disagree about Maguire. I thought he did very well in SM 1 & 2.

you forgot Maggie Gyllenhaal as Rachel Dawes, Vinnie Jones as Juggernaut, Kirsten Dunst as Mary Jane Watson, Gwyneth Paltrow as Pepper Potts, Liv Tyler as Betty Ross, and Ryan Reynolds as Hal Jordan/Green Lantern.

Good writeup I totally agree with Tobey Maguire sucking ass as Peter Parker, and the completely lifeless Emma Frost character, I guess I agree with all your choices, just not the order they're put in

I can't say that I agree with this list. Maguire was fine as Spider Man even if the movies are not my favorite. and I thought Terrence Howard was great as Rhodey. He entered a financial dispute with Marvel for Iron Man 2 which is why Don Cheadle was cast as his replacement, not because Marvel thought Howard did a bad job.

Nobody Messes with the Cage...Nobody

If the director cant' the character right in the first place I wouldn't say it was a miscast. Doesn't matter who plays the character its wrong from the get-go.

Good call on most of them. I'm glad somebody finally had the cajones to call MacGuire out on Spider-Man.

I dont like the Raimi Spider-Man movies and I despise Toby as Spidey, im not saying it has to be 100% like the comics but even as a 8 year old I knew yeah..... this guy is a shitty Spider-Man and this is a boring and soul less movie series based on Spider-Man.

High Jackman awesome

Agree with most, but in some cases the writting for those movies wasso bad that not even meryl streep or daniel day lewis could have given a good performance..

you forgot ryan reynolds as hal jordan, deadpool, and hannibal king, kristen dunst as mj, bryce dallas as gwen, keanu reeves as john constantine, gyllenhall as reachel dawes, the mute windmaker and the flying stripper from first class (much worse than jones), shaquille o´neal as steel,kate bossworth as lois lane, malin akerman as silk spectre, josh brolin as jonah hex. vinnie jones as jugernnaut.. just to name a few.

maguire the worst? dont think so... not even close.

This list sucks, you're either really whiny or you realized that twenty-five choices were way to much maybe subtract ten or so choices and it would be more realistic. Plus, you seem to be more-so pointing out flaws in the way the character was written, than the way the character was portrayed.

Plus, Andrew Garfield sucked as Parker, why isn't he on this this rather than Maguire, who nailed the role.

At least Green Lantern is not in the List. because he was a awesome Hal Jordan. Great choice for GL. Haters gonna Hate.

@Brian Van Hooker Thank You for this article and Yes Tobey Maguire is the Worst In History.. He Killed the Image I had of him as a child growing up watching the 1994 cartoon.. Thank God for the Reboot.. And Please could we get you 25 Best

high jackman was the hugh point of the x-men movies.

Maguire worse than Schwarzenegger? yeah right.......

I agree with most of these. But Tobey being #1? Come on man! Yeah, he DID get really annoying, and I laugh sooo hard every time I see this:


But he certainly does not deserve the #1 spot. He did pretty well otherwise, and it's not like HE completely ruined the whole Raimi trilogy. Aside from some cheesiness in parts (like the dialog with him and Mary Jane), I still enjoy the first two Spiderman movies. The third one....well. That was awfull. And Tobey is to blame for a good part of that one. But, he himself wasnt a half-bad Spiderman/Peter Parker in the first two.

@RunDTC
I agree with all of those except Paltrow and Reynolds. Reynolds was NOT to blame for how terrible GL was. He was actually a pretty good Hal Jordan. And why is Paltrow even in your list man? She is a good Pepper, and I've liked her performance in all the Marvel movies she has been in. I honestly don't see anything wrong with her in the role.

But, yeah, Maggie Gylenhaal. Oh my word. I know Katie Holmes wasn't that great, but I would've SO much rather had her for TDK. I HATED Maggie in TDK. That casting choice honestly is one of the only things I despised about the movie. She was so annoying, and her face...ugggh.

Plus, her character's death would've made much more of an impact if it were Katie Holmes because we have already seen her and Bruce's connection.

I wouldn't put Taylor Kitsch and Val Kilmer in there. Kitsch was alright for the most of the part. He looks the role and I accepted that. Val Kilmer was my favorite Batman before Bale took over in Begins,so... yeah.