SPOILERS: LOGAN - 5 Things It Got Right And 3 Things It Got Wrong

Logan is the first big live-action comic book adaptation of 2017 and while it delivers an interesting ending for Hugh Jackman's Wolverine, it doesn't quite stick the landing on every facet of that...

By JoshWilding - Mar 02, 2017 08:03 AM EST

Filed Under: Logan

For a while, it didn't look like Logan was actually going to happen, but after director James Mangold and star Hugh Jackman found a story they were happy with, work on Wolverine's final adventure finally began. Now, the movie has started hitting theaters across the world, but does it live up to expectations and deliver a satisfying conclusion to the story of this iconic member of the X-Men?

For the most part, yes, though as much as Logan gets right, it definitely makes a few blunders. They're fairly significant ones too as neither the lead villain or Wolverine's fate quite stick the landing!

What you'll find here then is a SPOILER-FILLED look at what Logan does and doesn't do right. It goes without saying that major plot points from the movie are touched on here, so read ahead at your own risk! However, if you're curious about what's to come in Wolverine's swan song or whether the movie is actually worth checking out after so many let-downs from Fox, get to clicking...

Did Work: The Fate Of The Mutants

The reveal that Zander Rice has been chemically altering food to suppress the mutant genome worked really well. The explanation made perfect sense to me and reminded me of the Legacy Virus from the comic books. Uninterested in hearing more of what Rice has to say, Wolverine shoots him in the neck and seemingly kills him, a sign perhaps that mutantkind will be able to recover if he's no longer around to produce those chemicals.

That's a pretty optimistic way of looking at it and the damage may have already been done, but this is a plot point it's actually easy to picture a future set X-Force movie touching on assuming mutants are still very much in the minority in Cable's timeline. The reveal might have worked a tad better had Rice been given more screentime, but as explanations for where the mutants have all gone go, I definitely think this was a strong one.

X-24 being revealed as a mindless Wolverine clone may have come as surprise, but it's in some ways as disappointing as when The Wolverine turned into a big CGI-fest which saw Logan battling a gigantic robotic samurai in the final act. While it's cool to see the hero taking on a pretty much unstoppable version of his younger self, it just feels kind of lame and is a really weird decision on Mangold's part. His demise is also pretty unsatisfying as his skull is blown off by X-23 and an Adamantium bullet, a pretty easy way to go out considering the fact he ruthlessly murdered Professor X and a kind family earlier in the movie.

However, my biggest issue with X-24 is the fact he wasn't Sabretooth. X-Men Origins: Wolverine may be reviled, but how cool would it have been to see Liev Schrieber's version return now controlled by Zander Rice (or even as another clone) so we finally got the epic battle between the two we've all waited seventeen years to see since they barely crossed paths in the first X-Men movie This is a real missed opportunity.

Back Next

Did Work: The R-Rated Violence

There's a lot more to Wolverine than just being a violent badass, but dammit, that doesn't make seeing him unleashed here any less awesome. Fight scenes featuring Jackman's clawed mutant have always been pretty great, but Mangold being allowed to push the boundaries really helps bring the comic books to life. Claws tear through limbs and rip apart skulls, while the amount of blood is just enough to ensure than Logan never becomes overly cartoonish; what we're seeing feels very real and is all the more shocking and compelling because of it.

The fight scenes here are also a step up. While many of Bryan Singer's Wolverine based sequences felt highly coreographed, Logan feels like the John Wick of superhero movies and I just wish that we'd spent maybe one or two fewer scenes on the road in exchange for a little more action (especially as it feels a little overlong). If this really is Jackman's farewell to Wolverine, no one can deny he went out in style, and as much as I disliked X-24, the fight between him and Logan was still suitably cool and brutal.

Back Next

Didn't Work: The Fall Of The X-Men

One of the best things about the Old Man Logan comic book was the reveal that Wolverine went into hiding because he'd been tricked by a group of villains into slaughtering the X-Men. Logan handles things a little differently with the reveal that Professor X lost control of his powers and accidentally killed them, but the movie never provides a detailed or lengthy explanation and that's really frustrating.

The thoughts of Charles (a man we've followed through decades worth of history in this franchise now) being responsible for the fall of the X-Men definitely sticks with you, but a flashback or something more in-depth really would not have hurt. Why not show Wolverine being forced to kill his friends due to the horrible damage Xavier's psychic attack had done to them? At the end of the day, this is a Wolverine movie and not an X-Men one, but given the importance they've played in his storied history, I expected a little more than what that got here, especially as the end of the team is arguably a moment fans deserved to see on the big screen.

Back Next

Did Work: Caliban

Going into Logan, I was more annoyed by the fact Fox were using another version of Caliban less than a year after we met a version of the character in the 1980s set X-Men: Apocalypse than I was interested in what he'd be getting up to here. However, all thoughts of that quickly vanished upon realising just how damn good Stephen Merchant is in the role. I've always been a fan of his whether we're talking about his work on TV shows like The Office and Extras or as himself in stand-up and The Ricky Gervais Show, but he really impresses here.

The actor's dry wit is perfectly suited for Caliban and he provides some much needed levity at various points throughout the movie with his sarcastic remarks and peculiar relationship with Wolverine and Professor X. His sacrifice in the movie's third act is also handled well, though I was a little disappointed not to see it achieve more, especially when Rice later points to his body and seemingly indicates that he intends to clone him for his mutant tracking powers. Who knows, perhaps we'll see a monstrous version of the character appear in X-Force or something similar down the line!

Back Next

Did Work: X-23

As I mentioned in my review for Logan, I fully expected to leave the movie hoping to see more of X-23, albeit as an adult with a new actress in the role. Not any more. Dafne Keene was superb as the young mutant and watching her grow up as the character over the next few years promises to be a lot of fun assuming execs at Fox have the brains to utilise her in movies like X-Force and perhaps even her own solo outing. The ending of Logan leaves Laura in a very interesting place; she's seen her father die and is now on the run with a group of young mutants, so there's really any number of directions her story could go in next.

Despite being mute for most of the movie, Keene's performance is still excellent, but it's when she starts talking that she really impresses. The actress has a tonne of attitude and already feels like a believable badass, and I for one could get behind her essentially being the new Wolverine of this world until Jackman is inevitably recast somewhere down the line. Ultimately, it's going to depend on where Fox goes next with her, but expect X-23 to be a big fan-favourite after Logan.

Back Next

Didn't Work: Wolverine's Demise

Logan ending with the demise of Wolverine was pretty much inevitable and I'm genuinely surprised by how much of a whimper the hero goes out on. While it's true he dies fighting to protect the young mutants from X-24, he doesn't actually stop his clone; X-23 does. That robs him of a truly heroic ending and while his injuries from the fight are significant, he life ending after he's impaled on a tree branch doesn't feel like the most fitting of deaths for the iconic hero.

His healing factor may not be what it once was, but comic book fans will know Wolverine has "died" many times only for that power to resurrect him and his wounds never feel significant enough for him not to ultimately heal even if it takes weeks. Who knows, perhaps Jackman will be convinced to return and we'll see him claw his way out of that grave, but if the answer is that his healing factor simply couldn't recover from such significant injuries, I just wish they'd been a little worse as this feels like a huge underwhelming note for his story to wrap up on. Maybe it's just me, but I expected better.

Back Next

Did Work: The Family Dynamic

The dynamic between Wolverine, Professor X, and X-23 is very much a family one and that works brilliantly here. When Logan introduces Charles as his father, it's surprisingly believable, while his budding relationship with Laura is handled in a very interesting way (and less conventionally than movies which feature similar situations). While I think an argument could be made that the movie spends a little too much time on the road with the trio - shaving twenty minutes or so off the running time would have been no bad thing - these scenes are thoroughly enjoyable and a definite highlight outside of the big fight scenes.

Wolverine's relationship with Charles has always been interesting and after what happened to the X-Men, it's even moreso, though it would have definitely helped if a greater amount of light had been shed on that. Logan ultimately does a lot right and very little wrong and as much as I would have liked to learn more about how Wolverine decided to call himself James Howlett or why Mr. Sinister had no presence here, this trio mostly makes up for what's lacking!

Have you seen Logan? If so, what do you think did and didn't work? As always, feel free to weigh in with your spoiler-filled thoughts in the comments section down below.

Back

Jean Grey Rises From The Ashes In Her New Costume On PHOENIX #1 Variant Covers

Recommended For You:

X-MEN: 7 Mutants We Need To See In The MCU Reboot To Make The Ultimate X-Men Dream Team

DISCLAIMER: ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and... [MORE]

ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

Do you have what it takes to write for us?

Want to contribute?

147 Comments

1 2 3 4

Thanoice - 3/2/2017, 8:10 AM

One of my most anticipated movies of the year. Can't wait too see Logan and Xavier for one last swan song

Scarilian - 3/2/2017, 9:51 AM

@JustUsLeague -

Logan is done well.

Prof X on the otherhand doesnt feel in character due to plot aspects.

Thanoice - 3/2/2017, 10:43 AM

@Scarilian - That's a shame. He was one of my most anticipated parts.

Scarilian - 3/2/2017, 2:31 PM

@JustUsLeague -

He's alright, it just feels like he's had better portrayals in other films. At some times i felt he was only in the film to get the story moving, at other times he felt like he was interupting the story. The film just seemed to work better when it was Logan and X-23 rather than Logan and Prof X.

Logan has not changed in character too much from his very first appearance.

mutantsoldier2 - 3/3/2017, 6:21 AM

@JustUsLeague - don't listen to him. watch the movie and make your own opinion.

Scarilian - 3/3/2017, 9:07 AM

@mutantsoldier2 -

Who are you saying for him not to listen to? I massively enjoyed the movie and just gave my opinions on it.

He's likely going to see the movie anyway and i encourage him to do so also.

Thanoice - 3/3/2017, 11:56 AM

@Scarilian - That's a bit of a shame but I'm sure Patrick Stewart did the best with what he was given. Sucks it's his last film as the professor.

Thanoice - 3/3/2017, 11:58 AM

@mutantsoldier2 - Oh I will don't you worry. It's just nice to hear what most other people on here think of these, considering we all have to be pretty big fans too be on here talking about them lol. Like I said, one of my most anticipated CBMs ever so I'll be seeing her soon enough

Scarilian - 3/3/2017, 5:11 PM

@JustUsLeague - Just got out of seeing it for a second time. His performance has grown on me a bit more. I think it mostly comes down to that his character's storyline has advanced a lot and you have to kind of get used to where he is now before you can appreciate how well his acting is.

Everyone in the film does great performances, but i think i just was more accustomed to how Prof X was acted in the previous movies where he was more of a mentor figure.

Thanoice - 3/4/2017, 12:06 PM

@Scarilian - Haven't heard a single bad thing about it yet. Glad to hear it's just as good the second time around! I'll be seeing it Tuesday so I'll let you know my thoughts. So pumped.

Scarilian - 3/5/2017, 11:11 AM

@JustUsLeague -

Hope you enjoy it :)

Thanoice - 3/8/2017, 12:10 AM

@Scarilian - I'm sure I will, I'll let you know what I think!

leethario - 3/2/2017, 8:18 AM

Yeah but if X flipped out and killed the x-men why does logan tag along with him, be like sleeping on a land mine. Surely he would do the right thing and take X out, kinda like logan does to that kid in ultimate x-men that poisons everyone near him.

TheBeard - 3/2/2017, 8:21 AM

I read on Reddit that Xavier puts old man Logan's mind into x-24, and then they kill old man logan's body with the clone's mind in it . Adamantium bullet to the head after Xavier dies. That way Logan can continue on and help mutant kind rebuild or whatever as a young Logan again. I guess that's not the case.

JoeMomma29 - 3/2/2017, 8:24 AM

@TheBeard - Yeah not true.

McGee - 3/2/2017, 9:05 AM

I read on Imgur that if you watch Guardians of the Galaxy on acid, you can have sex with Zoe Saldana while floating in the vaccum of space. True or false?

rebellion - 3/2/2017, 8:22 AM

it said that seven mutants died, some of them x-men. so not all of them are dead. use your brain. and ears, they seem big enough.

Scarilian - 3/2/2017, 9:52 AM

@rebellion -

We see a mass graveyard in the trailers and Logan talks like every one of them is dead.

1 2 3 4

Related Headlines

X-Men '97

X-MEN '97 Showrunner Addresses Some Of The Biggest Moments And Easter Eggs In Today's Episode

JoshWilding

16 hours ago

X-Men '97

Who Is [SPOILER]? Everything You Need To Know About X-MEN '97 Surprise New Villain

JoshWilding

22 hours ago

X-Men '97

X-MEN '97 "Bright Eyes" Recap: An Unexpected New Villain Revealed As [SPOILER] Makes Shock Return

JoshWilding

1 day ago

Related Headlines

X-Men '97

X-MEN '97 Showrunner Addresses Some Of The Biggest Moments And Easter Eggs In Today's Episode

JoshWilding

16 hours ago

X-Men '97

Who Is [SPOILER]? Everything You Need To Know About X-MEN '97 Surprise New Villain

JoshWilding

22 hours ago

X-Men '97

X-MEN '97 "Bright Eyes" Recap: An Unexpected New Villain Revealed As [SPOILER] Makes Shock Return

JoshWilding

1 day ago

X-Men '97

X-MEN '97 "Bright Eyes" Recap: Breaking Down Those TWO Surprise Marvel Universe Cameos (And Who Played Them)

JoshWilding

1 day ago

X-Men '97

X-MEN '97: Rogue Unleashes Her Rage In Action-Packed Clip From Tomorrow's New Episode

MarkCassidy

1 day ago

X-Men '97

The Flash

THE FLASH: Today Is The Day Barry Allen Goes Missing After He Vanishes In Crisis; Grant Gustin Responds

JoshWilding

1 hour ago

Deadpool & Wolverine

Marvel Studios Veteran And DEADPOOL & WOLVERINE Production Designer Ray Chan Has Passed Away

JoshWilding

2 hours ago

Latest Headlines

Disney

THE LITTLE MERMAID Is Given An R-Rated Makeover In First Trailer For MSR's Adaptation

MarkCassidy

26 mins ago

The Flash

THE FLASH: Today Is The Day Barry Allen Goes Missing After He Vanishes In Crisis; Grant Gustin Responds

JoshWilding

1 hour ago

Deadpool & Wolverine

Marvel Studios Veteran And DEADPOOL & WOLVERINE Production Designer Ray Chan Has Passed Away

JoshWilding

2 hours ago

Superman: Legacy

SUPERMAN Stunt Performer Praises Man Of Steel's Costume And Says DCU Feels Like "Start Of A New Era"

JoshWilding

3 hours ago

Netflix

Zack Snyder Shares First Official Look At His TWILIGHT OF THE GODS Animated Series

MarkCassidy

3 hours ago

The Sandman

DEAD BOY DETECTIVES Spoilers: Find Out Which OTHER Characters From THE SANDMAN Appear

MarkCassidy

4 hours ago

Hot Headlines

166 comments

MAN OF STEEL Director Zack Snyder Says Superman Would Be "Fake" If He Hadn't Killed General Zod

JoshWilding

1 day ago EST

107 comments

DEADPOOL AND WOLVERINE's Post-Credits Scene Said To Be "Mind-Blowing"

MarkCassidy

18 hours ago EST

103 comments

Former X-MEN '97 Showrunner Beau DeMayo Says Show Will Address Mr. Sinister's Racism

MarkCassidy

1 day ago EST

79 comments

SHE-HULK: ATTORNEY AT LAW Guest-Star Megan Thee Stallion Sued For Workplace Harassment

MarkCassidy

1 day ago EST

73 comments

More Sci-Fi & Fantasy ►

X-MEN '97: Beau DeMayo Hints At Possible Appearances From BLACK PANTHER And SPIDER-MAN

More Cartoons & Animated ►

New DESTINY 2: THE FINAL SHAPE Trailer Takes Us Into The Pale Heart Of The Traveler

More Anime & Manga ►

THE LITTLE MERMAID Attacks In First Trailer For New R-Rated Live-Action Adaptation

More Horror ►

MONKEY MAN Exclusive Interview With Mask Designer Eddie Yang; Dev Patel Film Now Available On Digital HD

More Action Movies & TV ►

AEW Officially Jumps The Shark As Jack Perry And The Elite Attack Tony Khan On DYNAMITE

More Pro Wrestling ►

REBEL MOON 2 Is Netflix's No. 1 Movie Worldwide Despite Abysmal Rotten Tomatoes Critics AND Audience Scores

More Sci-Fi & Fantasy ►

More Cartoons & Animated ►

More Anime & Manga ►

More Horror ►

More Action Movies & TV ►

More Pro Wrestling ►

SPOILERS: LOGAN - 5 Things It Got Right And 3 Things It Got Wrong

Logan is the first big live-action comic book adaptation of 2017 and while it delivers an interesting ending for Hugh Jackman's Wolverine, it doesn't quite stick the landing on every facet of that...

Did Work: The Fate Of The Mutants

Didn't Work: X-24

Did Work: The R-Rated Violence

Didn't Work: The Fall Of The X-Men

Did Work: Caliban

Did Work: X-23

Didn't Work: Wolverine's Demise

Did Work: The Family Dynamic

Jean Grey Rises "From The Ashes" In Her New Costume On PHOENIX #1 Variant Covers

X-MEN: 7 Mutants We Need To See In The MCU Reboot To Make The Ultimate X-Men Dream Team

X-MEN '97 Showrunner Addresses Some Of The Biggest Moments And Easter Eggs In Today's Episode

Who Is [SPOILER]? Everything You Need To Know About X-MEN '97 Surprise New Villain

X-MEN '97 "Bright Eyes" Recap: An Unexpected New Villain Revealed As [SPOILER] Makes Shock Return

X-MEN '97 Showrunner Addresses Some Of The Biggest Moments And Easter Eggs In Today's Episode

Who Is [SPOILER]? Everything You Need To Know About X-MEN '97 Surprise New Villain

X-MEN '97 "Bright Eyes" Recap: An Unexpected New Villain Revealed As [SPOILER] Makes Shock Return

X-MEN '97 "Bright Eyes" Recap: Breaking Down Those TWO Surprise Marvel Universe Cameos (And Who Played Them)

X-MEN '97: Rogue Unleashes Her Rage In Action-Packed Clip From Tomorrow's New Episode

Former X-MEN '97 Showrunner Beau DeMayo Says Show Will Address Mr. Sinister's Racism

Popular Headlines

DEADPOOL & WOLVERINE: Rumored New Details About [SPOILER], [SPOILER], And [SPOILER]'s Roles Revealed

DEADPOOL AND WOLVERINE's Post-Credits Scene Said To Be "Mind-Blowing"

X-MEN '97 "Bright Eyes" Recap: An Unexpected New Villain Revealed As [SPOILER] Makes Shock Return

Sam Raimi On AVENGERS: SECRET WARS Rumors And Potential SPIDER-MAN 4 Story

DEADPOOL AND WOLVERINE Rumored To Feature An Appearance From [SPOILER] As [SPOILER]

THE LITTLE MERMAID Is Given An R-Rated Makeover In First Trailer For MSR's Adaptation

THE FLASH: Today Is The Day Barry Allen Goes Missing After He Vanishes In Crisis; Grant Gustin Responds

Marvel Studios Veteran And DEADPOOL & WOLVERINE Production Designer Ray Chan Has Passed Away

THE LITTLE MERMAID Is Given An R-Rated Makeover In First Trailer For MSR's Adaptation

THE FLASH: Today Is The Day Barry Allen Goes Missing After He Vanishes In Crisis; Grant Gustin Responds

Marvel Studios Veteran And DEADPOOL & WOLVERINE Production Designer Ray Chan Has Passed Away

SUPERMAN Stunt Performer Praises Man Of Steel's Costume And Says DCU Feels Like "Start Of A New Era"

Zack Snyder Shares First Official Look At His TWILIGHT OF THE GODS Animated Series

DEAD BOY DETECTIVES Spoilers: Find Out Which OTHER Characters From THE SANDMAN Appear

Hot Headlines

MAN OF STEEL Director Zack Snyder Says Superman Would Be "Fake" If He Hadn't Killed General Zod

DEADPOOL AND WOLVERINE's Post-Credits Scene Said To Be "Mind-Blowing"

Former X-MEN '97 Showrunner Beau DeMayo Says Show Will Address Mr. Sinister's Racism

SHE-HULK: ATTORNEY AT LAW Guest-Star Megan Thee Stallion Sued For Workplace Harassment

Sam Raimi On AVENGERS: SECRET WARS Rumors And Potential SPIDER-MAN 4 Story

Sci-Fi & Fantasy

REBEL MOON 2 Is Netflix's No. 1 Movie Worldwide Despite Abysmal Rotten Tomatoes Critics AND Audience Scores

STAR WARS: THE ACOLYTE Star Explains How Vernestra Rwoh Will Differ From Books; New Still Released

REBEL MOON Director Zack Snyder Shares First Official Look At TWILIGHT OF THE GODS Animated Series

THE LITTLE MERMAID: Ariel Gets An R-Rated Makeover In First Trailer For New Live-Action Adaptation

STAR WARS: TALES OF THE EMPIRE Clip Sees General Grievous Attack Dathomir's Nightsisters

DUNE: PART TWO Honest Trailer Isn't Afraid To Point Out The Flaws In Denis Villeneuve's Sci-Fi Masterpiece

Cartoons & Animated Features

X-MEN '97: Beau DeMayo Hints At Possible Appearances From BLACK PANTHER And SPIDER-MAN

X-MEN '97 Hinted At The Show's Big Bad As Early As The Second Episode - SPOILERS

THE SIMPSONS Just Killed A Character Who Has Been Part Of The Series Since Its First Episode

X-MEN '97: Marvel Studios Commemorates A Fallen Hero With Stunning New Artwork - SPOILERS

TWILIGHT OF THE GODS Director Zack Snyder Shares First Look At His Animated Norse Mythology Series

THE LITTLE MERMAID: New Live-Action Movie Rated R For "Violence & Nudity" - Check Out The Trailer

Gaming

New DESTINY 2: THE FINAL SHAPE Trailer Takes Us Into The Pale Heart Of The Traveler

GTA 5 Voice Actor Reveals Plans For "Agent Trevor" DLC Before Rockstar Apparently Scrapped It

TALES OF THE SHIRE: A LORD OF THE RINGS GAME Official Announcement Trailer Released

FALLOUT Series Showrunners Strongly Hint Season 2 Will Take Us To An Iconic Location From The Games

Billie Eilish Headlines FORTNITE FESTIVAL Season 3

LaKeith Stanfield To Star In Film Based On EL PASO, ELSEWHERE Vampire Video Game

Anime & Manga

Netflix's ONE PIECE Season 2 Finally Gets A Release Window

UniVersus Reveals New MY HERO ACADEMIA: GIRL POWER Set

New Trailer For GAROUDEN: THE WAY OF THE LONE WOLF Released Ahead Of Netflix Debut

Netflix's ONE PIECE Finds New Showrunner In PERCY JACKSON AND THE OLYMPIANS' Joe Tracz

DRAGON BALL SUPER Interval Special Announced By Jump While Manga Remains On Indefinite Hiatus

New Teaser And Key Art For Live-Action TRILLION GAME Movie

Horror

THE LITTLE MERMAID Attacks In First Trailer For New R-Rated Live-Action Adaptation

28 YEARS LATER: Jodie Comer, Aaron Taylor-Johnson & Ralph Fiennes Officially Join Cast

WEDNESDAY Season 2 Adds WESTWORLD Star Thandiwe Newton In Mysterious Role

BLINK TWICE: Channing Tatum Invites You To "Pussy Island" In First Trailer For Zoë Kravitz's Directorial Debut

THE WATCHERS New Trailer Sees Dakota Fanning Terrorised In Ishana Night Shyamalan's Directorial Debut

EVIL DEAD RISE Director Lee Cronin Shares Gruesome New BTS Photos To Mark Movie's One-Year Anniversary

Action Movies & TV

MONKEY MAN Exclusive Interview With Mask Designer Eddie Yang; Dev Patel Film Now Available On Digital HD

Tom Cruise's MISSION: IMPOSSIBLE 8 Adds SEVERANCE Actor Tramell Tillman