Why all the reboots?

Why all the reboots?

I'll explain why reboots generally need to be done, and then why some movie's just stand the test of time.

Editorial Opinion
By BatmanFan8383 - Mar 02, 2011 03:03 PM EST
Filed Under: Other
Source: ComicBookMovie.com

I wonder all the time, why there is such a huge uproar when it comes to reboots? However Hollywood is bad about "Starting Over" yes. But shouldn't we thank Hollywood in general for the "Do Overs"? Shouldn't there be a tiny bit of sympathy from the fan's of these movies? Shouldn't executives be applauded for there effort's to stick by the people? There is a ton of movie's out there that are just simply put bad. I will take ten franchises that need a Reboot, or have already been rebooted because it was needed. And then, ten that do not need a reboot as an opposite argument. "Warning"!!! These will not all be "Comic Book" related films so just a heads up.

1.Judge Dread (Does Need a reboot)

Now Why did I mention this film with only one movie? Well, there are several reason's for this simply put, Sylvester Stallone is the #1 reason why this movie should be rebooted. Id rather bet bitten by one thousand mice, then listen to Stallone do his Rocky voice for the Judge. I kept waiting for him to scream out ADRIAN!! Come on guys I know you know what I am talking about. Another large reason is the failure to keep to Comics. Which is where most Hollywood director's have been screwing going wrong. Is it getting to ugly for you yet? Oh trust me its about to get worse!! =/



2.The Shadow (Does Need a reboot)


I really would not be analyzing this film, if it were not for the constant reminder of the lack of "Origin" in it. Plus I would enjoy seeing a movie with Batman at least making a Cameo. Two very intellectually gifted men working together possibly on a case. Or the other way around seeing Shadow in a Batman movie. That's simply put my only problem with the last film, other than that I have zero problem with this movie's original make up.


3. Spiderman (Already being rebooted)


Unless you have lived under a rock you probably know about, the announced reboot of the Spiderman franchise. At least when it comes to "Sam Raimi's" version anyway. Now you are probably thinking, hey give good ole Sam credit for making at least 2 good films right? My problem is not with Sam Raimi it is the horrid writing that this movie produced. These idiots could not tell a decent story if there lives were at stake. Or maybe they could? But that's off the subject, Sam took the fall because directors always do. Fox hated the third film, and so did the fan's. So they left Sam without a job, and Toby McGuire and the rest of the staff bailed.


4. Tomb Raider (Possibly being rebooted)


Please God make this happen! I don't think I can list the multiple reasons why this movie should be redone. I like to call it "Born Again" an ability to totally abandon the past. Which is the direction this franchise should go, and everyone with a brain knows it.



5. Batman (Already rebooted)


Some may believe that this movie didn't need a remake. I totally disagree and not just because of Batman and Robin. Even Batman Returns was some what making fun of Batman. Not blatantly but in all our minds it was not really what you would call a "great" Batman film. Just seeing Danny Devito try so hard was kind of touching, in a really sickening sort of way. Penguin is one of those character's you can't make a mockery out of. Again another large case of bad writing in general in that movie.



6. Doom (Shouldn't have been made)

I will place this in the "Never should have been made" category. Everyone hates on the "Rock" as an actor. And they think that he was the sole reason why the movie failed. Are you kidding me? The movie should never even have been picked up or written out. The game itself should stand alone, mainly because if you are going to make a Doom movie. I believe it should be a first person viewpoint that will never be done.


7. Star War's (Not a reboot, more of a revamp)


Mhmmm I am going there haha!! Please George Lucas, I am begging you for a Force Unleashed trilogy, ounce a third game is made. Time for him to jump on that right off the bat. Am I right? Ya that's right I know I am!! =)



8. Ghost Busters


Ok, I will admit it; this really does not need a "Reboot" because they were not really bad movie's. However, how cool would it be with this year's tech alone to see something that spectacular? Come on guys you know I am onto something here admit it I am right again.


9. Dick Tracy (Needs to be Rebooted)


Frank Miller+David Goyer= Classic plainly and simply put



10. Game of Death (Reboot)

A classic Bruce Lee film that was unfinished hands down.




And now I will move onto the movie's that should be left alone and not rebooted.



1. The Goonies (Should not be rebooted)

This is for obvious reasons but mainly one specific one. Clearly it would be quiet difficult to recreate such chemistry. Such a magical film, and a true 80's cult creation. Everyone is surely aware that this film, stands alone as one of the Top five best over all films of all time.


2. Total Recall (Should not be rebooted)


Very good movie my favorite character, is played by Michael Ironside he is one of the detective's/Cops assigned to go after Quad. This role alone stands the test of time and in my "opinion" cannot be outdone. Plus the film was solidly written and the action sequences, really are the only thing that can be done better I feel.



3. Daredevil (Should not be rebooted)


A reboot is a new start, I believe Ben Affleck did just fine as Matt Murdock and Daredevil. My biggest problem issue with this film, is Kingpin he isn't Black as most people know. Get a large White dude, and make a sequel, and that franchise will be just fine.


4. The Big Lebowski (Should Not Be Rebooted)

Two words "Jeff Bridges" Instant classic and everyone knows it.



5. Back To The Future (Must not be Rebooted)


Must I even explain why?



6. The Breakfast Club (No Reboot)

It simply dealt with some of the most controversial subjects for teens. And it was casted so very well, you cannot deny that at all. And being in a Room in a school for the majority of the movie, and yet still able to keep the dialogue going well with the script, the way it was written just all of it. You can't do that again and that's all there is to it.


7. The Exorcist (No Reboot)

Scary as hell leave it alone!



8. Indiana Jones (No Reboot)

Harrison Ford's rendition should be left alone plain and simple.


9. Aliens



10. Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid


What do you think? And what is your list of do's and don't for reboots? Keep the conversation civil as always thanks guys.

Paramount Skydance Is Preparing A Bid To Purchase Warner Bros. Discovery (And DC Studios)
Related:

Paramount Skydance Is Preparing A Bid To Purchase Warner Bros. Discovery (And DC Studios)

HIGHLANDER Reboot Production Pushed To 2026 As Star Henry Cavill Suffers Training Injury
Recommended For You:

HIGHLANDER Reboot Production Pushed To 2026 As Star Henry Cavill Suffers Training Injury

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

WeekendAvenger
WeekendAvenger - 3/2/2011, 4:35 PM
i mean spidey def. needs a reboot tobey sucked
Ironbat95
Ironbat95 - 3/2/2011, 5:27 PM
sony made spidey not fox. great article though
RyanLantern77
RyanLantern77 - 3/2/2011, 5:28 PM
This editorial lost all credibility when you said that Ben Affleck did fine as Daredevil. He butchered that role and Michael Clarke Duncan actually did his best as Kingpin, hating the movie because he is black is just ignorant. Asking for a sequel is the most retarded thing I have ever heard. Ben Affleck is now best known as a great director and an actor that is back on the rise. He would never reprise his role as Daredevil, it would bring up reminders of how crappy the first movie was.
ironpool007
ironpool007 - 3/2/2011, 6:12 PM
I would take a Daredevil reboot. Ben Affleck was good when he was in costume as Daredevil but when he was just Matt Murdock, his performance came off as forced. Reboot with, Bradely Cooper, Aaron Eckhardt, or Ethan Hawke as Matt Murdock with Michael Mann directing with a script from Frank Miller(and maybe miller could co-direct it too). This would would work as either a movie or a tv show.
Checkmate
Checkmate - 3/2/2011, 7:49 PM
Easy.
Don't reboot classics.
Movies based on other properties that were horribly created need to be rebooted, I'm looking at you Daredevil. And Batman's next on my list.
RyanLantern77
RyanLantern77 - 3/2/2011, 9:25 PM
Thanks BatmanFan. The truth is, we all win when the CBM are good. I am a huge Deadpool fan too, but at this point i think they should just move on to another actor (even though I think reynolds is perfect for it), but with Green Lantern already having a sequel being written, I just don't see Reynolds making time for the Merc with a Mouth. After reading that Deadpool leaked script I want that movie made A.S.A.P.!!
Havok89
Havok89 - 3/2/2011, 11:04 PM
DAREDEVIL must be rebooted!

Get David Fincher to direct and we will get gold on par with The Dark Knight and Heat.
LEEE777
LEEE777 - 3/3/2011, 2:01 AM
ROBOCOP and THE CROW - MUST NOT BE REMADE!

Oh dude, what's FOX got to do with the Spider-amn franchise?!? : /

Talking FOX.... Only franchise that needs to be rebooted is actually the horrible X-MEN one, f'ing sucks lol!

DD was okay, but that was about it!
LP4
LP4 - 3/3/2011, 2:14 AM
@LEEE777- Agreed! I don't get why everyone has to hate on the Daredevil film. The action was great and top-notch, the villains- Kingpin and Bullseye had AWESOME portrayals and the music was top-notch. I don't see what else anyone could have asked for.

As for Ben Affleck, I still say that dude did an ok job as DD. At least he acted the part. Yeah he seemed a bit goofy because we ALL knew it was Ben Affleck but I mean he still acted the part well.

If we're going to go into shitty portrayals, I'd say Routh's Superman from Superman Returns was worse. The guy didn't even do any real acting in the film...barely said a word. At least Ben Affleck ACTED in his film and at least he conveyed a wide range of emotions.

Superman was one franchise that desperately needed a reboot and thank god it's getting a proper one for a change.

marvel72
marvel72 - 3/3/2011, 3:21 AM
reboots that are needed.

-ghost rider
-the x-men
-wolverine origin
-daredevil
-fantastic four

Caedus137
Caedus137 - 3/3/2011, 3:42 AM
I quite liked Doom...
Caedus137
Caedus137 - 3/3/2011, 3:43 AM
...or maybe it was just Rosamund Pike...
CraptainAmerica
CraptainAmerica - 3/3/2011, 4:11 PM
What a great article!...until I read that Daredevil should only be revolted if they find a large White guy to play Kingpin! I mean, that was nowhere near it's worst failing! Clarke Duncan was actually a highlight. The script, direction and overuse of extra mature cheese were its shortcomings...amongst a few. That should go in the "should be rebooted" section as there is one hell of a franchise to be made from it
Moakynubs
Moakynubs - 3/3/2011, 4:34 PM
Uh. Okay.
RyanLantern77
RyanLantern77 - 3/4/2011, 6:10 AM
@Craptain- Totally agree. I didn't have a problem with Clarke Duncan playing Kingpin, his performance was really good, but the movie was just beyond saving
HUSoldier
HUSoldier - 3/5/2011, 10:20 PM
really? you didnt think that daredevil didnt need a reboot? I agree on most of those but come on, daredevil was bad. I am pretty upset about the goonies getting a reboot since I love that movie but if you think about it many reboots will open the movies to a whole new generation. I think it is too early for goonies but with a movie like total recall, just think about the great special effects they can put into a reboot. I think they need to make sure that they take care with their reboots and make sure the fans are not going to flip out like what would happen if they redid back to the future. i think they need to just go with the sequel idea instead and just continue stories instead of starting over.
View Recorder