TDKR: Bane Co-Creator Chuck Dixon Discusses Tom Hardy's Portrayal Of The Character

In an interview with Philly.com, Bane co-creator Chuck Dixon discusses what he thought of Tom Hardy's portrayal of the villain in The Dark Knight Rises. Hit the jump to check it out!

Follow TheSkywalkingKnight:
By TheSkywalkingKnight - 7/24/2012


In an interview with Philly.com, Co-Creator of Bane Chuck Dixon discusses the creation of the character and his different incarnations in the media, including Wrestler Robert Swenson's performance in Batman and Robin (stating that in that film,the character was an "imbecile"). He also talks about what he thought of actor Tom Hardy's portrayal of the character in The Dark Knight Rises.

"Apparently, Warner Bros. was pressuring Nolan to use the Riddler, which would have been too similar to the Joker," Dixon continued. "Plus, the Riddler, like the Joker and so many of Batman's villains, is no challenge against him in a mano-a-mano fistfight. Batman will wipe the floor with him in that situation.

I am beyond glad that Nolan had the juice in Hollywood to stick to his guns," he added. "From interviews I've seen, it's clear he understands the character and he gets what we were going for. It's not exactly what I created, but he's physically imposing and Tom Hardy is one hell of an actor. I can't imagine Bane being better portrayed."


You can read the full interview with Dixon by clicking HERE!






Source: Philly.com
DISCLAIMER: This article was submitted by a volunteer contributor who has agreed to our code of conduct. ComicBookMovie.com is protected from liability under "safe harbor" provisions and will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. For expeditious removal, contact us HERE.
5
LIKE!
97 Comments
1 2
Wildaniel - 7/24/2012, 11:12 AM
I still dont know if Bane died. Im guessing he did when Selina blasted him with the batpod.
IronDean2099 - 7/24/2012, 11:17 AM
Worst final battle ever. Even Elektra had a better fight at the end.
Frogman - 7/24/2012, 11:21 AM
"Worst final battle ever?" Have you seen Captain America: The First Avenger? or Iron Man? or Iron Man 2? or Thor? They were no better. Ok before Whiplash arrived Iron Man 2 was pretty good then Whiplash comes and it's over in seconds.
DragonofDarknessXIII - 7/24/2012, 11:32 AM
If Joker couldn't stab Bane, then Catwoman should had.
sansClaymore - 7/24/2012, 11:43 AM
vader!best bane ever
SpiderFan35 - 7/24/2012, 12:00 PM
Good for straight up fights with Batman? Yes

Physically imposing? Yes.

One hell of an actor? Okay, but when your face is 75% covered and your voice sounds like it is coming from a megaphone off camera, is that good acting? I don't know about that.
dahamma - 7/24/2012, 12:00 PM
@Vegakingblade, man if that joker cameo you mentioned would've happened. I would have shat my pants so hard. that woulda been so freaking awesome. I just got excited reading that lol
Frogman - 7/24/2012, 12:01 PM
@Vekakingblade: firstly I'm not a DC or a Marvel, read my profile or ask about my DVD collection if you don't believe me. I like both equally because I'm a comic book movie fan as well as comic fan, I even like Elektra, Fantastic Four and Green Lantern. Secondly, as BizarroNumber1 said I was pointing out that those final endings weren't any better. Plus IronDean2099 mentioned Elektra, last time I checked that was Marvel. I'm not trying to start the war because I think it's stupid and pathetic, I was merely pointing out that there are far worse or equally as bad final battles.
MrRogers - 7/24/2012, 12:05 PM
We could bring up superman and Kumar kicking his ass or green lantern and that shit storm of and ending. Bane was badass but killing him like that Idk it was extremely anti climactic. I new he had to die but cat women blasting him and saying a cheesy 1 liner was dumb. Bane deserved a better death but it didnt ruin the movie for me I still enjoyed the film.
MJPETTY7 - 7/24/2012, 12:07 PM
I don't think Bane died from that blast. Severely injured perhaps, but I don't think he died. Sure the Bat-Pod has enough firepower to it to do that, but Selina had to blast through the wall first in order to get Bane, so IMO, she did both at once, therefore allowing the wall to take most of the heat, but giving Bane enough to send him flying. Anyway, that's just my opinion.

On the topic of it being the "worst final battle ever", it wasn't all I had hoped for or wanted between them, but it was enough for me to be a little satisfied. Could have been more Batman beating Bane though.
AsianVersionOfET - 7/24/2012, 12:07 PM
The first fight between Bane and Batman will be remembered forever.
OdinsBeard - 7/24/2012, 12:08 PM
wildaniel@ it's hard to show a death like that in a PG-13 movie. same went for dark knight. my money is he is dead. but i see where you're coming from.

Bane was awesome!!
Bumble - 7/24/2012, 12:09 PM
@Bizzaro Did you pay attention to the movie? Did you not listen to the doctor's assessment of bruce's injuries? no cartilage in his knees and elbows, scar tissue on his organs, etc? There's your answer on why he was in such bad shape after eight years, those kind of injuries don't just heal; you can't regrow cartilage, trust me, i know from experience.

Now, with that being said, i think Tom hardy's Bane was very good. Was it an exact copy of the character from the comics? No. But it was a true enough interpretation of the character on film. And anyone who says, "where's the venom?" is a mark to actually think that a movie trilogy based on a realistic interpretation of the characters was going to have venom in it.
MJPETTY7 - 7/24/2012, 12:10 PM
@NinjaJesus Batman & Robin's Bane had only two similarities to the comics. The costume and the VENOM. Nolan's Bane had the comics Bane's criminal mind, the organization, the fighting skills, the fearlessness, and the ruthlessness. Plus, him breaking Batman's back there was straight out of Knightfall.
MJPETTY7 - 7/24/2012, 12:11 PM
@Bumble Also, he had gas pumped into his body for the pain. A direct reference to VENOM.
UncleJimmy - 7/24/2012, 12:13 PM
if he badmouths Bane he will never work for DC again.
its pandering for public relations
Bumble - 7/24/2012, 12:14 PM
@Petty I'll give you that. I was referring to the people who wanted it to be some body bloating, super steroid. I totall got that refernce to it being a steroid of some sort that allowed him to live and deal with the pain from his injuries.
95 - 7/24/2012, 12:16 PM
Bane was brutal, and big. Tom Hardy did better than expected. That showdown in the sewers was one of the best "hero-versus-villain" confrontations on screen. So iconic, very close to Knightfall. He was a powerful presence.
nikgrid - 7/24/2012, 12:19 PM
@Vegakingblade - I think Arkham would be unaffected because the narrows is over one of the blown up bridges.
Tony93 - 7/24/2012, 12:20 PM
Bane died in a stupid way
I was expecting much more from Nolan..
Every other movies ending was tolerable since the overall product was somewhat mediocre..
But c'mon this is CHRIS NOLAN
He could have gave us a Better battle fight...
DarthBob - 7/24/2012, 12:24 PM
"The first fight between Bane and Batman will be remembered forever." Already forgot about it until you brought it up. Both fights were lame; sorry not buying the "imposing" Bane as portrayed by a 5'9" actor. No venom then Bane somehow is able to punch through a concrete pillar. Downright stupid!
AgentDelta - 7/24/2012, 12:25 PM
@BizzaroNumber1 It's funny how you corrected someone for saying 'except' instead of 'accept' and then you say 'your' instead of 'you're' lol
OdinsBeard - 7/24/2012, 12:25 PM
it's my opinion that people should sort of change their expectations sometimes when it comes to a final fight scene. for instance in IM2 the "fight" with whiplash should just be looked at as part of the entire climax/fight. i would argue that as soon as the drones starting flying that's when the fight began. the drones were deployed by whiplash. so in my mind he was fighting whiplash that whole time. when he came in at the end that was just icing on the cake. would i have done different? probably. was i happy and satisfied with what i saw? of course!

as for the second fight scene with Batman and Bane. what do you want? MORE punching? after we already had them fight once? again, thats just a small piece of a giant, action-packed climax that included car chases and air battles. and for those saying batman didn't even beat bane, catwoman did. story-wise batman DID beat him. he had him dead to rights. then the twist came in the form of Talia! he was better than bane, he did beat bane. but the patient knife was waiting for him. Banes death scene was more about catwoman's redemption.

instead of saying "this would have been better" ask yourself why the director decided to do what he did. why am i being shown this as part of a visual story? Nolan is a smart guy, if you think he went wrong somewhere that's cool! everyone has their opinion. but i didn't make the batman movie. Nolan did. and any "mistakes" you think were made might have a deeper meaning to them.

I'm sure im going to get fried for "telling people how to watch movies." but thats just my two cents. i loved the final scenes in TDKR.
FilmsFan - 7/24/2012, 12:27 PM
SPOILERS::..



I don't know why people are confused with BANE's death (or not)!

She blasted a ton of cars away in that tunnel & then BANE!
What makes anyone think he'll be alive!!
It would Atleast have burned all his anisteics etc!

HE DIED! No more argument!
worldbreaker - 7/24/2012, 12:28 PM
does no one remember that some of nolan enthusiasts were HAPPY about bane being small? and they did make bane seem much bigger in the movie, which i like. but its odd that the people who were wanting bane to be small were also happy about him being big. the people who love everything about it just because its nolan make the rational people that enjoy it for what it is look bad
BackwardGalaxy - 7/24/2012, 12:28 PM
I liked Bane and I don't feel his story was undercut as much as others have suggested by the Talia reveal. Still, I'm very much disappointed that we'll never see the intended third movie in this trilogy because Heath Ledger died. We can't even say that Nolan has it in his head and could tell us about it from what we know of his creative process.
HavocPrime - 7/24/2012, 12:29 PM
I liked this interpretation of Bane, he was ruthless, brutal, and seemed nearly unstoppable.

Until of course that moment when it turns out he did Talia's bidding, everything that he was built up to be just crumbled into dust, to think I believed he had destroyed the Henchmen Bane from Batman and Robin.
shadearts - 7/24/2012, 12:31 PM
BINO Jr cause he was so damn short
DrainBamage - 7/24/2012, 12:32 PM
I have to admit, I initially thought the casting was all wrong. Hardy, while pretty yoked, is no where near Bane's size. And Hathaway...what has she done to make me think she could pull off Catwoman? Now, I think Hardy did a great job as Bane. I even enjoyed Hathaway's Catwoman.

What I found interesting was how different they are from their comic book counterparts. It's like my kids say, they're those characters, but not really.

Just my opinion, but it's like Bane and Catwoman, in name only. I don't think anyone even called her Catwoman. And her 'ears' were just her goggles sitting on top of her head. And while they did use some elements of Bane's story in the movie, most of it wasn't.

Nonetheless, still loved it. I'll definitely make room for on my home video shelf.
KidZombie - 7/24/2012, 12:34 PM
ya he for sure died. He was wearing that metal looking body armor on his chest but I still would say he died. I just wish talia didn't die. That means no damian! Well they are rebooting anyways but still ha ha.

@BizzaroNumber1: 'What DC movies are there to bring up?"
ha ha i like how you act like Dc has never made a bad movie. Other then Nolans Bat trilogy and superman 1 and 2, what movie was good? Not trying to start shit, just saying. green lantern, Batman returns, Batman and robin batman forever, superman returns, STEEL, CATWOMAN, jonah hex, return of swamp thing, all terrible movies. Some would add watchman to this list, but i liked it ha ha Just be happy that justice league movie starring arnie hammer as batman never got made.
So yes DC has its faults, and majority of those flicks had bad final fights. I for one liked dark knights final battle. Ya Bane went out poorly, but they had a city to save. plus the sewer fight was epic, so that makes up for it ha.
Again not trying to start shit, just wanted to point out the obvious to someone who clearly was trying to.

KeyserSoze44 - 7/24/2012, 12:34 PM
Bane was perfect and he didnt look small(looked huge),lifting batman off the ground one handed choking him. Also watch the last fight when banes mask starts to break he goes rapid,punches through the pillar
RunawaysHD - 7/24/2012, 12:34 PM
Bane was a threat! lol

I didn't like the way he died (did he? Looked weak)
The first fight was legendary!
He was a genius lol

Did anyone feel sorry for him? When Talia was talking about them in the Pit? His face looked like he was upset and about to cry lol..
fedup - 7/24/2012, 12:35 PM
I personally thought the final fight was great. Batman bests Bane in combat. That was what mattered. Outside intervention from Talia put Bane in position to kill him and outside intervention from Selina put a stop to it. Was kind of full circle for me. But that's just my opinion.
worldbreaker - 7/24/2012, 12:35 PM
and the fights were completely forgettable. they seemed like it was just made on the fly with no choreography. and fight being shorter and longer shouldn't really affect its quality if it's done right. hulk didn't take long with loki and that was beautiful
sbdc1939 - 7/24/2012, 12:38 PM
The final battle was awesome batman thrashed bane the second time after getting himself ready to fight him again beating the crap out him... WHERES THE DETONATOR!!!! I loved that sh*t!!!!!!
Fxrank - 7/24/2012, 12:38 PM
Riddler would have been the best choice, I mean after all batman comics are detective, mystery, thillers.
Adiel - 7/24/2012, 12:40 PM
How many years does this trilogy span? How old is Bruce at the end of TDKR?
Bumble - 7/24/2012, 12:41 PM
@ bizzaro First all, all thefighting and the falls that you see him take in the frst two movies put him in that shape. He was living a very extreme lifestlye. This a't football or MMA he was doing. This was life and death fighting. This was being yanked out of a building by a steel cable, this is being attacked by dogs and grown men, etc. Do you not remember the massive whelps and bruises he had during batman begins? You go and try to live the life that he lead duringthe time span of batman begins to the dark kght and see what happens to you. tack on that seven years prior where he was trolling the world and being trained by the league of shadows. tht's enough to break down even the best man.
And yeh, I've heard of knee repacement surgery and for your information, it's not like a brand new knee; it's limiting, it's man made. you probably have half the mobility that a normal knee does and in nowy would a replacement knee be able to hold up to the strain he would put it under. plus the rehab time would've been too long for a man of bruce's character to stay out of the fight.
worldbreaker - 7/24/2012, 12:41 PM
Uncliche- your relentless love for tom hardy is hilarious. i hope it's a joke, or else it really doesnt make sense to use the word "gay" as an insult to loki/hiddleston
NotU - 7/24/2012, 12:45 PM
let's face it Bane was overshadowed by Selina Kyle in this film. I did enjoy the Nolan version of Bane better than the comic Bane for some reason, but after he boiled down to nothing more than a strong-man henchman for Talia, all the air flew out of the Bane-balloon.

everyone kept saying how 'brutal' he was. I didn't see it.

A Riddler/Bats match up would've been great if it was done so that the Riddler was always out of reach. constantly baiting Bats into Saw-like traps that he had to get out of.

A Deadshot match-up would've been great. The World's greatest assasin vs. The world's greatest detective. The man who kills for a living vs. the man who will not kill.

in fact if the Riddler had been the primary and pitted Bats and Deadshot against each other it would've been really something.

what happen to the Russian arms-dealer Cobblepot? yet another idea passed over.


I really enjoyed the film, but unfortunately for this life-long Bats fan, the swirling ideas and suggestions with other characters from the rogue gallery would've provided Nolan more wiggle-room to insert his own story. The Bane conclusion wrote itself into a corner complete with the only thing Bane does 'break Bat's back'
lame.lame.lame. and then Nolan was subject to explaining shorthand in a condensed amount of time the recovery of Wayne.

A great movie, but everything was so rushed.

BB: A
TDK: A+
TDKR: A-

Trilogy: A
LAWLZY96 - 7/24/2012, 12:48 PM
@Adiel I've been wondering that myself. In Batman Begins we see Bruce on his 30th birthday towards the end. We can assume that Dark Knight happens almost directly after BB since Wayne Manor is still being rebuilt and Batman is still using the same suit. But its clear that some time has passed since criminals are now generally fearful of Batman, also Joker has been up to at least some shenanigans since BB. At most two years have passed between BB and TDK, so Bruce is, at most, 40 in Rises.

At least thats the conclusion I came too, but I'm not sure on how much time passed between BB and TDK.
Name - 7/24/2012, 12:51 PM
I'd like to know how bane went super saiyan and punched chunks out of concrete if there wasnt any venom?
Bumble - 7/24/2012, 12:52 PM
Bizzaro: Nice of you to pull the "articulation" line to get yourself out of losing an argument. You have a nice day as well :-)
brokeBatman - 7/24/2012, 12:54 PM
Honestly I loved TDKR, But TDK had the best villain of all time the Joker, played surprisingly well and twisted by Heath Ledger. So that being said I loved Bane in his fear inducing presence and the fact that physically he was stronger. The first fight Between Batman and Bane I thought was good but could've been better (more Bat kicks and jumps of course)lol. What I did love was his lil monologue about the darkness being his ally during the fight which made it really fun to watch. The last fight scene Was good, and I like the reference to "Bataranging" the venom tube in the animated series, when he hit his mouth piece with his gauntlets, making him immediately "weak". But wait when I say Good I mean good enough because Batman was winning Because he "ROSE" out of that hole and got all crazy on him. Im also ok with Bane being defeated like that by Catwoman because at that very moment he was revealed as not being the main villain only to find that Talia was pulling all the strings anyway. Overall I believe it was a fine Batman film done Nolans way I guess. Although I can almost shed a tear when I think about how incredibly awesome it would have been to see Joker escape Jail and somehow do some crazy stuff in this lil Gotham War plot. Man, one can only Imagine;) Great trilogy! -my two cents.
ATOMbomb - 7/24/2012, 12:55 PM
Tom Hardy did an incredible job! He made the film, the breaking bat scene was incredible. What he did with his eyes really pulled you in. His attitude poured through the screen I've never had that feeling from a villain before. You knew every time Batman screwed with Bane you he was gonna [frick]ing kick his ass! I can't wait too see the movie again.
kirynthemighty - 7/24/2012, 12:55 PM
@Uncliche omg I have gone on so many of these posts and just reading what people say, but for the love of god man will you pull Nolans d&%k out of your mouth man! All of your comments are ...Nolans the best, Nolan is the best director ever, hes amazing, Batmans > avengers and every other movie ever created. STFU dude we get it!! If you have some intelligent comment post, otherwise STFU already!
sinchsw - 7/24/2012, 12:55 PM
I would argue that Thor's end battle was worse than Batman's.
Bumble - 7/24/2012, 12:56 PM
@ name: I was wondering that myself. Out of that whole movie, that was the one instance I was like, "what the?" I bet that was the one condition that he gave into wb on, "no, no riddler for you. but i'll let you have input on one frame." you know just so they felt "in conrol."
Name - 7/24/2012, 12:57 PM
what is uncliche talkign about how would the fights in avengers work without cgi. Whats wrong with a badass fight between thor and hulk on a massive airbourne ship?
Name - 7/24/2012, 1:00 PM
im ready to watch a batman film where i dont question why banes able to demolish concrete. I think its time.
1 2

Please log in to post comments.

Don't have an account?
Please Register.

.