ComicBookMovie.com Start A Fansite!
You are not currently logged in. Login

Taylor Swift to Play Supergirl?

The Grammy award winner may be in the running to star in a Supergirl movie and TV series.


That's right, rumor has it that studio bosses want Taylor Swift to portray Kara Zor-El, most commonly known as Supergirl, in a new live-action endeavor.

An unnamed source spoke with Undercover.com about the reason behind the possible casting choice:

"Hollywood is short of female heroes and the time is right for a new Supergirl."

"A number of young stars are being mentioned for the title role in a 'Supergirl’ movie and possible TV spin-off and Taylor is top of that list. She has all the right elements to be a positive role model to young girls."


Swift's only acting credit so far is from guest starring on Saturday Night Live. He first venture into feature films will be Valentine's Day, playing the role of Samantha Kenny.



The character of Supergirl first appeared in comic books in 1959. Actress Helen Slater portrayed the character in the 1984 'Supergirl’ movie, which was a critical and box office flop.

MPP - I think Taylor has tremendous talent as a singer, musician and songwriter. In my opinion, she's very attractive in a 'girl next door' kind of way. That being said, is this really the first major role that an unproven acting hopeful should take? Especially with a comic character that mainstream audiences aren't very familiar with? I don't think so. This would be the equivalent of casting a Backstreet Boy as Tony Stark.



7 Yes
11 No
MultiPurposePoni
12/17/2009
Undercover.com

DISCLAIMER: This posting was submitted by a user of the site not from Comic Book Movie editorial staff. All users have acknowledged and agreed that the submission of their content is in compliance with our Terms of Use. For removal of copyrighted material, please contact us HERE.

107 Comments

If they're looking to make a movie starring a female hero, they damn well better make Wonder Woman first.
tazmaniak - 12/17/2009, 10:32 PM
This....would...suck....

Wasn't this info already posted earlier?
thehumantorch - 12/17/2009, 10:33 PM
@kenny: Damn right

@humantorch: I dunno. The boss asked me to put this up, so I did

Oh, if you guys get the chance, give me some feedback on my Avengers Trilogy Cast and Storylines over in Fan Fic
MultiPurposePoni - 12/17/2009, 10:35 PM
@Poni...

There's a good chance I just read it somewhere else, and just assumed I read it here, since I spend most of my spare time on this site ;)

It's a good article, but I really hope this rumor doesn't fly...
thehumantorch - 12/17/2009, 10:42 PM
It's all good man. I've only had about an hour a day to check this site over the past week, so I hope I'm not treading on someone else article.

BTW, love the avatar! My kiddos collect those things :)
MultiPurposePoni - 12/17/2009, 10:47 PM
personally i wouldnt cast her. I would look around more. i saw her performance on SNL and tho it was live i still think she doesnt look the part. I would rather have a girl with some muscle too. not massive muscles but at least gymnast size proportions.
theartofoneness - 12/17/2009, 10:51 PM
Oh yeah, that would be awesome.

Then John Krasinski should be Lex Luthor. And Drew Carey should be Lois. And Dana Carvey can be Bizarro.
Fartman - 12/17/2009, 10:53 PM
"This would be the equivalent of casting a Backstreet Boy as Tony Stark. "

You find the video "I want it that way", you find the one named Kevin in the trenchcoat, and you tell me that didn't look like Sean Chen's Tony Stark from Heroes Return.

Swift is like, over 6' tall, I think she can pull something off. Either Kara or even an amazon like Cassie or a young Donna/Diana.

(stupid question: how to you post an image when replying?)
Pyche - 12/17/2009, 10:54 PM
Instigatorgirl originally posted this under a rather derogitory heading. I thought it was funny, but well... I could accept her if she can carry the role. Look at Justin Timberlake, I would not have watched him in anything out of principle. Then Alphadog and his stuff with The Lonely Island made me think twice.
Ugh - 12/17/2009, 11:06 PM
Well if they do her first villain can be Kanye West. I also heard they were gonna cast Hanna Montana as Wonder Woman. LOL! Kidding!
animeex - 12/17/2009, 11:21 PM
Whoop. n/m figured it out


Pyche - 12/17/2009, 11:21 PM
I'm alright with this, maybe I'm just still cheery from IM2 Trailer but still, could be worse, DC better start pumping out more movies then just the dvds.
ClintEastwood - 12/17/2009, 11:29 PM
No disrespect to Taylor Swift...but i think that Hayden Girl from Heroes would be a better choice for a supergirl series then her... LOL!

And that may bot even be the BEST for the role either...

Sorry but no thanks for Swift...

If it wasn't for Jamie Foxx I NEVER would've even Heard of Taylor Swift or even paid attention to that Award show at all...
NubaX - 12/17/2009, 11:30 PM
InstigatorGirl did post this in the last few days but like Ugh said it was more an editorial. I looked at her site and don't see it anymore so either she or CBM deleted it.
DogsOfWar - 12/17/2009, 11:35 PM
WTF???

Why did INSTIGATOR GIRL'S article on this get delete yesterday if its true?!?

As for TAYLOR SWIFT,, [frick] NO! ; D

ELISHA CUTHBERT makes a great SUPERGIRL!


LEEE777 - 12/17/2009, 11:35 PM
Great their talking about a SUPERGIRL movie though! ; P


As for a TV series, [frick]ing LAURA VANDERVOORT!!!



: D
LEEE777 - 12/17/2009, 11:39 PM
Damn straight Leee. The industry is really trying to make Swift the next it girl.
Shadowelfz - 12/17/2009, 11:41 PM
She's a pretty decent actress, actually.
MovieTheaterLad - 12/17/2009, 11:44 PM
Shadowelfz @ ; D

[frick], next we'll be getting [frick]ing BRITNEY SPEARS as POWERGIRL, and BEYONCE as WONDER WOMAN!! : D
LEEE777 - 12/17/2009, 11:45 PM
Taylor Swift is a talented artist, if allowed she may suprise a lot of people. Singers can be actors. Cher, a singer, is an Oscar winner. If they did decide for a female superhero, I'd much rather see Wonder Woman. Katy Perry looks like a clone of Lynda Carter and she would be my pick.

JesuCrisco - 12/17/2009, 11:46 PM
Beyonce for wonder woman LOL
MightyThor1 - 12/17/2009, 11:53 PM
Hey Taylor I'm gonna let you do this, but Superman shoulda won and be the next DC Movie
DogsOfWar - 12/17/2009, 11:59 PM





Katy Perry for WW?
JesuCrisco - 12/18/2009, 12:03 AM
I don't care what character they use to get the ball rolling on, so long as this leads to more characters being developed. Hell, Marvel didn't really kick off till Blade got released. The dude was a forth stringer for crying out loud.
Ugh - 12/18/2009, 12:04 AM
if katy [frick]ing perry is cast as wonder woman then i quit [frick]ing life.
deathmetalbrian - 12/18/2009, 12:29 AM
if katy [frick]ing perry is cast as wonder woman then i quit [frick]ing life.
deathmetalbrian - 12/18/2009, 12:30 AM
Katy Perry for Wonder Woman???


Phinehas - 12/18/2009, 12:45 AM
wow...i've always loved the flavor of my own vomit.
Weeton - 12/18/2009, 1:00 AM
hahaha vomiting over a pretty girl..idk..kinda strange..but no 2 swift as supergirl...she's jus hillary duff's doppleganger...

@deathmetalbrian = parrot

~X
XmutantX - 12/18/2009, 1:10 AM
UGH@ u aint dissin on snipes now r u?!?!?!
XmutantX - 12/18/2009, 1:11 AM
MULTI@ we missed u in the otha blog...they were sayin thor may be in iron man 2...i said no cus in thors movie he begins in asgard....but hell yes 2 captain america cameo or lead off in2 the 1st avenger! we all thought of u and wanted ur input!!!
~X
XmutantX - 12/18/2009, 1:14 AM
phine@ WRONGE!!! hahahaha sweet
XmutantX - 12/18/2009, 1:15 AM
nobody is going to go see a movie staring any female super hero. There is no appeal to the average guy to see a chick beat up a bunch of dudes. I for one would never go to see a wonder woman movie and look how well elektra and catwoman did.
andyoung2002 - 12/18/2009, 1:26 AM
@xmutantx- Heck no, dude turned a forgotten horror comic supporting character into a first rate badass. Just wish the guy could pull it together and get us better quality movies. Snipes could play a heck of a Luke Cage.
Ugh - 12/18/2009, 1:33 AM
Taylor Swift should star as Taylor Swift not even thinking about this role.
shibazz - 12/18/2009, 1:33 AM
IDK about this. im just waiting for the article that says Kanye west thinks beyonce would be a better choice....
Peteyparker - 12/18/2009, 2:25 AM
KATY PERRY for WW, ffs???!!! OMG lol! : D

HILLARY DUFF as the SUPERGIRL clone MATRIX! : P

LEX LUTHER as JUSTIN TIMBERLAKE! ; D

PHINES @ Lmao man!!!!
LEEE777 - 12/18/2009, 3:47 AM
KATY PERRY LOOKS PRETTY HOT THOUGH..YOU WANNA GO OVER AND JUST GRAB HER...
GUNSMITH - 12/18/2009, 3:53 AM
this is unholy
grif - 12/18/2009, 4:28 AM
Why did the other article by InstigatorGirl get deleted?

This won't happen. It's pretty obvious that Swift won't play Supergirl, I don't think that WB, even though they have their heads up their asses when it comes to DC films, are THAT stupid.

Swift is 5'11" BTW.

And Kristen Bell for Supergirl
InTylerWeTrust - 12/18/2009, 4:35 AM
swift is toooooooo skinny

I think she can act, at least she was pretty good on SNL, but she is wrong for soopygirl
BubbaDude - 12/18/2009, 4:49 AM
at least they have put ideas together to make a supergirl movie.
StrangemannX09 - 12/18/2009, 5:34 AM
Taylor certainly could pull off the look, not to sure about her acting ability yet tho. I liked the girl from Smallville as Supergirl personally. But they should really be focused on a new SuperMAN movie in my opinion
dxperry - 12/18/2009, 5:42 AM
Wow... thw WB has been spreadin' heavy on the retard butter!!! WTFF?!?!?!?!?!?

I own the Supergirl movie and my all time favorite Michael J. Fox movie was "The Secret of my Success" which also starred Helen Slater. I remembered her to be sooooo beautiful and i just saw her recently in the fourth season of Supernatural. I had no idea how many years had passed. She's practically unrecognisable!!! She still looked like a decent 50 year old MILF but damn... such a surprise.
Shaman - 12/18/2009, 5:44 AM
Where's the "Oh HELL NO!" selection for this poll? The little girl can barely sing, let alone ACT!

I agree with Kenny - Wonder Woman FIRST!

JesuCristo - Katy Perry - SERIOUSLY?!!! KeepItReal, were are you when I need you (LMFAO!)?!!

LEEE brings up a good point - if we're talking Supergirl, ther can be only one... and her name is Cuthbert, Elisha Cuthbert!

Shaman - don't forget, Slater also got to play Lara (Clark's Kryptonian mom) in Smallville (nice little humorous twist there...)
loganoneil - 12/18/2009, 6:33 AM
No one saw her on CSI?
She did alright but i'm not sure if that makes her a good Supergirl. I'd still like to see her in tights though!!
glmeyer - 12/18/2009, 6:38 AM
I think she is the perfect build for supergirl. Petite and gorgeous but with that Kryptonian punch with some acting lessons and a good graphics team, it could make me believe a hot blonde chick could fly.
batfan39 - 12/18/2009, 6:40 AM
ELISHA CUTHBERT FOR POWERGIRL!!! Supergirl too LOL :P











Shaman - 12/18/2009, 6:42 AM
I think Swift is a talented singer but lets wait on giving her a big screen role. As for how a Supergirl movie would do dont compare it to catwoman and Eletkra cuz i thought both of those sucked. If you got the right actress a good script and a good director a Supergirl film could do very well. But i think another Superman should be done first before Supergirl. Then maybe WW or Supergirl in what ever order. I do agree with the earlier post Katy perry has nice ****.
BrutalDuke - 12/18/2009, 7:08 AM
I'd have to see her act first. I'm not gonna say nay to her though. Remember when Will Smith was just a rapper who played the Fresh Prince (not that it was a bad show, FP was awesome) Never expected him to become the serious actor he is today.
Runefyst - 12/18/2009, 7:21 AM
The problem is that if they do a Supergirl movie, they'll probably end up leaving out Superman. The fact remains that if you don't show Superman in the film, you're gonna piss fans off. We all know that if they make this movie, it will be just like the 80s Supergirl movie--no Superman. Lame.
Spectre1983 - 12/18/2009, 7:34 AM
I actually prefer Will Smith in Fresh Prince than in any other film he's made. I'm REALLY NOT a fan of his. Yes... i've seen all the films he's been in that people rave about. I still hate him.
Shaman - 12/18/2009, 7:35 AM
@ Poni, Taylor Swift was also on an episode of CSI not too long ago I believe it was this year even and she did great.
Kratos6 - 12/18/2009, 7:37 AM
Taylor Swift needs to put on a heck of a lot of weight
SoulAllFlush - 12/18/2009, 7:52 AM
Give it to Laura Vandervoort, at least she has played her and has the look and everything. I liked her in Smallville.
Timerider84 - 12/18/2009, 7:58 AM
Who is Taylor Swift? I've never seen her in anything and she looks extremely undersized for the role. Whats wrong with Laura Vandervoort from Smallville? She's cute enough,famaliar with the part,and can actually act.
BLADE4040 - 12/18/2009, 8:01 AM
Shaman nice pic as usual...Im surprised you dont like any of Will Smith's work. Bad Boys, Enemy of the State,Pursuit of Happiness and I could go on. He's done well for an ex-kool-aid rapper and CLOWN of Fresh Prince. Well to each it's own that's what make's the world an interesting place. We all have diffrent reasons why we like or dislike something or someone.
BLADE4040 - 12/18/2009, 8:11 AM
It appears that not many people know this, but she actually guest-starred on CSI last season and her performance was not that bad for an amateur. She was a very believable teenager, and you honestly felt bad for her character's death.

As much as I love Taylor, I don't think she's meant to be Supergirl. I think she'd actually be better for Wonder Girl somewhere down the road. And they do HAVE to put Superman in the movie to give it any degree of validity. The original Supergirl movie with Helen Slater was pretty awful.
Morpheus - 12/18/2009, 8:18 AM
I just think Katy Perry looks a little like Lynda Carter. Who says guys won't watch women in a hero role? Underworld? Tomb Raider?
JesuCrisco - 12/18/2009, 8:21 AM
I liked Laura V from Smallville!Tay Swift does kind of have the look but I cant really see her throwing a punch. She is very talented tho
IronMarvel - 12/18/2009, 8:24 AM
Oh sure they want to make a Supergirl movie but not a Wonder Woman movie.
airbeyonder18 - 12/18/2009, 8:56 AM
Booo Elisha Cuthbert for Supergirl!!!

"Yo Taylor Swift I'ma real happy for yall and Ima let you finish..but Helen Slater was the best Supergirl of all time...ALL TIME!!"

Seriously though if it's a tv series just stick with Laura Vanderhoot or whatever her name is from Smallville.
Ryden - 12/18/2009, 8:58 AM
this is BS Taylor Swift will never be Supergirl. Kanye West behaviour made this girl too popular she should be thanking Kanye West big time with her career lol.

Amber Heard should be Supergirl


jazzman - 12/18/2009, 9:50 AM
Shes hot but nooooo way, I dont want some country singing chick who cant act for shit to play Supergirl

@DogsOfWar
I was waiting for that lol
dancingmonkey08 - 12/18/2009, 10:43 AM
@ Pyche i've been trying to figure that out for a while. somebody on yahoo answers tried to explain it but its just too complicated....

http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index;_ylt=AjPaJW4g80H5qb6UC8PoQJXty6IX;_ylv=3?qid=20091204141530AAsK0SQ
Fartman - 12/18/2009, 11:31 AM
holy shit! idk who Amber Heard is but she has the perfect face for what i want in a Supergirl! The suit is pretty cool too... could be a bit different for my taste but its a solid picture to sell ur point. IM SOLD!!!

HINKLEY - 12/18/2009, 11:32 AM
JAZZ @ Ummm..... Nahhhh!!





; D


Hey who is that AMBER anyway?? She don't look too bad dude!
LEEE777 - 12/18/2009, 12:36 PM
@HINKLEY + LEEE777

Amber Heard is a actress she was in Never Back Down, Pineapple Express and Zombieland




jazzman - 12/18/2009, 12:39 PM
As much as I like TAYLOR SWIFT, who i saw growing up about 10 minutes from my house here in PA and sang the national anthems at Reading Philles games this is not a job shes "perfect" for.

She is a sweet girl and is a good role model but someone thought too much of her appearence on CSI to think shes ready to take on a lead role like this. This is a job for some who looks closer to the part and who has a some kind of an acting abilty.

I could see her be in the tv series and play a part in it but not for the lead role. the bottom line is someone is trying to capitalize on her fame right now and doesnt see past the name. Sorry, I love her but shes not the perfect fit at this time in her career. If I saw her in a few more things I might change my mind but sorry, not now.
brianj22 - 12/18/2009, 12:52 PM
in responce to Ryden's comments

--------------------------------------------------

Booo Elisha Cuthbert for Supergirl!!!

Um, why? shes be great in the part! She not only has the look but she is bad ass and can pull it off. im all for Elisha doing it, but...read below.

-----------------------------------------------------

"Yo Taylor Swift I'ma real happy for yall and Ima let you finish..but Helen Slater was the best Supergirl of all time...ALL TIME!!"

Um, you realize that HS is the only one who has ever portrayed Supergirl in a movie right? not like the list is long or anything.

-------------------------------------------------------

Seriously though if it's a tv series just stick with Laura Vanderhoot or whatever her name is from Smallville.

Its Vandervoort and if there is a movie/smallville spin off series shes perfect for the job so why F around and hand it to someone else?

My pick is laura V first, but if she cant do it elisha is a great second choice.
brianj22 - 12/18/2009, 12:57 PM
In responce to airbeyonder18's comment

Oh sure they want to make a Supergirl movie but not a Wonder Woman movie.
--------------------------------------------------------

Um, they are making a WW movie. its an on again/off again thing. my sources say this will get settled by end of summer.

brianj22 - 12/18/2009, 12:59 PM
NOOOOOO!!!!!! Elisha Cuthbert for Supergirl!!!
TheCritic17 - 12/18/2009, 1:49 PM
what the hell is with this love affair the world has with this girl?

until the Kanye incident i had never even heard of her. her music is terrible, basically the country equivalent of bubble gum britney spears pop of 10 years ago.

also, while i understand the whole thought of role model for young girls thing that supposedly the studios want. the majority of people going to see this movie are going to be guys. Guys are the ones who will be shelling out 10 bucks a ticket to go see a hot girl in a skin tight top and short skirt kicking ass.

i understand wanting someone girls can look up to, but if they cast Swift, they are basically just making another turd like the Supergirl movie from the 80s
l0rdleg0las - 12/18/2009, 2:04 PM
people are just hating for no reason. is she right for the role?? probably not. but half the people complaining about her are saying she should "stick to singing", or "she can barely sing". and instigatorgirl's article straight up called her a tard.

lets learn about the people you guys bash before you start bashing.

first of all, the girl can sing. i don't care what you guys think. she has more talent in her pinky than brittany spears, christina aguilera, lady gaga, and all these other so called "divas" combined.

second, unless you've seen the things she's acted in (which clearly, most of you haven't) then don't hate. i haven't seen her act, but from what people on here have said, she's pretty decent.

and last, the "tard" comment. what exactly has she done to be called a tard?? NOTHING! on all accounts, she's a pretty respectable young lady. otherwise, we would be hearing all kinds of crazy shit about her in the news, like we do with actual famous "tards". (lohan and spears ring any bells??) we don't hear anything remotely close to that kind of stuff with her.

i understand if you don't want her to play supergirl, but relax. just because you think she's wrong for a part doesn't automatically condemn her to being a no talent hack.

this isn't directed at everyone, just the [frick]ing haters.

CorndogBurglar - 12/18/2009, 4:59 PM
im ok with it i seen he act and she was good better than other singers trying to act
flames809 - 12/18/2009, 6:03 PM
im ok with it i seen he act and she was good better than other singers trying to act
flames809 - 12/18/2009, 6:03 PM
I Hayden from HEROS all the way she is hot and has spunk... and HOT ;-)

Hayden 1

hayden 2
thegreek - 12/18/2009, 8:44 PM
I'm sorry, but Hayden P from Heroes is too damn tiny, as is Kristen Bell, so NO to them.

Laura Vandervoort 1st
Elisha Cuthbert 2nd
Amber Heard 3rd
Anybody else 4th

Taylor Swift, yeah she has the height and kinda the looks, but no acting talent. I would cast her Dead LAST.
Timerider84 - 12/18/2009, 9:57 PM
@timerider you would also be giving taylor swift the job as they would cast all them and get her last and cast her because of her popularity right now how about not cast her at all their is a longer list then this for super girl but your number one laura is who i would choose, hell just use the smallville cast for any future superman movies they are already succesful why not continue with that.
basically saying reboot

thegamedrex - 12/18/2009, 10:47 PM
I can definitely see someone else playing supergirl but not Taylor Swift
shahrazstate - 12/19/2009, 12:16 AM
Yeah I did post this and I understand why it was deleted I had it under a bad heading and it came off as offensive and I agreed with why it was deleted. I wrote it while angry at the news, so good article Multi ^_^
I don't think Swift could do it. I like some of the other choices others are saying except Hayden from Heroes... Not Supergirl. Also like Tyler said before in the article I posted. Doesn't seem right to bring in Supergirl when Superman has not gotten a proper reboot...
Bring in Wonder Woman if they want a female hero.
InstigatorGIRL - 12/19/2009, 12:31 AM
@Shaman Slater was also in the 7th? season of Smallville and I thought she looked great. Totally beautiful. She played Lara.
InstigatorGIRL - 12/19/2009, 12:38 AM
Why didn't they mention Laura Vandervoort as having played Supergirl? Anyway, I think they might as well give Taylor Swift a chance. She looks like Supergirl, and even though we haven't seen her act in anything else, nobody knew who Christopher Reeve, Tom Welling, or Brandon Routh were at first, either. Supergirl and Superman Returns were both dumb movies, but Helen Slater and Brandon Routh still played the parts well, so I say let Taylor audition, and if she stinks we will never speak of it again.
CaptainDunk - 12/19/2009, 8:09 AM
INSTIGATOR@ supernatural is only in the 5th season lol...
I luv cowgirlz!!!
~X
XmutantX - 12/19/2009, 10:35 AM
Jessica Biel + Bleach Blonde Hair = Supergirl
Talontd - 12/19/2009, 10:35 AM
@XmutantX. I know.... I never said anything about Supernatural I mention SMALLVILLE. lmao.
InstigatorGIRL - 12/19/2009, 3:04 PM
I had some witty comment to post, but looking at all the pics on the way down I seem to have forgotten what it was.
HouserepresentativeZod - 12/19/2009, 4:57 PM
Lady GaGa and Christian Aguilera are pure talnet and true artists. I would punch a bunny to get between either of those sets of thighs...mmmm i would kiss a rattlesnake to get in the middle of all four.
shibazz - 12/20/2009, 1:16 AM
@shibazz: who in the hell is your avatar a pic of? is that ol' girl from Reno 911?
IronClad - 12/20/2009, 2:00 AM
On the one hand you would find it hard to believe that they could screw this up by miscasting Taylor Swift as Supergirl, but then again if a director could cast Kate Bosworth as Lois Lane, the I guess that anything is possible.

Linda Vandervoort, IMO, was good, but not great as Kara. She lacks a little bit of intensity that being a superheroine entails. Looks, she's right on. Taylor Swift is too much of a waif.

Katy Perry should not be Wonder Woman. She's a little too short and she's pretty, but not gorgeous and Diana should be jaw-drop gorgeous.
serateigiburim - 12/20/2009, 6:28 AM
WHEN ARE THEY GONNA GET WONDER WOMAN ON SMALLVILLE?
GUNSMITH - 12/20/2009, 9:33 AM
instigator@ oops sorry...musta read it 2 fast...can i try on ur hat?? lol
Talontd@ beil?..alltho hott yes!! supergirl no!...lets pic a tru blonde here...(or r we 4getting alba with blong locks??)
jus pic a hott athletic blonde girl who can act and im down like a frown baby!
~X

Altho i agree...1st there should be superman or wonderwoman!!!
XmutantX - 12/20/2009, 10:28 AM
Gunsmith, I've been wondering that myself (pardon the pun). This is just a supposition, but it could be that the way that the character is intertwined with Greek mythology could be present a problem for the directors. On the other hand, they were able to do Zatanna's magic.
serateigiburim - 12/20/2009, 2:41 PM
I think Kristen Bell would make a great Superigirl.

She's damn hot, but she's also very sunny and spunky. Supergirl needs to be hot, but when she smiles she needs to light up the room, and to have the kind of irrepressible optimism that only Kristen could pull off.

There are other solid actresses already suggested though.

Beil and the like are hot, but are weak actors, and frankly, can't do much other than look hot. But that doesn't seem to matter to a lot of the guys up here... If thats all you're looking for in your female superheroes, thats fine...but you're also probably a misogynist :(
DannyRand401 - 12/20/2009, 3:00 PM
PLEASE GET SOMEONE WHO CAN ACT!!!! While there are great LOOKING actresses out there way too many ACTORS and ACTRESSES nowadays have one or two "FACES" and its like the studios don't even notice.. damn i feel like i'm take crazy pills...
darkblade - 12/20/2009, 5:20 PM
I like Elisha Cuthbert she is def a totally hotty you were right TImber - Hayden is to short ... Elisha ultimate hottie... YEEEAAHHHH
thegreek - 12/21/2009, 7:38 AM
CDB- True, we are jumping the gun but since we haven't seen anything of hers that we feel would help her become a worthy contender, it's easy for us to choose someone else. I also don't get why people are calling her a retard, i think the WB are the retards here. How about consider MORE actress, have auditions and THEN establish which one is best. It's retarded to just go with her without concidering others only because of her "example" towards teen girls which will change the moment she has cock.

InstigatorGIRL- Well i don't know what happened between Smallville 7 and Supernatural 4 but she wasn't all that. She was decent, but it was a surprising change. Don't think for one second that i though she was ugly, but she was waaaaaayyyyyyy prettier when she was young. It's weird but certain women actually look hotter with age while others don't.
Shaman - 12/21/2009, 9:57 AM
Taylor Swift, WTF, this has to be straight up BS rumor. Someone just wanting to start some buzz over the holiday weekend. First of all, if DC/WB does have plans for a female hero then they need to pay respect and focus on Wonder Women. That's the First Lady of the (female HERO) DC world who should get first dibs for own. I know the reason for a WW hold up, studio doesn't know the angle. Hey, Thor is in the same (type of realty), supposedly the plot of the movie will take place majority in Asguard. DC/WB needs to follow the same road for WW. On a side note, referring to someone else comment. The reason why WW isn't on Smallville is because the studio has her as a possible movie so it's hand's off.

As far as the thought of SG in her own movie, IMO that will not work. She's a 2nd tier character IMO, her character will only help as a supporting role in a DC movie. Regarding a thought for a TV show it's the same, Supergirl is best fit as a supporting role, it's best just to put her back on Smallville for now till a JLA or any other DC movie is green lit (as a supporting role). IMO as to who should play SG, my vote goes to Laura Vandervoort, she's played SG before and she's hot. There's a few hater's out there saying she's ugly, lol yeah ok, check out her pictures, she's about a 9 and any man wouldn't mind having her on their resume. Ol' Canada we Thank You for Laura.
blueorangeny - 12/21/2009, 10:28 AM
I kinda have to agree with blueorangeny.

DC has yet to make movies for one out of their top 3, let alone the rest of the Justice league. The only way I could see it happening is in a Superman sequel and that's it.
MovieTheaterLad - 12/21/2009, 8:43 PM
LEEE777 @.

Agree whit you, ELISHA CUTHBERT for SUPERGIRL.
She´s Beautiful and Sexy.
OSCURO - 12/22/2009, 8:37 AM
I agree with you kenny38606 that that may very well be a good idea, especially since people have been practically holding their breath over the yet to made (never-mind started) Wonder Woman movie.
abw2 - 12/22/2009, 5:57 PM
Right after this was posted Kanye West made an anouncement that although he's very happy for her Linda Carter made the best superheroine ever.
dccofer - 12/22/2009, 8:25 PM
JAZZ @ Cool!

OSCURO @ Heck yeah!!! ; )
LEEE777 - 12/23/2009, 2:10 PM
I don't know if Taylor can act, but if you've been reading the Supergirl comic books right now, you would know that she's like a fifteen year old girl, not that bright, and according to Lex Luthor has "less than impressive chest". I think if she can act she would do okay. But Supergirl is so much of an idiot, I think I'd end up disliking Taylor Swift as a result to seeing her do stupid thing from week to week.

However, I don't think they need to have a Supergirl show at least not right now. What for?
gorgeousgeeks - 12/23/2009, 3:09 PM
I know I'm late posting, but CBD - you're nuts if you think Taylor Swift is more talented than Christina Aguilera!!! And didn't Lady Gaga just have 4 #1's off of the same album? She's all over the radio!! C'mon man! Get serious!
JonF - 12/23/2009, 3:19 PM
I thought this was a joke.
KeepItReal - 1/1/2010, 11:40 PM
Everyone here is going for buxom blondes and not anyone who could play a 15 year old girl (actual age when Supergirl first appeared). Everyone will balk at this, but my thoughts go to Ellen Page (yea I know she's only 5' 1"), but she could probably pass as a fifteen year old (or close - she's actually 23) and she's got the acting chops to take the role seriously. She's also got a quality of morphing to look more like a kid and then when dolled up she looks quite nice.
ravforu - 3/17/2010, 1:35 AM

Please log in to post comments.

Don't have an account?
Please Register.