8 Times Rotten Tomatoes Got It Wrong About Awesome (And Awful) Superhero Movies

We've scoured through the Rotten Tomatoes scores for every superhero movie ever made and singled out eight we both believe deserved better and some which quite honestly should have scored much, much worse!

By JoshWilding - Nov 16, 2017 08:11 AM EST

Filed Under: Justice League

Rotten Tomatoes has become a very touchy subject among some fans but it's not hard to see why. Regardless of whether you love or hate the review aggregator, moviegoers do pay attention to the scores generated for films and that can make or break a release during opening weekend. The company has also been accused of bias which is ridiculous but we all pay attention to those percentages!

With Justice League's score causing controversy once again this week (not to mention Rotten Tomatoes' decision to hold off on revealing it), we thought now would be a good time to look over the scores of some of our favourite - and least favourite - superhero movies to see if they fit. So, what you'll find below is a look at eight past movies we think deserve considerably better (or worse!) scores...

To view this list of movies in its entirety, simply click on the VIEW LIST (ONE PAGE) button below!

Man of Steel - 55%

Critics Consensus: Man of Steel's exhilarating action and spectacle can't fully overcome its detours into generic blockbuster territory.

A great effort from Zack Snyder, the only explanation I can see for Man of Steel receiving such a divisive score is that a lot of middle-aged film critics couldn't quite cope with seeing a Superman slightly harder around the edges. Yeah, it was a little daft for Clark Kent not to become Superman until he was in his 30s but that and a few other mistakes weren't enough to earn this many bad reviews.

The destruction in Metropolis was totally justified as was Superman's clearly very hard decision to put a permanent end to General Zod. Alas, Man of Steel's final act generated a good two year's of think pieces and became such an issue that Snyder had to address it at the start of Batman v Superman! Regardless, this was a solid reboot which may not have exceeded expectations but certainly met them.

Iron Man 2 - 73%

Critics Consensus: It isn't quite the breath of fresh air that Iron Man was, but this sequel comes close with solid performances and an action-packed plot.

Iron Man 3 may have been a controversial movie after that big Mandarin reveal but it's nowhere near as bad as some fans try to make out. Iron Man 2, on the other hand, most certainly is! The fact it has a score of 73% is nothing short of mind-blowing, especially when there's little about this movie which is actually good beyond some solid action scenes and enjoyable performances.

Mickey Rourke remains one of the worst MCU villains to date and there was so much groundwork laid here for The Avengers, the sequel delivered a barely cohesive story (and don't even get us started on that subplot about Tony Stark's illness) and it's easy to see why Jon Favreau decided to move on from this franchise after this one. Why it scored such favourable reviews is really hard to say.

The Wolverine - 69%

Critics Consensus: Although its final act succumbs to the usual cartoonish antics, The Wolverine is one superhero movie that manages to stay true to the comics while keeping casual viewers entertained.

Logan has been showered with praise and much of that is well-deserved but what went wrong with this solo adventure for Hugh Jackman's Wolverine? While it's true that the final act became something of a mess with the hero losing his claws (a plot thread ditched by the time X-Men: Days of Future Past rolled around) and a big CGI battle but there was so much here that worked well.

It was a huge improvement over X-Men Origins: Wolverine and that sword fight alone was out of this world and shot beautifully. The movie did a great job of adapting the Japan Saga and while it wasn't 100% faithful to the source material, it was a fun adventure and deserved a better score than this. Sure, it wasn't on par with Logan but an argument could be made it wasn't that far behind either.

Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice - 27%

Critics Consensus: Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice smothers a potentially powerful story -- and some of America's most iconic superheroes -- in a grim whirlwind of effects-driven action.

Sorry, but this was a travesty. Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice is a flawed movie but didn't deserve the scorn it received from critics because there's a lot this movie does right. For starters, we get the best big screen Batman to date, not to mention a meeting and epic battle between the Caped Crusader and Man of Steel which should put a huge smile on any comic book fan's face.

It's overlong, a little muddled in terms of plot, and definitely dark but it seems most critics tore into Batman v Superman solely because it wasn't a Marvel movie and because of that one "Martha!" scene (which really isn't all that bad and far less silly than what we've got in other superhero releases). This may not have been a perfect movie revolving around the Trinity but it wasn't bad.

The Amazing Spider-Man 2 - 52%

Critics Consensus: While the cast is outstanding and the special effects are top-notch, the latest installment of the Spidey saga suffers from an unfocused narrative and an overabundance of characters.

52% is obviously a score which points to The Amazing Spider-Man 2 being a divisive movie but that's still way too generous for this horrendous sequel. There are a lot of superhero movies better than this which were better in almost every way that have scored lower and when you compare this to Suicide Squad, it's unbelievable that this total mess would somehow score higher.

Don't get me wrong, that messy DC Comics adaptations made a lot of mistakes but even reshoots and a bizarre editing process didn't result in it being anywhere near as bad as this disaster which wasted Jamie Foxx, ruined one of the most powerful moments in comic book history with the death of Gwen Stacy, and was ultimately so terrible that Sony scrapped the franchise and teamed up with Marvel.

Watchmen - 64%

Critics Consensus: Gritty and visually striking, Watchmen is a faithful adaptation of Alan Moore's graphic novel, but its complex narrative structure may make it difficult for it to appeal to viewers not already familiar with the source material.

Oh boy, are you starting to see a pattern here? Watchmen was a very long movie and clearly aimed at fans of Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons' complex graphic novel but that doesn't mean it didn't deserve better reviews and it should rightly be hailed as a masterpiece because lesser films have earned such a title without putting in anywhere near as much effort as Zack Snyder did here.

64% puts Watchmen squarely in the "Well, it's pretty good!" neighbourhood and that's just not fair. A movie like this was always going to be a hard sell to moviegoers but this sort of score no doubt put a lot of people off from checking out what is arguably still one of the best comic book movies to date. Where should it be ideally? Well, I'm shocked it's not at least in the high 80s!

X-Men: Apocalypse - 48%

Critics Consensus: Overloaded action and a cliched villain take the focus away from otherwise strong performers and resonant themes, making X-Men: Apocalypse a middling chapter of the venerable superhero franchise

X-Men: Apocalypse wasn't perfect but I still don't think it deserved a critical pounding anywhere near as bad as this. Sure, Apocalypse wasn't great but Oscar Isaac delivered a solid enough performance and Bryan Singer definitely set the franchise on the right track here by introducing younger versions of fan-favourite characters and finally giving the heroes some proper costumes.

Perhaps he tried a little too hard but the endless comparisons to X-Men: Days of Future Past (an undeniably superior film) were ridiculous, especially when this one clearly wasn't trying to be that. Of course, the critics who pretty much chased Singer off this franchise may live to regret it now that Simon Kinberg is in charge because it's hard to imagine X-Men: Dark Phoenix being any good!

The LEGO Batman Movie - 91%

Critics Consensus: The Lego Batman Movie continues its block-buster franchise's winning streak with another round of dizzyingly funny -- and beautifully animated -- family-friendly mayhem.

The LEGO Movie was a superb animated adventure but this spinoff...well, it kind of sucked. It wasn't bad by any means and while the animation was on point, the story was weak and while throwing a bunch of random movie characters into the final act may have been appreciated by some, it didn't work in this world and the only really good thing here was Batman and The Joker's relationship.

Aside from that, there was really nothing special about The LEGO Batman Movie as it was instantly forgettable and failed to do the Caped Crusader justice. It seems many critics gravitated towards this release because it was the "fun" Batman movie that Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice wasn't but you just know that if half of these plot elements were seen in live-action, they would hate it.

JUSTICE LEAGUE Director Zack Snyder Reveals Plan To Restore Superman's Humanity In Scrapped Sequels

Recommended For You:

DC Studios Rumored To Be Planning A JUSTICE LEAGUE INTERNATIONAL Movie

DISCLAIMER: ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and... [MORE]

ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

Do you have what it takes to write for us?

Want to contribute?

281 Comments

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

HappyHater - 11/16/2017, 9:04 AM

L M A O

KiranSolus - 11/16/2017, 9:05 AM

Wrong according to who? is there a higher authority who decides they got it wrong?

AEStark - 11/16/2017, 9:21 AM

@KiranSolus - that's exactly what I was thinking

Brave - 11/16/2017, 9:33 AM

@KiranSolus -

Wrong according to Martha.

CaptDeadpool - 11/16/2017, 9:46 AM

@KiranSolus - im not sure what I was expecting but this entire article is entirely one editors opinion. I feel that even though he is a paid writer for this site, articles like this belong or at least need to be labeled under editorial and not news

Forthas - 11/16/2017, 9:07 AM

BVS was absolute garbage. They should be happy they got the score they got.

BUT

Man of Steel along with The Incredible Hulk are the most underrated CBM's ever made.

Menks123 - 11/16/2017, 9:14 AM

@Forthas - Love MoS, and I am not a very big Superman fan in general.

Chewtoy - 11/16/2017, 9:14 AM

@Forthas - your damn gifs are making the comments page unusable, and making me hate that film even more.

Forthas - 11/16/2017, 9:17 AM

@Chewtoy - Sorry!

But it is still a great film

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

Related Headlines

Justice League

JUSTICE LEAGUE Director Zack Snyder Reveals Plan To Restore Superman's "Humanity" In Scrapped Sequels

JoshWilding

5 hours ago

Justice League (Animated)

CRISIS ON INFINITE EARTHS - PART THREE Teaser Features Kevin Conroy's Batman And Mark Hamill's Joker

JoshWilding

1 day ago

Justice League (Animated)

Will JUSTICE LEAGUE UNLIMITED Get An X-MEN '97-Style Revival? DC Studios Boss James Gunn Weighs In

JoshWilding

4 days ago

Related Headlines

Justice League

JUSTICE LEAGUE Director Zack Snyder Reveals Plan To Restore Superman's "Humanity" In Scrapped Sequels

JoshWilding

5 hours ago

Justice League (Animated)

CRISIS ON INFINITE EARTHS - PART THREE Teaser Features Kevin Conroy's Batman And Mark Hamill's Joker

JoshWilding

1 day ago

Justice League (Animated)

Will JUSTICE LEAGUE UNLIMITED Get An X-MEN '97-Style Revival? DC Studios Boss James Gunn Weighs In

JoshWilding

4 days ago

Justice League

DC Studios Rumored To Be Planning A JUSTICE LEAGUE INTERNATIONAL Movie

JoshWilding

5 days ago

Netflix

Zack Snyder Shares First Official Look At His TWILIGHT OF THE GODS Animated Series

MarkCassidy

Apr 25, 2024 08:04 AM

CRISIS ON INFINITE EARTHS - PART 2 Spoilers: Batman Beyond Disappoints But Stage Is Set For Epic PART 3

Justice League (Animated)

Thor

THOR Star Chris Hemsworth Reveals Secret Hatred Of Capes While Promoting FURIOSA: A MAD MAX SAGA

JoshWilding

1 hour ago

Deadpool & Wolverine

DEADPOOL & WOLVERINE: Logan Is Spoiling For A Fight In New Still As Kevin Feige Teases "Universe-Sized" Stakes

JoshWilding

1 hour ago

Latest Headlines

Thunderbolts

THUNDERBOLTS* Star Olga Kurylenko On That Mysterious Asterisk: "They Changed A Few Things"

MarkCassidy

1 hour ago

Thor

THOR Star Chris Hemsworth Reveals Secret Hatred Of Capes While Promoting FURIOSA: A MAD MAX SAGA

JoshWilding

1 hour ago

Deadpool & Wolverine

DEADPOOL & WOLVERINE: Logan Is Spoiling For A Fight In New Still As Kevin Feige Teases "Universe-Sized" Stakes

JoshWilding

1 hour ago

Sci-Fi

REBEL MOON: CHALICE OF BLOOD(?) - Extended Cut Officially Rated R For "Gore, Sexual Content, & Graphic Nudity"

MarkCassidy

1 hour ago

The Boys

THE BOYS Crash Homelander's Party On New Season 4 Posters

MarkCassidy

2 hours ago

Deadpool & Wolverine

DEADPOOL & WOLVERINE Empire Magazine Covers See Wade Wilson And Logan Team Up With Dogpool

JoshWilding

3 hours ago

Hot Headlines

202 comments

RUMOR: DEADPOOL & WOLVERINE Reshoots Add Even More Cameos; X-MEN Reboot Seeking POC To Direct

MarkCassidy

5 hours ago EST

134 comments

CAPTAIN AMERICA: BRAVE NEW WORLD Promo Art Finally Unveils Harrison Ford's Red Hulk

MarkCassidy

1 day ago EST

93 comments

X-MEN '97 Recap: "Tolerance Is Extinction - Part 1" Includes Some Amazing Marvel Universe Cameos - SPOILERS

JoshWilding

1 day ago EST

74 comments

X-MEN '97 Drops A Reveal Which Could Have Major Consequences For The Wider Multiverse Saga - SPOILERS

JoshWilding

20 hours ago EST

61 comments

More Sci-Fi & Fantasy ►

X-MEN '97: Beau DeMayo Hints At What's To Come In Next Week's Episode - Possible SPOILERS

More Cartoons & Animated ►

FORTNITE Heads To A Galaxy Far, Far Away With STAR WARS Crossover Event

More Anime & Manga ►

MICKEY MOUSE Vs. WINNIE-THE-POOH Horror Movie In The Works From Untouchables Entertainment

More Horror ►

MONKEY MAN Exclusive Interview With Mask Designer Eddie Yang; Dev Patel Film Now Available On Digital HD

More Action Movies & TV ►

The Rock Reportedly Only Returned To WWE Because His Hollywood Career Was On The Decline

More Pro Wrestling ►

MASTERS OF THE UNIVERSE Movie To Hit Theaters In 2026; Synopsis Reveals Significant Lore Change

More Sci-Fi & Fantasy ►

More Cartoons & Animated ►

More Anime & Manga ►

More Horror ►

More Action Movies & TV ►

More Pro Wrestling ►

8 Times Rotten Tomatoes Got It Wrong About Awesome (And Awful) Superhero Movies

We've scoured through the Rotten Tomatoes scores for every superhero movie ever made and singled out eight we both believe deserved better and some which quite honestly should have scored much, much worse!

Man of Steel - 55%

Iron Man 2 - 73%

The Wolverine - 69%

Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice - 27%

The Amazing Spider-Man 2 - 52%

Watchmen - 64%

X-Men: Apocalypse - 48%

The LEGO Batman Movie - 91%

JUSTICE LEAGUE Director Zack Snyder Reveals Plan To Restore Superman's "Humanity" In Scrapped Sequels

DC Studios Rumored To Be Planning A JUSTICE LEAGUE INTERNATIONAL Movie

JUSTICE LEAGUE Director Zack Snyder Reveals Plan To Restore Superman's "Humanity" In Scrapped Sequels

CRISIS ON INFINITE EARTHS - PART THREE Teaser Features Kevin Conroy's Batman And Mark Hamill's Joker

Will JUSTICE LEAGUE UNLIMITED Get An X-MEN '97-Style Revival? DC Studios Boss James Gunn Weighs In

JUSTICE LEAGUE Director Zack Snyder Reveals Plan To Restore Superman's "Humanity" In Scrapped Sequels

CRISIS ON INFINITE EARTHS - PART THREE Teaser Features Kevin Conroy's Batman And Mark Hamill's Joker

Will JUSTICE LEAGUE UNLIMITED Get An X-MEN '97-Style Revival? DC Studios Boss James Gunn Weighs In

DC Studios Rumored To Be Planning A JUSTICE LEAGUE INTERNATIONAL Movie

Zack Snyder Shares First Official Look At His TWILIGHT OF THE GODS Animated Series

CRISIS ON INFINITE EARTHS - PART 2 Spoilers: Batman Beyond Disappoints But Stage Is Set For Epic PART 3

Popular Headlines

CAPTAIN AMERICA: BRAVE NEW WORLD Promo Art Finally Unveils Harrison Ford's Red Hulk

CAPTAIN AMERICA: BRAVE NEW WORLD Promo Art Reveals Sam Wilson's New ANT-MAN-Style Helmet

X-MEN '97 Drops A Reveal Which Could Have Major Consequences For The Wider Multiverse Saga - SPOILERS

RUMOR: DEADPOOL & WOLVERINE Reshoots Add Even More Cameos; X-MEN Reboot Seeking POC To Direct

RUMOR: Wesley Snipes' Return As BLADE Could Be Happening Much Sooner Than Expected - Possible SPOILERS

THUNDERBOLTS* Star Olga Kurylenko On That Mysterious Asterisk: "They Changed A Few Things"

THOR Star Chris Hemsworth Reveals Secret Hatred Of Capes While Promoting FURIOSA: A MAD MAX SAGA

DEADPOOL & WOLVERINE: Logan Is Spoiling For A Fight In New Still As Kevin Feige Teases "Universe-Sized" Stakes

THUNDERBOLTS* Star Olga Kurylenko On That Mysterious Asterisk: "They Changed A Few Things"

THOR Star Chris Hemsworth Reveals Secret Hatred Of Capes While Promoting FURIOSA: A MAD MAX SAGA

DEADPOOL & WOLVERINE: Logan Is Spoiling For A Fight In New Still As Kevin Feige Teases "Universe-Sized" Stakes

REBEL MOON: CHALICE OF BLOOD(?) - Extended Cut Officially Rated R For "Gore, Sexual Content, & Graphic Nudity"

THE BOYS Crash Homelander's Party On New Season 4 Posters

DEADPOOL & WOLVERINE Empire Magazine Covers See Wade Wilson And Logan Team Up With Dogpool

Hot Headlines

RUMOR: DEADPOOL & WOLVERINE Reshoots Add Even More Cameos; X-MEN Reboot Seeking POC To Direct

CAPTAIN AMERICA: BRAVE NEW WORLD Promo Art Finally Unveils Harrison Ford's Red Hulk

X-MEN '97 Recap: "Tolerance Is Extinction - Part 1" Includes Some Amazing Marvel Universe Cameos - SPOILERS

X-MEN '97 Drops A Reveal Which Could Have Major Consequences For The Wider Multiverse Saga - SPOILERS

Josh Brolin On Cable's DEADPOOL & WOLVERINE Absence: "Marvel Is A Complex Labyrinth"

Sci-Fi & Fantasy

MASTERS OF THE UNIVERSE Movie To Hit Theaters In 2026; Synopsis Reveals Significant Lore Change

FURIOSA Director George Miller Confirms [SPOILER] Has Cameo In Movie; Reveals Plans For Next MAD MAX Movie

HARRY POTTER: Daniel Radcliffe Responds To Claims He Owes J.K. Rowling His Career Amid Continued Controversies

THE MANDALORIAN AND GROGU Gets An Exciting Production Update As Next STAR WARS Movie Draws Near

THE ACOLYTE Footage Leaks Online Ahead Of Its Debut With STAR WARS: THE PHANTOM MENACE This Weekend

FURIOSA: A MAD MAX SAGA New Poster, TV Spots And Still Released As Press Tour Kicks Off In Sydney

Cartoons & Animated Features

X-MEN '97: Beau DeMayo Hints At What's To Come In Next Week's Episode - Possible SPOILERS

TEENAGE MUTANT NINJA TURTLES: Jason Aaron's Comic Book Relaunch Will See Raphael Behind Bars

MASTERS OF THE UNIVERSE Movie Sets Theatrical Release; New Synopsis Reveals Major Lore Changes

X-MEN '97 Showrunner Breaks Down "Tolerance Is Extinction" And Reveals Whether That Was The Amazing [SPOILER]

SAUSAGE PARTY: FOODTOPIA - Prime Video's Sequel Series Gets A Suitably Salacious First Poster

X-MEN '97's Latest Episode Features An Intriguing Link To The MCU's Wider Multiverse Saga - SPOILERS

Gaming

FORTNITE Heads To A Galaxy Far, Far Away With STAR WARS Crossover Event

STARFIELD Update Brings Improved Surface Maps, New Gameplay Options And More

Xbox Games Showcase Confirmed For June 9 Followed By Possible First Look At CALL OF DUTY

Team-Based Shooter STAR WARS: HUNTERS Sets A June Release Date

PALWORLD: More Pals Set To Arrive This Summer In Newly Teased Update

STARFIELD: SHATTERED SPACE Expansion Coming This Fall; Bethesda Teases Another New Update Soon

Anime & Manga

BLUE LOCK THE MOVIE -EPISODE NAGI- Celebrates Success With New Trailer Ahead Of North American Debut

CRUNCHYROLL Announces Price Hikes For Mega And Ultimate Fan Tiers

MY HERO ACADEMIA Shigaraki Voice Actor Teases Big Show Down With Star And Stripe In Season 7

DRAGON BALL: SPARKING! ZERO Trailer Reveals More Powerful Characters Joining The Roster

GUILTY GEAR -STRIVE- Reveals Slayer As Final Season 3 DLC Fighter

HATSUNE MIKU Is Coming To MAGIC: THE GATHERING SECRET LAIR

Horror

MICKEY MOUSE Vs. WINNIE-THE-POOH Horror Movie In The Works From Untouchables Entertainment

M3GAN 2.0 Casts AHSOKA Star Ivanna Sakhno In Major Role

TERRIFIER 3: Art The Clown Is Up To His Old Tricks In First Official Promo Still

AVENGELYNE: Margot Robbie Eyeing Lead Role In Olivia Wilde's Comic Book Adaptation

FEAR STREET: PROM QUEEN - Return To Shadyside With First Official BTS Teaser

IN A VIOLENT NATURE Teaser Highlights Stellar Reviews Along With Terrifying New Footage

Action Movies & TV

MONKEY MAN Exclusive Interview With Mask Designer Eddie Yang; Dev Patel Film Now Available On Digital HD

Tom Cruise's MISSION: IMPOSSIBLE 8 Adds SEVERANCE Actor Tramell Tillman