Can J.J. Abrams End the Star Wars vs Star Trek Debate?

Can J.J. Abrams End the Star Wars vs Star Trek Debate?

Now that J.J. Abrams will direct Star Wars: Episode VII, what does this mean for the feud between the Star Trek vs. Star Wars argument?

Star Wars Ships Star Trek


For decades, there has been a rivalry in geek culture epitomizes the fanbase of the Comic Con crowd: which is better, Star Wars or Star Trek? To outsiders, it's the perfect go-to example to have a stereotypical nerd have the argument, but to those that are fans of one or the other, they're ready to back up their favorite at a moment's notice.

Personally, I've always been a Star Wars fan but I've never been able to get into the Star Trek series. With the 2009 film, it captured my interest enough for me to go see it and not only enjoy it, but I'm very excited for the sequel this year. It seems that that film has affected many other pro-Wars, anti-Trek fans in the same way.

Hot Princess Leia Gold Bikini Kristen Bell Slave Girl


Now that Star Trek director J.J. Abrams has signed on to direct the next installment of the Star Wars saga, what ramifications does it have for this great debate?

Right off the bat, it appears as though Abrams has been met with a positive reaction. For the most part, I see people excited for the new film more so than before, as if a weight has been lifted because they know they can trust Abrams to not screw it up. There doesn't seem to be much hesitation from what I've noticed of people looking at things in a black and white way that "the Star Trek guy can't direct Star Wars!"

Kirk Screams Khan Vader Screams No


This is good news, naturally. That means Star Wars fans are going into it open-minded. This also means that Star Trek fans aren't being defensive and feeling like he's abandoning the Trek series (think Bryan Singer for X3 going to Superman Returns).

One factor that comes into play - and could possibly be the primary reason why there's such a positive reaction to this announcement/choice - is the level of similarity that Abrams's 2009 Star Trek film has in comparison to the original Star Wars: Episode IV - A New Hope. To simply write them out would to a disservice to this popular CollegeHumor video embedded below:



While the two franchises have some very big differences between each other, J.J. Abrams could be the guy to bridge those gaps and unite fans in a theoretical sense to lay down their arms and admit that each series is its own animal that appeals to some different likes and dislikes probably at the same intensity. After all, isn't that why this feud exists in the first place, because of the devotion that the fans have to the series?

Come Episode VII, will we see a calming of the Civil War of Star franchises, with the North and the South finally joining as one, or is the struggle between the Jedi Order and the Starfleet Academy going to rage on even more?

Which is Better Star Trek or Star Wars


If you're a fan of this site, come check out my new site Fanboys Anonymous for other articles like this.



DISCLAIMER: Comic Book Movie is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and... [MORE]
Related Headlines
DUNE Will Officially Receive Its World Premiere At The Venice Film Festival; New Image Released

DUNE Will Officially Receive Its World Premiere At The Venice Film Festival; New Image Released

Denis Villeneuve's Dune is currently scheduled for theatrical release this October, but those in attendance at the Venice Film Festival will get to see the sci-fi adaptation a little earlier...
STAR TREK: Q Returns & Seven Loses Her Borg Implants In First Teaser Trailer For PICARD Season 2

STAR TREK: Q Returns & Seven Loses Her Borg Implants In First Teaser Trailer For PICARD Season 2

We recently found out that Star Trek: The Next Generation fave John de Lancie was set to reprise the role of Q for the second season of Picard, and this new teaser trailer gives us a first look...
Jennifer Lopez To Star In New Netflix Sci-Fi Thriller ATLAS From RAMPAGE Director Brad Peyton

Jennifer Lopez To Star In New Netflix Sci-Fi Thriller ATLAS From RAMPAGE Director Brad Peyton

Jennifer Lopez recently signed a first-look deal with Netflix, and the Hustlers star's first project for the streamer will be a sci-fi thriller called Atlas from Rampage director Brad Peyton...
Latest Headlines
JURASSIC WORLD: DOMINION - First Footage Takes Us Back To A Time When Dinosaurs Rules The Earth

JURASSIC WORLD: DOMINION - First Footage Takes Us Back To A Time When Dinosaurs Rules The Earth

Though it's not the full extended teaser that's set to play in theaters in front of Fast 9, the first few seconds of footage from Jurassic World: Dominion have now been released online...
THE FLASH: 7 Biggest Reveals From The Movie's Set Photos - Possible SPOILERS

THE FLASH: 7 Biggest Reveals From The Movie's Set Photos - Possible SPOILERS

The first batch of set photos for The Flash included some key reveals, and we're now taking a closer look at those to see what they really tell us about Andy Muschietti's DC Comics movie. Check it out...
BLACK WIDOW Long-Range Tracking Points To A Domestic Opening Weekend As High As $90 Million

BLACK WIDOW Long-Range Tracking Points To A Domestic Opening Weekend As High As $90 Million

There's some good news for Black Widow today as those glowing social media reactions have been followed by positive early box office tracking that should see the movie beat all post-pandemic releases...
BLACK ADAM Star Pierce Brosnan On His Doctor Fate Role: I Know How To Get Into Tights

BLACK ADAM Star Pierce Brosnan On His Doctor Fate Role: "I Know How To Get Into Tights"

One-time James Bond star Pierce Brosnan has commented for the first time about boarding the upcoming Black Adam movie as Doctor Fate, confirming that he'll be wearing a motion-capture suit for the role.
LOKI Character Poster Reveals An Awesome New Look At Sophia Di Martino As [SPOILER]

LOKI Character Poster Reveals An Awesome New Look At Sophia Di Martino As [SPOILER]

Marvel Studios has shared a new poster for Loki, putting a spotlight on the character played by British actress Sophia Di Martino. Needless to say, spoilers follow if you haven't seen last week's episode!
SNAKE EYES: Discover What Hides Behind The Mask In The Action-Packed Official Trailer

SNAKE EYES: Discover What Hides Behind The Mask In The Action-Packed Official Trailer

The official trailer for Snake Eyes: G.I. Joe Origins is finally here, and it features Henry Golding kicking all kinds of ass as we learn more about the mysterious man behind the iconic mask.