First Reactions from San Diego Comic-Con Screening of DREDD Surface Online

Following the preview screening that was held this evening at San Diego Comic-Con, various media outlets have shared their thoughts on Pete Travis' reboot movie, Dredd, via Twitter. Are they positive, or negative? Find out for yourself after the jump...

Follow Jolt17:
By Jolt17 - 7/12/2012
And the reactions are mostly positive! Check out some of the reactions, coming from numerous sites such as /Film (Peter Sciretta), Collider (Steven Weintraub), AMC Theatres (John Campea), and many others right below...





































Additionally, here's the longer version of Empire's reaction toward the movie.

We're delighted to say that it's a solid, often excellent adaptation, and not at all Dreddful. (Sorry, had to do it.) Karl Urban is excellent as the grizzled gunslinger (and yes, the helmet stays on throughout, which will please fans of the comic no end), growling his lines like a man who's just gritted his driveway using only his teeth, and the ultra-violence (which, in a way, may please fans while damaging its commercial chances) is presented stylishly. It has problems - it's bound to suffer comparisons to The Raid, with which it shares a basic plot, but has little of the invention or pulsating pace of that movie's fight scenes. It has a significantly smaller budget than the rest of this year's comic book movie crop, and at times it shows. But it's worth seeing for Urban alone, who erases any memories of the awful Sly Stallone vehicle from 1995.


UPDATE: Yet another lengthy reaction has made its way online, this time coming from Total Film. Check it out right below...

Despite rumours of rifts during production, Garland and Travis have created a horribly gorgeous vision of dystopian future where monolithic housing towers are run by criminal gangs - and policing is undertaken by judge/jury/execution officers, Judges. Urban certainly has the downturned mouth and super-cool, gravelly delivery to pull off Dredd's nonchalance but he's aided by Garland's smart, fast script, a relentless flow of Rorschach Test blood sprays from bone-shattering brutality, eye-poppingly beautiful 3D visuals and peppy banter with Thirlby. The body count is high, the humour grim and the violence stylishly graphic and reminiscent of Sin City (scenes involving a drug called Slo-Mo are visually intoxicating).


Several sites have also promised that they will debut their full reviews of the movie later on, so stay tuned on CBM for more Dredd reports. Anyway, what do you think of these? As usual, sound off with your thoughts on the space provided below.


The story of Dredd takes place on an Earth ravaged by the Atomic Wars. Survivors of this world live within "Mega-Cities", gargantuan urban sprawls which protect its citizens from the Cursed Earth, a radioactive desert environment populated by mutants. The main story takes place in Mega-City One, where its police force, known as judges have the power of judge, jury and executioner to thwart crime. One man, Judge Dredd, a senior Judge, teams up with rookie Judge Anderson to stop drug dealer Ma-Ma and her traffic of the reality-altering drug Slo-Mo. Directed by Pete Travis and starring Karl Urban, Olivia Thirlby, and Lena Headey, the movie is set to be released on September 21, 2012.


DISCLAIMER: This article was submitted by a volunteer contributor who has agreed to our code of conduct. ComicBookMovie.com is protected from liability under "safe harbor" provisions and will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. For expeditious removal, contact us HERE.
9
LIKE!
56 Comments
1 2
BenderDickCumPatch - 7/12/2012, 1:24 AM


CAN'T [frick]ING WAIT.
RidiculousFanBoyDemands - 7/12/2012, 1:27 AM
Yes!! violence!! This movie will get slammed by critics but I will love it.
lunesta - 7/12/2012, 1:30 AM
if its michael bay violence
CoolantTech - 7/12/2012, 1:33 AM
I will be checking this out, these Twitter reactions won me over
SageMode - 7/12/2012, 1:40 AM
Wow. I surely wasn't expecting that. I might give this a peek.
musashi - 7/12/2012, 1:55 AM
Sounds great! I'm sold!
ChiefJudge - 7/12/2012, 1:56 AM
Prepare for Judgement Day
White - 7/12/2012, 1:58 AM
YES!
R888 - 7/12/2012, 2:12 AM
YES YES YES
SKetCH - 7/12/2012, 2:22 AM
It's violence compared to 'Starship Troopers'??

I've been waitin' for a movie to come CLOSE to Starship's gore.

Sign me up. Two times!!
INSTANTJUSTICE - 7/12/2012, 3:24 AM
I did try to tell y'all.
KingEmperor - 7/12/2012, 3:31 AM
Could this movie be this generation's "The Crow"?
marvel72 - 7/12/2012, 3:36 AM
violent,just what i wanted to hear,i hope it makes enough money to warrent a sequel......

JUDGE DEATH NEEDS MOVIE LOVE!
5T0N3R - 7/12/2012, 3:38 AM
the day the law died or america for a sequel please, the dark judges for the 3rd, my jizz doth bubble over for this move :)
INSTANTJUSTICE - 7/12/2012, 3:39 AM
"Could this movie be this generation's "The Crow"?" -KingEmperor


No, it's better.
Maia87 - 7/12/2012, 3:50 AM
"Think I just saw the most violent movie I've ever seen in my life!"

poor lil' girl.
timotey - 7/12/2012, 3:54 AM
Awesome review here: http://io9.com/5925364/dredd-is-a-brutal-action-flick-with-both-a-high-body-count-and-a-brain No real spoilers. I hope it's a hit. Karl Urban deserves one.
Nomis1800 - 7/12/2012, 3:58 AM
Of course it's fun.
Chewtoy - 7/12/2012, 4:19 AM
Cool... It's good to hear this kind of thing after the trailer underwhelmed.
Jollem - 7/12/2012, 4:19 AM
i hope it's good
DetBullock - 7/12/2012, 4:29 AM
The review posted by @timotey and the articles from Empire and Total film get my hopes about this film up more than any twitter buzz.
Jimdlux - 7/12/2012, 4:31 AM
Not 1 negative Tweet...yea, only 13 positive ones... The trailer looked boring...
BenderDickCumPatch - 7/12/2012, 4:50 AM
I can't wait for little kids to bitch and whine how much this movie sucks because its violent and has blood in it. Oh and lack of story makes a movie suck, in the action genre....Oh and yes they will complain.


CrowPirate1 - 7/12/2012, 5:19 AM
YAY!!!

I just friggin LOVE movies that make NO excuses for just being as violent as they want!!

I hate the friggin correct side of wanking Hollywood. Leave us the blood filled horror and action movies that we want to see and love..

and you make your "chick flick love touchy feely" crap I will forever avoid!!
AlexDeLarge87 - 7/12/2012, 5:25 AM
Cant wait.

Definitely going to watch in theater. :)

Would like to see red band trailer for this.

Really hope its success so we can get a big budget sequels for it.
inky - 7/12/2012, 5:31 AM
what the general public need to realize is that judge dredd was born of a violent era and his attitude is of that era wich makes him more dirty harry than your more politicaly correct police of today.
his is a world surviving the brink of extermination where corruption and genocide are hand in hand, even when the halls of justice were corrupted this one man stood for the law with out wavering.
stalones JD was an attempt at creating the market for DC comics this was partly why it was so bad and so mixed up ABC warriors did not exist in the JD world.
but that aside for a stalone it was good but this new reboot feels far better and shouldnt be overly messed with by the powers that be.
jimoakley666 - 7/12/2012, 5:41 AM
That was all VERY positive. Been looking forward to this since I hard of it and this has boosted my anticipation glands.
Bandrews1 - 7/12/2012, 6:04 AM
That's all I needed to know, it looks like this could wind up being a sleeper hitt.
ABLEE337 - 7/12/2012, 6:07 AM
Awesome, can't wait to see it!!!
CrimsonReign - 7/12/2012, 6:11 AM
I must say that these early reviews have me shocked. I expected lots of negativity, but this sounds good.
bagadoosh - 7/12/2012, 6:15 AM
Urban is excellent he was fantastic and probably the best part of star trek IMO , I hope this does well enough for a sequel but 50 million may be a tall order .
ISeeStupidPeople - 7/12/2012, 6:23 AM
I don't recognize any of these people. [frick] Twitter.

I hope it's good, but Twitter won't get any rise out of me.
ZombieOverEasy - 7/12/2012, 6:37 AM
I really want this movie to be good. The Verhoeven comment sold me, I'll be there opening week!
RamonSuarez - 7/12/2012, 6:47 AM
Nice reviews.
INSTANTJUSTICE - 7/12/2012, 6:55 AM
"I must say that these early reviews have me shocked. I expected lots of negativity, but this sounds good."- CrimsonReign


I think that's because a lot of people don't get what Dredd and this film is representing which is not in anyway anythign like Stallone and his film.

Dredd done well is better than anything else in serial comics.
dreddhead123 - 7/12/2012, 6:56 AM
Dredd needs one more trailer. Released mid-August. Needs to show a bit more of the action, perhaps Judge Dredd's lawgiver and the various bullet modes. Something like that would help get more interest in the film. I don't think one trailer is enough.
Talontd - 7/12/2012, 7:32 AM
Sold!
Ceejay - 7/12/2012, 7:35 AM
All I'm hearing is that the film is bloody violent, violence don't make a great film, story and production does.
dreddhead123 - 7/12/2012, 7:54 AM
"All I'm hearing is that the film is bloody violent, violence don't make a great film, story and production does."

Amen, bro! DNA Films seem to think Dredd (and it's JUDGE DREDD, Sheesh! - how hard is it get the damn name right!) is just violence. John Wagner's gift as a writer: tell a good story. He's never deviated from that basic rule. If John Wagner is the Mount Everest of comic book writers, I fear Alex Garland is the ant hill. :P
j0hnb1aze - 7/12/2012, 8:09 AM
As an atheist, I'd rather to go church than this movie...
storyteller - 7/12/2012, 8:35 AM
The thing about the Raid comparisons is that simply, in the US not many people have even heard of the film much less seen it. So basically it's a pointless comparison if it's trying to be used as a negative or positive.
TheBlackPhantom994 - 7/12/2012, 8:43 AM
Even grif has hope...holy shit. I knew this would be a hit!
Dedpool - 7/12/2012, 8:44 AM
HOLLAJULIA!!!
Danbojohnj - 7/12/2012, 8:50 AM
No whiny girlfriend/father soul serching spandex bollocks,just some good old fascist ultra violence.

Can.Not.Wait.
ralfinader - 7/12/2012, 9:28 AM
If it makes it way out to my theater in BFE, I'll see it. Sounds great, and read a couple of positive reviews. The first Dredd was a glaring disappointment, and this sounds like it has it beaten, which I assumed it would with Urban's ability to just own a role.
ralfinader - 7/12/2012, 9:30 AM
storyteller - 7/12/2012, 8:35 AM
Report Comment The thing about the Raid comparisons is that simply, in the US not many people have even heard of the film much less seen it. So basically it's a pointless comparison if it's trying to be used as a negative or positive.

Very true. I only knew about the Raid from reading about it in on this site when the first comparisons began a month or so ago. After learning the Raid and Dredd were in production almost at the same time, I didn't care about the Raid anymore, I wanted Dredd.
Oxbow - 7/12/2012, 9:53 AM
I'm glad that the early word on the twittersphere is good. Hell, I don't want to see this, but as a die hard comic book fan I will still feel like a proud uncle if Dredd does well.
Love the Verhoeven ans staship trooper analogies btw!!
JULEZ13 - 7/12/2012, 9:58 AM
Violence?!? Did someone say endless violence! My boyfriend will love this. AND Rated R violence?!? Mmmmhmmmm... We in there!

All good reviews, I'm excited for this now. Didn't really follow it, just heard many fanboys saying it'll flop, looks like they were all wrong!
bane187 - 7/12/2012, 10:01 AM
Awesome hope it gets the sequel
supermarioworldE - 7/12/2012, 10:08 AM
Robocop was essentially a Dredd movie anyway, so I'm glad that this is more like that and less like the cheesy Stallone version.
1 2

Please log in to post comments.

Don't have an account?
Please Register.

.