THE NEW MUTANTS: Fox Considered Reshooting The Entire Movie; Shocking New Details On BTS Chaos Emerge

THE NEW MUTANTS: Fox Considered Reshooting The Entire Movie; Shocking New Details On BTS Chaos Emerge

Some shocking new details have emerged about the production of The New Mutants, including a huge number of uncredited rewrites, Storm's bizarre original role, and plans to reshoot the entire movie...

Vulture has done some digging into The New Mutants - talking to several people close to the production - and come back with some real bombshells about what happened behind the scenes. As we recently learned, the original plan was for the movie to be set in the 1980s so that it would tie into X-Men: Apocalypse and the main franchise's timeline. However, after that underwhelmed both critically and financially, Fox changed tact, and director Josh Boone and co-writer Knate Lee's plan to deliver a "hybrid-horror Breakfast Club movie" were thrown out by the studio. 

That did not sit well with either of them, and once shooting was finally finished, it's said that "Fox was so displeased with the initial cut the studio discussed throwing the entire movie out to 'start over' with a total reshoot." That likely explains the reports that surfaced when the movie was first delayed by Fox, but there's a lot more to the story than that. 

Apparently, Boone and Lee's initial 2015 screenplay didn't really deliver what they'd initially pitched, with crude humour, in particular, needing to be toned down. As well as The Breakfast ClubThe Legend of Billie Jean served as part of the filmmaker's inspiration, but as one source puts it, "Punk-rock-y, rebellious teens are already baked into the X-Men, but here, one of the characters was a misogynist and graffiti-ing his penis on stuff. There were head scratchers."

It's no secret that Storm was in an earlier version of The New Mutants (the director has talked about that on a number of occasions), but here, Boone portrayed her as the "sadistic jailer" of the leads, a depiction which confused those at the studio. "It felt like the kids were being tortured," one source explains. "If the X-Men are holding [the young mutants] there, it can’t feel different from the mental furniture that audiences bring into the theater knowing that the X-Men are good guys. Storm like that made no sense." At this point, a number of writers were brought in to take a crack at the screenplay, including The Fault in Our Stars scribes Scott Neustadter and Michael H. Weber, but Boone kept butting heads with producer (and Dark Phoenix director) Simon Kinberg. 

New versions of the scripts kept coming in, with Chad Hayes and Carey W. Hayes (The Conjuring), Joshua Zetumer (RoboCop), and Seth Grahame-Smith (Abraham Lincoln: Vampire Hunter) all making attempts to punch up the horror after studio boss Stacey Snider decided it should be a straight horror movie, and not the teen drama/horror hybrid Fox originally greenlit. Boone would then do his own revisions, often removing the changes that had been made. Things came to a head before cameras rolled in 2017, with a roundtable assembled made up of some of those uncredited writers and Logan scribe Scott Frank. They "delivered a roundelay of critiques, pointing out lapses in logic, deficits of humor, and underdeveloped characters." Still, Boone pushed back. 

Shooting obviously did end up happening, and that takes us back to Fox's unhappiness with what was delivered to them. A high ranking Fox executive tells the site, "You could throw the movie out, start over, and it would still be the least expensive X-Men movie so far." That's something they seriously considered, and it wouldn't be overly surprising if Kinberg was hoping to take charge of the project as he did Fantastic Four...with even more disastrous results. 

Ultimately, it seems a clash in visions was the problem here, and which party was to blame will likely remain a talking point for years to come (five years on and Josh Trank's Marvel movie is still widely discussed and debated). Now, The New Mutants is opening in the midst of a pandemic and, much to the relief of most fans, the rights to the X-Men are back with Marvel Studios. For those willing to risk a trip to the theater, they'll get to see the version of the movie Fox wanted to throw out before the Disney/Fox merger halted those plans. If that truly is Boone's vision, though, at least he's been able to share it...

DISCLAIMER: Comic Book Movie is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and... [MORE]
Related Headlines
THE NEW MUTANTS Has Become A Surprise, Sleeper Hit On Video-On-Demand Platforms

THE NEW MUTANTS Has Become A Surprise, Sleeper Hit On Video-On-Demand Platforms

After a disappointing run at the box office, there's finally some good news for The New Mutants because the Marvel movie has gone straight to the top of VOD charts. Find out more details after the jump...
THE NEW MUTANTS Honest Trailer Definitely Doesn't Shy Away From Skewering Fox's Final X-MEN Film

THE NEW MUTANTS Honest Trailer Definitely Doesn't Shy Away From Skewering Fox's Final X-MEN Film

We finally have an Honest Trailer for Josh Boone's The New Mutants, and it won't surprise you to learn that Fox's final X-Men film takes an absolute beating from the hilarious team at Screen Junkies!
THE NEW MUTANTS Blu-ray Fixes A Mistake In The Credits Of The Theatrical Version Of The Movie

THE NEW MUTANTS Blu-ray Fixes A Mistake In The Credits Of The Theatrical Version Of The Movie

A crucial mistake was made in The New Mutants' credits when it came to one of the team's creators, but that's thankfully been fixed in the Blu-ray and Digital releases of the Marvel Comics movie.
THE NEW MUTANTS: Sunspot Ogles Magik In New Deleted Scene From The Upcoming Blu-ray

THE NEW MUTANTS: Sunspot Ogles Magik In New Deleted Scene From The Upcoming Blu-ray

Ahead of the upcoming Blu-ray release of The New Mutants, a new deleted scene featuring a conversation between Sunspot (Henry Zaga) and Magik (Anya Taylor-Joy) has been released online. Check it out...
THE NEW MUTANTS Concept Art Reveals A Very Different Take On The Monstrous Demon Bear

THE NEW MUTANTS Concept Art Reveals A Very Different Take On The Monstrous Demon Bear

The New Mutants didn't exactly end Fox's X-Men Universe on a high note, but this must-see new concept art gives us a better idea of the work that went into bringing the monstrous Demon Bear to life...
Latest Headlines
New MORBIUS Still Features Jared Leto's Living Vampire Alongside Adria Arjona As Martine Bancroft

New MORBIUS Still Features Jared Leto's Living Vampire Alongside Adria Arjona As Martine Bancroft

A new image from Sony Pictures' Morbius movie has found its way online, giving us another look at Jared Leto as Doctor Michael Morbius alongside his love interest Martine Bancroft (Adria Arjona).
DEVIL'S REIGN Finale Details Reveal More About Kingpin's Evil Plans For The Marvel Comics Universe

DEVIL'S REIGN Finale Details Reveal More About Kingpin's Evil Plans For The Marvel Comics Universe

Marvel Comics has revealed details about the final batch of Devil's Reign issues, including intel on the final instalment of the event series and a bunch of tie-ins. Check out that and cover art here...
CATWOMAN Star Halle Berry Reveals Why She Chose To Accept Her Razzie For The Movie In Person

CATWOMAN Star Halle Berry Reveals Why She Chose To Accept Her Razzie For The Movie In Person

The Razzies don't really generate the sort of attention they once did, but Halle Berry showing up in 2005 to receive her "Worst Actress" award made a lot of headlines. Now, she's explained her attendance.
SPIDER-MAN: NO WAY HOME Posters Pit The Web-Slinger And Doctor Strange Against A Sinister Host Of Villains

SPIDER-MAN: NO WAY HOME Posters Pit The Web-Slinger And Doctor Strange Against A Sinister Host Of Villains

Two new posters for Spider-Man: No Way Home have swung online, both of which see Peter Parker and Stephen Strange suit up for an epic battle against a sinister group of villains. Check them out here...
METAL MEN Gearing Up As Animated Movie From SPACE JAM: A NEW LEGACY And THE LITTLE MERMAID Writers

METAL MEN Gearing Up As Animated Movie From SPACE JAM: A NEW LEGACY And THE LITTLE MERMAID Writers

Earlier this year, filmmaker Barry Sonnenfeld revealed he's still developing Metal Men for Warner Bros., but it's being reported that an animated version is in the works from an intriguing creative team.
SPIDER-MAN: NO WAY HOME Star Tom Holland Reveals The Movie's First Deleted Scene - Minor SPOILERS

SPIDER-MAN: NO WAY HOME Star Tom Holland Reveals The Movie's First Deleted Scene - Minor SPOILERS

Spider-Man: No Way Home star Tom Holland recently appeared on BBC's The Graham Norton Show, and revealed that one key scene we saw in set photos has ended up being cut from the movie. Read on for details!
THE PUNISHER Star Jon Bernthal Has No Interest In Returning As A Watered-Down Version Of Frank Castle

THE PUNISHER Star Jon Bernthal Has No Interest In Returning As A Watered-Down Version Of Frank Castle

Could we see Jon Bernthal reprise the role of Frank Castle in the Marvel Cinematic Universe? It could happen, but the King Richard actor has no interest in returning as a watered-down take on The Punisher.
SPIDER-MAN: NO WAY HOME - Amazing New 4DX Poster Sees The World Against Peter Parker

SPIDER-MAN: NO WAY HOME - Amazing New 4DX Poster Sees The World Against Peter Parker

The Spider-Man: No Way Home posters are definitely improving, as this 4DX effort sees a crestfallen Peter Parker overlooking a snowy New York City that's clearly turned against the heroic wall-crawler.