AMAZING SPIDER-MAN: Organic vs. Mechanical Web-shooters

AMAZING SPIDER-MAN: Organic vs. Mechanical Web-shooters

Ok, so mechanical is more faithful to the comics, but does it make as much sense to use? Raimi's movies worked very well after all. Check out one fan's editorial (and poll) about the webbing changes in the NEW Spider-Man movie...

As everyone knows by now, Marc Webb's The Amazing Spider-man will use mechanical web-shooters instead of Raimi's organic ones, which should be noted is true to the comics as written by Stan "the man" Lee and drawn by the legendary Steve Ditko. But was this wise? With the new origin story focusing seemingly on the purposeful manipulation of Peter Parker's genetics with a spider, wouldn't it be even more natural to have kept the organic web-shooters?

To be honest, I am still somewhat skeptical that this new Spidey movie will be accepted as well as Raimi's movies were. I was surprised when they scrapped Raimi's Spider-Man 4 and announced the reboot back in January 2010. While Spider-Man 3 had it's problems (the strutting disco walk and dancing scene--ugh!), it made a LOT of money and I figured the franchise would get back on track with a 4th film. So, when Sony went with the reboot I was not particularly thrilled with the idea. My concerns were validated when we learned that we would be put through yet another origin story with Petey back in high school. Can't our heroes ever grow up? Why to they keep rebooting them younger? What's next? A Spider-Baby movie?

But I digress. So, back to the topic at hand... When Sam Raimi took Spider-Man to the screen in 2002, he made a major departure from the classic mythology of the character by portraying the webbing as a organic substance created by Parker’s mutated biology. The move seemed to smartly streamline the origin but some purists complained that it tampered too much with tradition. Webb says that when he took on the reboot project he wanted to go his own path, which meant breaking from the Raimi movies in places where it made sense — and when it came to the webbing he sought out some very specialized counsel.

“I had a meeting with Stan Lee and we talked about the web-shooters,” Webb said. “I was curious about the incarnation of them [because] of course in the previous films [they went away from them] and we wanted to reestablish ourselves. That was one thing but the other thing was the fact that the web-shooters were able to dramatize Peter’s intellect and I thought that was really cool. ... It was in the comics and we have a different design but it’s a cool element to have. It’s not something we over-use or over-exploit. To me, it’s something I remember from when I was a kid and thinking ‘It would be cool if I could build those.’”


While highlighting Peter's intellectual, scientific background is all well and good, in my humble opinion, I think Raimi improved the story in his films with the organic web-shooters. It made much more sense. How can you be identified as being part spider WITHOUT webbing? That is an essential component of spiderhood! Especially since the focus on this new Spidey is the idea that Peter's genetics are altered purposefully.

But of course, what do I know. Let me know what you think in the poll and comments below.




The Amazing Spider-Man stars Andrew Garfield, Emma Stone, Denis Leary, Rhys Ifans, Martin Sheen, and Sally Field, the films swings into theaters July 3, 2012 in 3D!
DISCLAIMER: Comic Book Movie is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and... [MORE]
Related Headlines
SPIDER-MAN 3 Casting Points To Plans For The Threequel To Introduce A Member Of Ned Leeds' Family

SPIDER-MAN 3 Casting Points To Plans For The Threequel To Introduce A Member Of Ned Leeds' Family

Spider-Man 3 is currently shooting in Atlanta, Georgia, and a new casting call has gone out for what appears to be a member of Ned Leeds' (Jacob Batalon) family. Find out more details after the jump...
CHERRY First Look: AVENGERS: ENDGAME Directors Reunite With Tom Holland For Dark New Drama

CHERRY First Look: AVENGERS: ENDGAME Directors Reunite With Tom Holland For Dark New Drama

Avengers: Infinity War and Endgame directors Joe and Anthony Russo are set to reunite with Spider-Man star Tom Holland for dark existential drama, Cherry. Check out some first-look stills after the jump...
SPIDER-MAN: MILES MORALES Review; An Incredible Experience...You'll Want To Go Back And Play Again And Again

SPIDER-MAN: MILES MORALES Review; "An Incredible Experience...You'll Want To Go Back And Play Again And Again"

The PlayStation 5 was launched in the UK last week, so we now have our spoiler-free review of Spider-Man: Miles Morales on the next-gen system. Does it live up to expectations? Without a doubt...
Latest Headlines
WONDER WOMAN 1984 Global Release Dates Revealed Ahead Of Its December 25 HBO Max Debut

WONDER WOMAN 1984 Global Release Dates Revealed Ahead Of Its December 25 HBO Max Debut

Wonder Woman 1984 may be heading to HBO Max on Christmas Day, but it's arriving in a number of international theaters before then, and you can find the full list of global release dates right here...
SHE-HULK Disney+ Series Casting 5 Supporting Roles, Including A Mysterious Female Villain

SHE-HULK Disney+ Series Casting 5 Supporting Roles, Including A Mysterious Female Villain

Some character breakdowns for the upcoming Disney+ She-Hulk series have found their way online, giving us some idea of the supporting and main villain roles Marvel is currently looking to fill...
CYBERPUNK 2077: New Gameplay Footage Reveals The Difference Between The PS4 And PS5 Versions

CYBERPUNK 2077: New Gameplay Footage Reveals The Difference Between The PS4 And PS5 Versions

Some new gameplay footage from Cyberpunk 2077 has been released, and those of you wondering whether it's worth playing the PS4 version of the game on your new PS5 will definitely want to check this out...
SPIDER-MAN 3 Casting Points To Plans For The Threequel To Introduce A Member Of Ned Leeds' Family

SPIDER-MAN 3 Casting Points To Plans For The Threequel To Introduce A Member Of Ned Leeds' Family

Spider-Man 3 is currently shooting in Atlanta, Georgia, and a new casting call has gone out for what appears to be a member of Ned Leeds' (Jacob Batalon) family. Find out more details after the jump...
ETERNALS: Marvel Comics Releases Trailer For New Series Revealing That The Team Will Face Thanos

ETERNALS: Marvel Comics Releases Trailer For New Series Revealing That The Team Will Face Thanos

Marvel Comics has released a trailer for the new Eternals series coming out in January, and as well as crossing paths with The Avengers, the team looks set to take on their fellow Eternal, Thanos...
THE NEW MUTANTS Honest Trailer Definitely Doesn't Shy Away From Skewering Fox's Final X-MEN Film

THE NEW MUTANTS Honest Trailer Definitely Doesn't Shy Away From Skewering Fox's Final X-MEN Film

We finally have an Honest Trailer for Josh Boone's The New Mutants, and it won't surprise you to learn that Fox's final X-Men film takes an absolute beating from the hilarious team at Screen Junkies!