIRL Team-Up

The Suicide Squad star Margot Robbie debunks reports she's planning to take a break from playing Harley Quinn, all while sharing her excitement for a possible team-up with Leslie Grace's Batgirl...
WHAT IF...? Producer Teases Possible Live-Action Future For Characters And Stories In The Animated Series

WHAT IF...? Producer Teases Possible Live-Action Future For Characters And Stories In The Animated Series

What If...? executive producer Brad Winderbaum has confirmed that the characters and ideas seen in the Disney+ animated series aren't necessarily restricted to the show and could be adapted in the MCU!