The Thor vs. Superman debate Breakdown

The Thor vs. Superman debate <i>Breakdown</i>

Posted from Old-Wizard.com, I think this article gives a more in-depth reason on how Thor would win more battle against The Man of Steel than vice versa.



From Old-Wizard.com..............

The Mighty Thor and Superman are the heavy-hitters of Marvel and DC respectively, each of them arguably the most powerful hero in their respective universes. So its natural that this is without question the most discussed versus debate amongst comic book fans. No other versus battle comes close to being talked about as much than this one. Try to start a “Superman vs Thor” thread on any forum and the first response is sure to be: “Not this again”.

Some of you may remember our “Top 10 Most Powerful Superheroes” list that we released a while back, where we made the controversial claim that Thor was the most powerful superhero of all time (Superman coming in at number three on that list). Months later we are still receiving emails either agreeing with us, or flaming us for that decision. Many fans cite Superman’s speed as the deciding factor in any fight between the two behemoths. Other emails claim that Thor’s magical powers would be enough to stop the man of steel in his tracks. So, the natural question is, do we still stand by our claim that Thor is more powerful than Superman? The answer is still “yes.” In this article we’ll break down the seven most common arguments and give you our take on them.

1. Super Strength

The claim has often been made that Superman is stronger than Thor. Many times on versus forums threads this claim is accepted as a given by both sides of the debate. We don’t concede that the Man of Steel is physically stronger than the god of thunder though. Thor has performed feats such as lifting the World Serpent, and once hurled the Odinsword, an enormous mystical blade, through a Celestial! Thor has also single-handedly matched the strength of the Hulk on numerous occasions (the Marvel Universe’s strongest character). Not only that but Thor is capable of entering into a state known as the “Warrior’s Madness”, which will temporarily increase his strength tenfold. Some of these feats have no true equivalent in the DC universe. We think at the very least, the two character’s physical strength is equal.

Winner: Draw
_______________________________________________________________________________

2. Super Speed

This is Superman’s one true advantage in this fight. Superman is fast. We’re talking warp speed fast. We’re talking once around the entire planet and back before you can blink fast. You could easily make the argument that Thor would be lucky if he even saw Superman before he got pounded. But is Thor as slow as everyone seems to think? Unknown to many DC fanboys Thor can throw his hammer at the speed of light (See Thor#140, Thor#274). He can also swing it at TWICE the speed of light (Journey Into Mystery#102). In Thor -#393- it’s established that the speed of Thor’s hammer TRANSCENDS both TIME & SPACE. In addition Thor can appear anywhere across the Universe or other dimensions in just seconds (see- FF#339, and Thor#166). And, most importantly, Thor could, visually, detect objects that move at fantastic speeds (this happened when Thor was the target of artillery fire- see Invaders#33- and Avengers-#281- when he saw the speedy Hermes. And yes, I do need a life). Now if we accept that Superman can move at 99% of the speed of light, and that Thor can swing his hammer at twice the speed of light, it stands to reason that big blue is in some trouble. It’s true that Thor doesn’t use his super speed abilities often, but how many times have you seen Superman not use his super speed when he should have?

Winner: Superman
________________________________________________________________________________

3. Stamina

Who can take more punishment, Thor or Superman? This is a difficult question. Thor has withstood a blast from Asgardian Destroyer. Superman has withstood a direct hit from a nuclear bomb. Thor has taken everything the Hulk could dish out. Thor also once took a glancing hit by a Doomsday Bomb that was capable of destroying an entire planet, and soon after that explosion he fell from space (leaving a crater miles wide) to a planet called Pangoria-see Thor#387. Thor has also taken everything that Gladiator (an arguably more powerful version of Superman) could dish out. Both characters have come back from the dead a couple of times. Both characters have approximately the same stamina. But the deciding factor is that Superman has weaknesses (i.e. Kryptonite, Magic, and the fact he is powerless without yellow sunlight) whereas Thor pretty much doesn’t.

Winner: Thor
________________________________________________________________________________

4. Magic

Even the most diehard Superman fan would concede that Thor’s magical abilities would be an advantage for Thor. First, I would like to note that just because an opponent can wield magic, it in no way guarantees a win over the last son of Krypton. Superman has defeated countless magic users in the past, and so I have no illusions that just because Thor has magic powers and a magic hammer that he would automatically own Superman. That being said magic is just as lethal against Supes as kryptonite. Superman has no defense against it, and it can affect him greatly. Superman getting pounded by Mjolnir is the same as you and me getting pounded by a normal hammer. And consider the guy who’s swinging it. It’s Thor. The god of thunder. Not only that, but Thor’s lightning is magical too. Remember that just a single lightning bolt is equivalent to 15,000,000 volts of electricity and could travel over 224,000 miles an hour. The clear advantage here goes to Thor.

Winner: Thor
________________________________________________________________________________

5. Super Powers

Before Thor inherited the Odinforce, the super powers of these two heroes were a little more even. Now there is absolutely no contest. Thor has a clear edge over Superman here. His magical hammer gives Thor the ability to control the weather, the ability to fly; energy projection and absorption; dimensional apertures; matter manipulation, as well as the most powerful of his offensive powers: the God Blast, and the Anti-Force. Superman is no push over in this department either, with the already mentioned super strength, super speed, as well as heat vision, x-ray vision, enhanced senses, and the ability to blow hurricane force winds from his mouth. But what is that compared to being able to summon an actual hurricane? Not only that but with the Odinforce Thor was then capable of feats such as reconstructing the Earth’s Moon, willing the Asgardian monster Mangog into nothingness, and by focusing his entire power into a hammer throw that even decapitated a Desak-occupied Asgardian Destroyer. Having accepted his heritage as the son of the earth goddess Gaea, he has recently been shown to be capable of opening chasms in the earth itself, and who knows what other abilities he’ll be displaying now that he’s done that.

Winner: Thor
________________________________________________________________________________

6. Superman beat Thor in the Avengers / DC Crossover

I don’t want to spend much time on this one. Most fans of comics know how much weight we should give to crossovers. Besides, I personally have no doubt that Superman would beat Galactus in a crossover. He’s DC’s flagship character after all. Enough said on that one.

Winner: Superman by default
________________________________________________________________________________

7. Thor has Thousands of Years of Combat Experience

This is a common argument used by Thor fans to claim that Thor would take down Superman. It seems fairly obvious. If I somehow gained super powers and a Viking Warrior somehow gained the exact same or nearly equivalent powers, most people would put their money on the Viking if we fought each other. Now imagine the Viking warrior was thousands of years older than me, and had been using his powers for all those thousands of years to battle trolls, giants, demons, robots, aliens, and gods, and I have only been using my powers for 20-30 years. It seems clear to me that the Viking Warrior god has a clear cut advantage over me in a fight. Again advantage Thor.

Winner: Thor
________________________________________________________________________________

It seems obvious to me that Thor has a clear advantage over Superman in a fight. I don’t think that Thor is so powerful that there is no way that Superman could ever defeat him. But I believe that the majority of the time Thor would beat Superman in a one on one fight, assuming its not a fight to the death. If it is a fight to the death, then I think Thor would almost invariably win...............


Alright guys, what do you think?
DISCLAIMER: Comic Book Movie is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and... [MORE]
Related Headlines
SUPERMAN LIVES: Chris Rock On Not Getting The Chance To Play Jimmy Olsen In Tim Burton's Scrapped Movie

SUPERMAN LIVES: Chris Rock On Not Getting The Chance To Play Jimmy Olsen In Tim Burton's Scrapped Movie

Spiral star Chris Rock has opened up on how close he came to playing Jimmy Olsen in Tim Burton's ill-fated Superman Lives, pointing out that he feels like a superhero movie role has now passed him by...
SMALLVILLE Actress Allison Mack Reports To Prison Early To Serve Her 3-Year Sentence

SMALLVILLE Actress Allison Mack Reports To Prison Early To Serve Her 3-Year Sentence

Allison Mack was sentenced to three years in prison earlier this year for her involvement in the NXIVM cult, and has reportedly surrendered to authorities 2-weeks early to begin her stint behind bars.
DC EXTENDED UNIVERSE: 9 Superhero And Villain Costumes That The Franchise Nailed

DC EXTENDED UNIVERSE: 9 Superhero And Villain Costumes That The Franchise Nailed

The DC Extended Universe has a solid track record when it comes to superhero and villain costumes. Let's take a look at 9 costumes that the franchise nailed.
SUPERMAN: MAN OF TOMORROW Star Ikè Amadi Hopes To Return To The DCAU As Martian Manhunter (Exclusive)

SUPERMAN: MAN OF TOMORROW Star Ikè Amadi Hopes To Return To The DCAU As Martian Manhunter (Exclusive)

Ikè Amadi (Mortal Kombat: Battle of the Realms) put a fresh spin on Martian Manhunter in Superman: Man of Tomorrow, and the actor has now opened up on possibly returning to the DC Animated Universe...
SUPERMAN: THE ANIMATED SERIES Is Finally Coming To Blu-ray For Its 25th Anniversary

SUPERMAN: THE ANIMATED SERIES Is Finally Coming To Blu-ray For Its 25th Anniversary

Hot on the heels of Smallville getting an anniversary Blu-ray release, WB Home Entertainment has announced that Superman: The Animated Series is also coming to Blu-ray for its 25th Anniversary!
Latest Headlines
WHAT IF...? - Here Are The Returning MCU Actors From Today's Hilarious Episode (And Who Was Recast)

WHAT IF...? - Here Are The Returning MCU Actors From Today's Hilarious Episode (And Who Was Recast)

There were tonnes of characters from the Marvel Cinematic Universe in today's episode of What If...?, but how many were voiced by the actors who brought them to life on the big screen? Find out here...
WHO FRAMED ROGER RABBIT? Character Jessica Rabbit Gets A More Relevant” Makeover For Disneyland Ride

WHO FRAMED ROGER RABBIT? Character Jessica Rabbit Gets A "More Relevant” Makeover For Disneyland Ride

Iconic Who Framed Roger Rabbit? heroine Jessica Rabbit's appearance will be altered to give her a "more relevant" makeover for Disneyland's Roger Rabbit Car Toon Spin ride, and fans are not happy...
VENOM: LET THERE BE CARNAGE - Four New Clips Highlight Cletus Kasady, Shriek, Detective Mulligan, And More

VENOM: LET THERE BE CARNAGE - Four New Clips Highlight Cletus Kasady, Shriek, Detective Mulligan, And More

Sony Pictures has shared four new clips from Venom: Let There Be Carnage, highlighting some tense confrontations between Eddie Brock and Cletus Kasady, Detective Patrick Mulligan, and his own symbiote!
SPIDER-MAN: NO WAY HOME Leaked VFX Photo Claims To Reveal Four Members Of The Sinister Six

SPIDER-MAN: NO WAY HOME Leaked VFX Photo Claims To Reveal Four Members Of The Sinister Six

We can by no means guarantee this is real (especially after that convincing Andrew Garfield "leak"), but an alleged VFX shot from Spider-Man: No Way Home shows four members of the MCU's Sinister Six!
GOTG VOL. 3 Will Be Gamora And Nebula's Story According To Howard The Duck Actor Seth Green

GOTG VOL. 3 Will Be "Gamora And Nebula's Story" According To Howard The Duck Actor Seth Green

We still don't know a whole lot about the plot of Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3, but Seth Green - who has yet to confirm if he'll be back as Howard the Duck - has now given us a little more to go on...
ETERNALS Has Been Rated PG-13 For Fantasy Violence...And Brief Sexuality?!

ETERNALS Has Been Rated PG-13 For Fantasy Violence...And Brief Sexuality?!

It looks like that's a picture lock on Eternals as the Marvel Studios movie has received its expected PG-13 rating. However, mention of "brief sexuality" has caused quite a lot of discussion online...
DAREDEVIL Star Charlie Cox Continues To Play Coy About Rumored SPIDER-MAN: NO WAY HOME Return

DAREDEVIL Star Charlie Cox Continues To Play Coy About Rumored SPIDER-MAN: NO WAY HOME Return

A lot of fans run the risk of being disappointed if Charlie Cox doesn't return as the Man Without Fear in Spider-Man: No Way Home and She-Hulk, but recent comments from the actor may reign in expectations.
THE SANDMAN: ACT II Is Now Available On Audible - Check Out Three Exclusive Excerpts

THE SANDMAN: ACT II Is Now Available On Audible - Check Out Three Exclusive Excerpts

The second part of Audible's adaptation of Neil Gaiman's The Sandman is now available, and we have three clips, new key art and more. Hear Jeffrey Wright as Destiny & Kristen Schaal as Delirium right here.