This Could Very Well Be the Greatest Comic-Book Film Ever, But It Got Cut In-Half By a Convicted Rapist

This Could Very Well Be the Greatest Comic-Book Film Ever, But It Got Cut In-Half By a Convicted Rapist

When a film, The Crow: City of Angels, gets half the intended footage cut, it becomes a tragic mess. If the studio, Miramax, inevitably restores this deleted material, it becomes something beautiful.

Yesterday I finally got the chance to watch Batman Forever: Virtual Workprint (a fan-edit which brilliantly intigrates all of the deleted footage from this Joel Schumacher-helmed production), it now stands as my all-time favourite live-action Batman film.

Experiencing this fan-edit was a truly eye-opening experience and left me feeling a bit of melancholy. The fact that Warner Bros. have actively refused to officially release this version of the film, which some are rightfully calling "The Schumacher Cut", is, quite frankly, embarrassing. Not only is this fan-edit better than their studio cut, it is FAR BETTER. Fan-edits of this caliber are a testament to how out-of-touch executives are when it comes to what audiences desire.

So let's talk about Tim Pope's The Crow: City of Angels.

A convicted rapist, Harvey Weinstein, turned this gothic love story into a blatant remake of The Crow. Scenes of substance, such as grizly beheadings and compelling visions of the afterlife, are ripped away from this movie, rendering the theatrical cut (and "Exclusive Director's Cut" alike) a glorified mess. Featuring the all-time worst editing choices, like Sarah shooting at the crow (when she just lovingly painted Ashe's face) and the main villain sending Iggy Pop to capture Sarah only to let her get away after she disarms him, it's almost shocking that the movie is even watchable, mainly this is due to the unique set-design and dream-like cinematography (as well as Graham Revell's majestic score).

While this film does have a fan-edit, known as The Second Coming, which you can easily track down on YouTube, it has to use still images and wordy descriptions to clearly fill-in many of the blanks. The biggest sufferer is the climax, a finale which originally had a greater sense of peril and urgency; such as the aforementioned beheading of a pursuing henchman and Ashe crashing his motorcycle into a horse-drawn carriage beforehand. All of this eventually leads to one of the most compelling endings ever: Ashe, the newly resurrected Crow, makes the choice to not return to the afterlife with his son, damning himself to spend eternity among the living. The hero fails in Shakespearian-fashion, no coincidence since Vincent Perez molded his performance around Hamlet.

To say that this film deserves a cut that adheres closer to the original vision (from director Tim Pope and writer David S. Goyer alike) is the understatement of the century. Miramax owes it to their customers, especially considering the fact that they, almost as a sick joke, released a version to Pay-Per-View in 1997 which WAS the original cut. Running at over two hours, this "PPV Cut" was magnificent and is the first memory I have from my childhood. If this cut was available right now, there's no doubt in my mind that this would (easily) be my favourite comic-book film of all-time.

So, on August 30th (the 25th Anniversary of the film), I continue to wait for Miramax to deliver the good news: that they've finally agreed to share this "PPV Cut" with the world. I genuinely believe that, if this version gets released, it will go from being known as "one of the worst movies of all-time" to one of the best. It's been twenty-five years, and I'm still waiting.

DISCLAIMER: Comic Book Movie is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and... [MORE]
Related Headlines
THE CROW Test Footage Provides A First Look At AQUAMAN Star Jason Momoa As Eric Draven

THE CROW Test Footage Provides A First Look At AQUAMAN Star Jason Momoa As Eric Draven

Some test footage and stills from Relativity's now defunct reboot of The Crow have been shared online, giving us a first look at Aquaman star Jason Momoa painted-up as supernatural avenger Eric Draven.
THE CROW: Official Concept Art From Cancelled Reboot Shows Tom Hiddleston & Luke Evans As Eric Draven

THE CROW: Official Concept Art From Cancelled Reboot Shows Tom Hiddleston & Luke Evans As Eric Draven

Some official concept art for director F. Javier Gutierrez’s now defunct remake of The Crow has been revealed, and it puts actors Tom Hiddleston and Luke Evans in Eric Draven's iconic face-paint...
THE CROW Has Officially Been Removed From Sony's Release Schedule Following Jason Momoa And Corin Hardy's Exit

THE CROW Has Officially Been Removed From Sony's Release Schedule Following Jason Momoa And Corin Hardy's Exit

After losing its star and director, it seems as if the final nail has been placed in the coffin of The Crow reboot as Sony Pictures has officially taken the film off of their upcoming release schedule...
Jason Momoa Shares Concept Art From THE CROW And Weighs In On The Remake Being Scrapped

Jason Momoa Shares Concept Art From THE CROW And Weighs In On The Remake Being Scrapped

Yesterday afternoon, it was revealed that The Crow remake has lost director Corin Hardy and star Jason Momoa (Aquaman). Now, the actor has weighed in on the project once again coming to a halt...
THE CROW Remake Stalls AGAIN As It Loses Director Corin Hardy And AQUAMAN Star Jason Momoa

THE CROW Remake Stalls AGAIN As It Loses Director Corin Hardy And AQUAMAN Star Jason Momoa

Just as it was starting to look like The Crow was coming together, it's been revealed today that the reboot has stalled yet again, losing its director and lead star in the process. Find out more here...
Latest Headlines
RESIDENT EVIL: Brief Teaser And Logo For Netflix's Live-Action Series Revealed

RESIDENT EVIL: Brief Teaser And Logo For Netflix's Live-Action Series Revealed

Resident Evil: Welcome to Raccoon City is now playing in theaters, but Netflix has its own live-action adaptation of the iconic video game series in the works, and the first teaser is now online.
New MORBIUS Still Features Jared Leto's Living Vampire Alongside Adria Arjona As Martine Bancroft

New MORBIUS Still Features Jared Leto's Living Vampire Alongside Adria Arjona As Martine Bancroft

A new image from Sony Pictures' Morbius movie has found its way online, giving us another look at Jared Leto as Doctor Michael Morbius alongside his love interest Martine Bancroft (Adria Arjona).
DEVIL'S REIGN Finale Details Reveal More About Kingpin's Evil Plans For The Marvel Comics Universe

DEVIL'S REIGN Finale Details Reveal More About Kingpin's Evil Plans For The Marvel Comics Universe

Marvel Comics has revealed details about the final batch of Devil's Reign issues, including intel on the final instalment of the event series and a bunch of tie-ins. Check out that and cover art here...
CATWOMAN Star Halle Berry Reveals Why She Chose To Accept Her Razzie For The Movie In Person

CATWOMAN Star Halle Berry Reveals Why She Chose To Accept Her Razzie For The Movie In Person

The Razzies don't really generate the sort of attention they once did, but Halle Berry showing up in 2005 to receive her "Worst Actress" award made a lot of headlines. Now, she's explained her attendance.
SPIDER-MAN: NO WAY HOME Posters Pit The Web-Slinger And Doctor Strange Against A Sinister Host Of Villains

SPIDER-MAN: NO WAY HOME Posters Pit The Web-Slinger And Doctor Strange Against A Sinister Host Of Villains

Two new posters for Spider-Man: No Way Home have swung online, both of which see Peter Parker and Stephen Strange suit up for an epic battle against a sinister group of villains. Check them out here...
METAL MEN Gearing Up As Animated Movie From SPACE JAM: A NEW LEGACY And THE LITTLE MERMAID Writers

METAL MEN Gearing Up As Animated Movie From SPACE JAM: A NEW LEGACY And THE LITTLE MERMAID Writers

Earlier this year, filmmaker Barry Sonnenfeld revealed he's still developing Metal Men for Warner Bros., but it's being reported that an animated version is in the works from an intriguing creative team.
SPIDER-MAN: NO WAY HOME Star Tom Holland Reveals The Movie's First Deleted Scene - Minor SPOILERS

SPIDER-MAN: NO WAY HOME Star Tom Holland Reveals The Movie's First Deleted Scene - Minor SPOILERS

Spider-Man: No Way Home star Tom Holland recently appeared on BBC's The Graham Norton Show, and revealed that one key scene we saw in set photos has ended up being cut from the movie. Read on for details!
THE PUNISHER Star Jon Bernthal Has No Interest In Returning As A Watered-Down Version Of Frank Castle

THE PUNISHER Star Jon Bernthal Has No Interest In Returning As A Watered-Down Version Of Frank Castle

Could we see Jon Bernthal reprise the role of Frank Castle in the Marvel Cinematic Universe? It could happen, but the King Richard actor has no interest in returning as a watered-down take on The Punisher.