FAN CAST: Spider-Man: The Second Trilogy!

No long winded explanations-just who I think has the right look and acting skills for the following roles...

Follow Josh:
By Josh Wilding - 9/16/2009
Jake Gyllenhaal as Peter Parker/Spider-Man



Christina Hendricks as Mary Jane Watson



Bryce Dallas Howard as Gwen Stacy


Diora Baird as Felicia Hardy/Black Cat


J.K. Simmons as J. Jonah Jameson


Willem Defoe as Norman Osborn/The Green Goblin


Ben Foster as Max Dillon/Electro


Timothy Olyphant as Mac Gargan/The Scorpion


Ben Kingsley as Adrian Toomes/The Vulture


Bruce Campbell as Quentin Beck/Mysterio


Dylan Baker as Dr. Curt Conners/The Lizard


Josh Brolin as Sergei Kravinoff/Kraven the Hunter


Dominic Purcell as Eddie Brock/Venom


Robert Knepper as Carnage
Source: Josh Wilding
DISCLAIMER: This article was submitted by a volunteer contributor who has agreed to our code of conduct. ComicBookMovie.com is protected from liability under "safe harbor" provisions and will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. For expeditious removal, contact us HERE.
34
LIKE!
69 Comments
1 2
ThisFan - 6/13/2009, 4:14 PM
can i just say its scary how good this is
all those actors fit the roles you put for them so well and i would love if they recasted it like this
ElBicho - 6/13/2009, 4:57 PM
That's got to be at least 32 pounds of sweater meat.

Great cast choices too!
SupahPhreak - 6/13/2009, 8:18 PM
I don't like Robert Knepper as Carnage he seems too old =[. BUT CHRISTINA HENDRICKS IS FRIGGIN PERFECT. She Has to be a porn star.
SupahPhreak - 6/13/2009, 8:20 PM
Actually I just looked up Christina Hendricks..cause..yeah. It said she's thirty-nine years old. ..That sounds 20 years too old to be Mary-Jane. She really doesn't look it in these pictures but in other pictures she looks pretty old.
THEHAWK - 6/13/2009, 8:24 PM
Not bad, I like all of em except for Gyllenhal. Foster is a solid actor, but I'm not seeing Electro.

@NewAvengers. DO you have a problem with my castings? I put a lot of effort into my choices and explain them or give info for some of the lesser known characters/actors. A lot of people may not be familiar with the characters so I let thm know a little bit about them. I mean how many people on this page have heard of 'The Blue Snowman' but that was an important Wonder Woman villain, just not well known.

NightAvenger - 6/13/2009, 10:49 PM
@THEHAWK-no dude not at all,you are one of the best at casting,i just thought that joshw24 was making a joke to you,and i did not know who the blue snowman was either :]
you misunderstood me
THEHAWK - 6/13/2009, 11:30 PM
Thats cool man, sorry I went off on ya, it's been one hell of a bad week :( lol
LEEE777 - 6/14/2009, 3:43 AM
GOOD PICS JOSH Nice Article! ; )

Heyyyy how do you do bot pics together??? : /

<<<< LOST lol!

HEYYYYY thats my CARANGE pick!!! Damn great minds....
JoshWilding - 6/14/2009, 3:57 AM
SupahPhreak: she's 39!?!? I had no idea! I still think she could pull off MJ though-plus she is one of the hottest women I have EVER seen! (i knida wish she was a porn star!)

THEHAWK: i wasnt making a dig (check out my Avengers and Fantastic Four fan-casts to see how much i wrote there!) I just didnt feel like writing about each actor after it took me so long to find who I thought were the right choices, lol! I wasnt sure about Foster either but after seeing him in 30 Days of Night and 3:10 To Yuma playing two great villains I think there is definitely a role out there as a villain in some comic book movie for him! For now it gotta be Electro for me!

LEE: thanks, man! I just copy and paste the pics into 'Paint' and do my best to get them the same size so they line up, hehe!
dellamorte1872 - 6/14/2009, 7:51 AM
GERARD BUTLER FOR KRAVEN!
ElBicho - 6/14/2009, 8:07 AM
@ Everyone,

According to imdb and wikipedia she's only 34. But still, dammmmmmn fine!
JoshWilding - 6/14/2009, 9:34 AM
She's 1000x more beautiful than Kirsten Dunst, lol!

Diora Baird is also pretty damn perfect...and also perfect for Black Cat!!!
darkclaw - 6/14/2009, 10:59 AM
Jake is definatly a better pic then tobey macguire, I cant stand that guy. He's too much of a winey bitch.
FrankDrebin - 6/14/2009, 11:07 AM
how bout David Blaine as Mysterio? he does magic for real!!!!!!!!!!!!!! not
NightAvenger - 6/14/2009, 11:24 AM
@THEHAWK-i get what you mean.
LEEE777 - 6/14/2009, 1:05 PM
darkclaw @ He's the guy that was gonna take over the role for a while if TOBY wasn't up for SPIDEY 4! DONNIE DARKO is a masterpiece but JUGHEAD was cack lol!

Cheers JOSH @ If I knew how 2 copy an paste an know wtf paint was id try it myself lol! ; D

Still again, good work man! ; )
LEEE777 - 6/14/2009, 1:11 PM
Man, MYSTERIO an VULTURE are spot on! I thought them as well, SCORPION friggin good too! MJ oh yeahhh! Only one really i don't like is VENOM come onnnn, he's been DRAC in BLADE but that not the prob, i see him every week in PRISON BREAK darn it. good actor but i do see him as VENOM at all! Anyway VENOM got his own spin off! Well he'd better have now, now they said lol!
Damn JSH you have taste, MJ gal is mighty fine mmmm mmmm! ; )
THEHAWK - 6/14/2009, 1:18 PM
@Josh I like Ben he is a great actor, I just feel that Electro would be a waist of his talents, he has so much more potential. I could easily see him pull of an awesome Carnage, or even Ben Reily, now that would be awesome. I know he is supposed to be a clone, but i could seriously see Ben Foster as Ben Reily aka Scarlet Spider.

I lke the girl you picked for MJ, but isn't she like 40?
JoshWilding - 6/14/2009, 2:56 PM
THEHAWK: some people here have said she is but she is actually only 34 (though until i looked that up i would have guessed she was under 30) I dont think it would be a good idea for the Spidey films to head in the direction of the clone saga, lol! Still i could see him in the Scarlet Spider costume! However I find it much easier to imagine him in the classic Electro outfit-he's still my no.1 choice for Max Dillon!

LEE: I think it would be hard for a lot of people to accept Purcell especially now that he's forever associated as Dracula from that crap-fest Blade: Trinity, lol! Still despite this, Id like to see him either in Spidey or his own film as Venom! I think

Diora Baird is pretty damn fine as well-i doubt anyone realises (and I didnt until I looked her up on Wikipedia) that she played the green alien girl that Kirk hooks up with in Trek! Another interesting fact (which in my opinion is a BIG reason why she is perfect for Black Cat, hehe) is that(again according to Wikipedia) she is best known in Hollywood for having a 32DD bust! ;-0
Makiveli21 - 6/14/2009, 4:54 PM
right off the bat this is way better! as soon as i saw gyllenhall as parker i realized what i hated about the spiderman movies... TOBEY MAGUIRE SUCKS! he got way too caught up with the emo look and now spidey is a sniveling little pansy rather than the buttkicking smart mouth we all know and love. i wish we could burn every shred of evidence that maguire ever played spidey and just START OVER!
NightAvenger - 6/14/2009, 5:17 PM
let's not get carried away-he was good

(he had the emo look for 15 minutes in the 3rd one)
KEROSENE - 6/14/2009, 6:54 PM
perfect...nuff' said
Osiris - 6/14/2009, 7:00 PM
Awesome choices Josh, but with Raimi at the helm there will be no recasting sadly.
Osiris - 6/14/2009, 7:08 PM
also my choice for Blackcat

Image and video hosting by TinyPic
Shaman - 6/15/2009, 7:07 AM
You had me at the red head with the gigantic knockers, you had me at... the red head with the gigantic knockers *snif*, *tear* :P

JENSEN ACKLES FOR CAP!!!
Mankind - 6/15/2009, 8:56 AM
THIS WOULD BE FRINKIN AWESOME!!! good choices and i also agree with Shaman...

JENSEN ACKLES FOR CAP!!!!!!
ironknight27 - 6/15/2009, 10:13 AM
You also had me with the red head with the big knockers and you definitely had me with Diora. I remember hearin a while back Jake almost took over as Spidey because of a back injury that Tobey had. I remember saying NOOOO! But now I think he would be a better fit. I like Tobey though and I am glad he is continuing on as Spidey but if he wants to opt out, Jake would be a good replacement.
Urban8er - 6/15/2009, 11:52 AM
dude good job on finding this
it's scary on how good they resmble them
Shaman - 6/15/2009, 12:40 PM
Thanks Mankind :)) Need all the support we can get :P
TL - 6/15/2009, 5:43 PM
No to Jake brokeback. noto jake in the prince of persia also. Ben Kingsley is to old also. c'mon now.
Christina Hendricks as Mary Jane Watson ---PURE GENIUS!!!
why didnt they think of that b4 Dunst?!?! Big chest or not, gorgeous choice. FIREFLY fo Life!!!
everybody is a good choice as well. esp. Venom.
shoulda woulda coulda's....
NightAvenger - 6/16/2009, 10:48 AM
@TL-ben kingsley is almost 66 years old,vulture has been drawn/written from anywhere from 55-72 years old so...........
plus he was going to play him when vulture was in the sm3 script.

nuff said
Shaman - 6/16/2009, 12:53 PM
Oh he's a shoe in for that character.
billyhaup54 - 6/16/2009, 6:31 PM
great job with the casting ... but who for RHINO ?
... or HOBGOBLIN ... or even SHOCKER ... lets fill in all the blanks !!!
JoshWilding - 6/16/2009, 7:03 PM
billyhaup54: as shocker would probably only be a minor part and if he had the original type costume with a mask then pretty much anyone could play him, my choice for Venom, Dominic Purcell would make an ok Rhino if he wasnt Venom and as for Hobgoblin-I have no idea! But to be honest, the only Goblin I want to see in another Spidey film is the original...GREEN!!!
NightAvenger - 6/21/2009, 9:35 PM
why did you repost it....
ALmighty1080 - 6/23/2009, 3:34 AM
Peter Patralli as spiderman!!
riddlemethis09 - 7/2/2009, 10:02 PM
i definitely like the choice for venom...much better than the eric foreman chracter from that 70's show (Topher grace)...who names their kid topher anyways?
Swiftsword777 - 9/16/2009, 11:16 AM
Christina Hendricks IS NOT HOTT ENUFF
LEEE777 - 9/16/2009, 11:18 AM
WTF! DEJA VOO 2!!!

I should REPOST all of mine, you an HAWK luv doing it lol! ; D

JOSH @ Yeah i agree what you said in the SPIDEY article though dude!

GWEN should've been set up an killed ( by the GOBLIN, like the comics) in SPIDEY 1!!! Big mistake is right for the franchise! ; )

You got most of the picks that ive picked or like too buddy, though your SPIDEY is my second choice, but wasn't REAPER guy up there last time?

Im losing track lol, maybe not??

I like the actress but the MJ role is wrong for her!

But lovin the cast, an lets hope BRUCE CAMPBELL is that in SPIDEY 4! Fingers crossed.
Shaman - 9/16/2009, 11:19 AM
Wow, alot of reposting from everyone lately...
Frogman - 9/16/2009, 11:21 AM
if they recast the lead role and mary jane don't you think they'd recast everyone? It is a good cast list though
JoshWilding - 9/16/2009, 11:28 AM
LEE: I think I chose Harrison for Spider-Man in an editorial some time after I originally write this! I just thought id repost it with all the Spider-Man casting talk and as Ive pretty much cast the major Spider-Man charatcer I wasnt going to do another one, lol!

Frogman: maybe, but i liked those actors enough i wanted to keep them! Glad you like it though, thanks!
LEEE777 - 9/16/2009, 11:29 AM
SHAMAN @ Ive never reposted lol.

JOSH @ Yeah ya did, my bad! ; D
Shaman - 9/16/2009, 11:46 AM
Sorry LEEE LOL. Technically i should have said "from Josh, HAWK and Access (cause despite the character bios, it's exactly what he's doing)"
6of13 - 9/16/2009, 12:01 PM
I mentioned somewhere that I think Vincent Kartheiser would make a good Spiderman. I think he would be
quite convincing and could pull off the sarcasm.

Definte YES to Dominic Purcell. And Josh Brolin.

I have a different, somewhat CONTROVERSIAL choice for Kasady/Carnage.
I just think that just by the way he looks and his build, he can give us a terrifying, psychopathic and insane killer. And also, he has very much the opposite look to Purcell/Eddie/Venom.
My choice for Cletus Kasady/Carnage is DJ Qualls. Hate it if you must. I know DJ is somewhat skrawny, but I think that this characteristic will intensify the insane aspect of the character.
LEEE777 - 9/16/2009, 12:27 PM
SHAMAN @ Yeah, im kinda getting fed up being bumped further down all the time, im sure a lot of ppl are getting sick of it too, including yourself.

Alot of ppl do hard work then it gets bumped for old lol!

Though, for this article, i will make an exception, coz apart from SPIDEY an MJ i love the castings like most have done too, though SHAMAN @ I still like BUTLER much better as KRAVEN, even though he could turn out as CAP BRIT, i wouldn't mind him as KRAVEN too, first for me lol, wanting same actor in two MARVEL roles! ; D

P.S. But plz guys, no more REPOSTING its not fair on everyone else thats done alot of hard work on new articles! If your going to repost atleast update it like 25% min of new material!

JOSH @ Though again,. i do luv this article, so i wont moan this got reposted lol. But enough reposting everyone lol.

I bummed most didn't even get to see my MAX one! Halfway down the page in 3 hours!

Still sh!T happens lol.

P.s. anyone know whats wrong wiv OZy 2day???

InSpace - 9/16/2009, 1:03 PM
perfect casting
legder20 - 9/16/2009, 1:48 PM
I think Meagan Fox would do good as black cat, NOT CATWOMAN!!!!!!!!!!!!
Shaman - 9/16/2009, 2:01 PM
Good points LEEE ;)
JoshWilding - 9/16/2009, 2:07 PM
LEE: Then just repost yours!!! When I did my Captain Britain Fan Fic it got bumped down by about 6 articles so i reposted it and it was fine, lol! I posted this article back in June and there are a lot of new users here now so for veryone who has seen this im guessing there are two that havent! :)

Inspace: Thanks! :D
1 2

Please log in to post comments.

Don't have an account?
Please Register.

.